TinyURL VS Postproxy

TinyURL's answer

TinyURL has been running continuously since January 2002, which makes it the first notable URL shortening service and one of the oldest still operating. For a link shortener that longevity is the product, not trivia: a short link is only useful for as long as it still resolves, and links created here don't expire.

Three things set it apart day to day:

• Human and bot clicks are reported separately. Most shorteners report raw click totals that quietly include crawlers and link-preview bots, so reported traffic reads higher than the real audience. Separating them means the numbers can be trusted for attribution.
• Destinations stay editable after a link is published. A link already printed on packaging or posted to social can be repointed without reissuing it.
• A permanent free tier, not a trial - 30 links a month, one branded domain, links that never expire.

Postproxy's answer:

Postproxy combines production-grade publishing infrastructure, engagement, and analytics in one social media API. Every publishing request has an explicit status and human-readable failure reason, failed deliveries can be retried automatically, and the same platform also handles comments, direct messages, reviews, profile analytics, and webhooks.

Postproxy uses official platform APIs and OAuth flows, supports isolated profile groups for multi-tenant products, and provides integrations for n8n, Make, and Zapier, as well as an MCP server for AI agents.

TinyURL's answer

Three practical reasons, depending on what you need:

• You want attribution you can trust. Analytics cover clicks over time, referrer, geography, device, OS, browser and language, retained for two years, with bot traffic separated out.
• You want your own brand on the link. Bring your own domain or subdomain on any plan, with up to three branded domains on paid tiers.
• You want links that outlive the campaign. Twenty-four years of continuous operation, and a free tier that doesn't expire, matter when a link is printed on something you can't reprint.

Pricing starts free and goes to $9/month billed annually ($11 month-to-month) for 125 links a month with unlimited tracked clicks. Bulk plans handle 50,000 links a month for agencies and high-volume senders, and there's a REST API for automating the whole lifecycle.

Postproxy's answer:

Postproxy is a production-grade social media API for SaaS products, AI agents, and multi-tenant platforms. It provides one API for publishing, comments, direct messages, reviews, analytics, webhooks, and OAuth account connections across Instagram, Facebook, Threads, LinkedIn, TikTok, X, YouTube, Pinterest, Google Business Profile, Bluesky, and Telegram.

Compared with publishing-only APIs and automation tools, Postproxy is designed for customer-facing products that require official platform integrations, explicit delivery statuses, automatic retries, profile-group isolation, predictable pricing, and infrastructure built for production workloads.

TinyURL's answer

• Marketing teams running campaigns across several channels who need per-link attribution rather than a single lumped traffic figure
• Social media managers and creators working inside character limits, who want a branded link rather than a generic one
• Agencies managing links for multiple clients, each on its own branded domain
• Developers automating link creation and analytics through the REST API
• Enterprises needing SLA-backed uptime and compliance support
• Educational Institutions
• The healthcare industry

It also has a long tail of individual users who simply need a link shortened, which the free tier covers without an account upgrade.

Postproxy's answer:

Postproxy is primarily built for developers and product teams creating SaaS platforms, AI agents, marketing tools, and multi-tenant social media products. It is also used by agencies and automation specialists that manage social accounts for multiple customers.

Individual creators can use Postproxy, but the platform is optimized for software products and production workflows rather than manual social media management.

TinyURL's answer

Kevin Gilbertson, a web developer, launched TinyURL in January 2002 so he could link directly to newsgroup postings, which at the time had long and unwieldy addresses. It was the first notable URL shortening service, and it arrived years before shortening became a category.

Twitter used TinyURL as its default shortener until May 2009, which put it in front of a mass audience during the period when character limits made short links essential.

