Software Alternatives, Accelerators & Startups

AWS CodeCommit VS GitHub Desktop

Compare AWS CodeCommit VS GitHub Desktop and see what are their differences

AWS CodeCommit logo AWS CodeCommit

AWS CodeCommit is a fully-managed source control service that makes it easy for companies to host secure private Git repositories.

GitHub Desktop logo GitHub Desktop

GitHub Desktop is a seamless way to contribute to projects on GitHub and GitHub Enterprise.
  • AWS CodeCommit Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-04-22
  • GitHub Desktop Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-05-02

AWS CodeCommit features and specs

  • Scalability
    AWS CodeCommit scales automatically, so it can handle projects of all sizes without any need for manual intervention.
  • High Availability
    The service is hosted on AWS, which offers high availability and durability thanks to its reliable infrastructure.
  • Security
    AWS CodeCommit integrates with AWS Identity and Access Management (IAM), providing fine-grained access control and encryption capabilities.
  • Cost Efficiency
    For small teams, CodeCommit is cost-effective as it doesn't charge for the first 5 active users per month.
  • Integration
    Seamlessly integrates with other AWS services like CodePipeline, CodeBuild, and CodeDeploy, promoting a streamlined CI/CD pipeline.
  • Fully Managed
    Because AWS CodeCommit is a fully managed service, you don't need to worry about maintaining a version control server yourself.

Possible disadvantages of AWS CodeCommit

  • Learning Curve
    New users, especially those not familiar with AWS, might face a steep learning curve due to the complexity of AWS services.
  • Limited Ecosystem
    Compared to more mature platforms like GitHub or GitLab, the ecosystem around AWS CodeCommit is relatively limited in terms of third-party integrations and extensions.
  • User Interface
    The web interface of CodeCommit is not as user-friendly or feature-rich as competitors like GitHub or Bitbucket.
  • Regional Availability
    While AWS CodeCommit is available in many AWS regions, it might not be available in all regions, limiting its use for some global teams.
  • Storage Limitations
    Though generally adequate for standard use cases, larger teams or heavily data-driven projects may find the repository storage limitations to be a constraint.

GitHub Desktop features and specs

  • User-Friendly Interface
    GitHub Desktop offers a clean, intuitive GUI that simplifies the Git process, making it accessible for beginners and less technical users.
  • Seamless GitHub Integration
    The application is tightly integrated with GitHub, allowing users to easily clone repositories, create branches, and submit pull requests directly through the desktop interface.
  • Cross-Platform Support
    GitHub Desktop is available on both Windows and macOS, offering a consistent experience across these major operating systems.
  • Simplifies Workflow
    Features like drag-and-drop to add files, visual diff tools, and easy branching help streamline the workflow for users.
  • Collaborative Features
    The app provides useful collaborative tools such as reviewing changes, creating requests, and viewing history, enhancing team productivity.

Possible disadvantages of GitHub Desktop

  • Limited Advanced Features
    While GitHub Desktop is great for basic tasks, it lacks advanced features found in other Git clients like GitKraken or the command line.
  • Dependency on GitHub
    The app is deeply integrated with GitHub, which can be limiting for users who want to interact with repositories hosted on other platforms like GitLab or Bitbucket.
  • Performance Issues
    Some users report performance issues when dealing with large repositories or a significant number of files, which can hinder productivity.
  • Customization Limitations
    GitHub Desktop offers limited customization options compared to other Git clients or the command line, which may be a drawback for power users.
  • Offline Limitations
    Certain features of GitHub Desktop require an internet connection to interact with GitHub, limiting its usability in offline scenarios.

AWS CodeCommit videos

AWS Codecommit Hands On

More videos:

  • Review - Introduction to AWS CodeCommit
  • Review - Introduction to AWS CodeCommit: Setting Up Permissions

GitHub Desktop videos

GitHub Desktop 2.0 -- Easy Mode Version Control

More videos:

  • Review - GitHub Desktop Quick Intro For Windows
  • Tutorial - Git and GitHub for Beginners: GitHub basics, and how to use GitHub Desktop

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to AWS CodeCommit and GitHub Desktop)
Git
15 15%
85% 85
Code Collaboration
13 13%
87% 87
Git Tools
10 10%
90% 90
Continuous Integration
100 100%
0% 0

User comments

Share your experience with using AWS CodeCommit and GitHub Desktop. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

Reviews

These are some of the external sources and on-site user reviews we've used to compare AWS CodeCommit and GitHub Desktop

AWS CodeCommit Reviews

The Top 10 GitHub Alternatives
AWS CodeCommit eliminates the need for hosting, maintaining, backing up, and scaling your source control servers. It also allows you to customise access for each user to your repositories, with automatically encrypted files in transit. Additionally, it keeps your repositories highly available and accessible with a scalable, redundant, and durable architecture.
Top 7 GitHub Alternatives You Should Know (2024)
AWS CodeCommit is a fully managed source control service provided by Amazon Web Services (AWS) to host secure, scalable, and private Git repositories.
Source: snappify.com

GitHub Desktop Reviews

Best Git GUI Clients of 2022: All Platforms Included
Creating branches and switching to existing ones isn’t a hassle, so is merging code with the master branch. Furthermore, you can track your changes with GitHub Desktop. Check out our detailed guide on how to use GitHub for more detailed information.
Boost Development Productivity With These 14 Git Clients for Windows and Mac
GitHub Desktop is the global standard for working with Git-related tasks in a graphical user interface (GUI). It is an open-source tool and hence completely free to use for all sorts of projects. It is available for both Windows and macOS desktops and laptops.
Source: geekflare.com
Best Git GUI Clients for Windows
GitHub Desktop is, perhaps, the most famous solution for working with Git in a visual interface. It is familiar to all developers keeping their repositories on GitHub (Git repository hosting service used for version-controlling IT projects). This free Git GUI is open-source, transparent, and functional. When you consider the Git graphical interface for Windows, GitHub...
Source: blog.devart.com

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, GitHub Desktop should be more popular than AWS CodeCommit. It has been mentiond 135 times since March 2021. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

AWS CodeCommit mentions (22)

View more

GitHub Desktop mentions (135)

  • How to Fix the Issue of Not Being Able to View Your GitHub Account on Other Devices
    Download the latest version from the GitHub Desktop website. - Source: dev.to / 5 months ago
  • 12 Steps to Organize and Maintain Your Python Codebase for Beginners
    I’m not going to dive into Git commands here — you can find plenty of tutorials online. If you’re not a fan of using the plain terminal CLI, you can also manage repositories with tools like GitHub Desktop or SourceTree, which provide a more visual, intuitive interface. - Source: dev.to / 6 months ago
  • File Governance and Versioning in Corticon BRMS
    Using terminal commands isn’t necessary for basic adoption of Git with Corticon Studio files, though. There are various tools that will allow us to bypass the command line when defining rules, including the built-in Eclipse plugin for Git version control. If you’ll be storing your assets on GitHub, though, an even easier solution is GitHub Desktop, a free desktop software that GitHub offers. It can be used in... - Source: dev.to / 7 months ago
  • An Introduction to Nix for Ruby Developers
    Nix currently is akin to git's "porcelain": powerful but esoteric. However, much like git evolved into exoteric, user-friendly tools such as git-flow, GitHub Desktop, and Tower to become user-friendly, many developers are building abstractions, wrappers, and utilities to simplify Nix usage. Let's briefly look at a few of these tools now. - Source: dev.to / 9 months ago
  • Make your first contribution on github easily
    1.Download the github desktop. 2.Open the first contribution repository. 3.Open the github app and clone the repository. - Source: dev.to / 11 months ago
View more

What are some alternatives?

When comparing AWS CodeCommit and GitHub Desktop, you can also consider the following products

Git - Git is a free and open source version control system designed to handle everything from small to very large projects with speed and efficiency. It is easy to learn and lightweight with lighting fast performance that outclasses competitors.

GitKraken - The intuitive, fast, and beautiful cross-platform Git client.

Atlassian Bitbucket Server - Atlassian Bitbucket Server is a scalable collaborative Git solution.

SourceTree - Mac and Windows client for Mercurial and Git.

Mercurial SCM - Mercurial is a free, distributed source control management tool.

SmartGit - SmartGit is a front-end for the distributed version control system Git and runs on Windows, Mac OS...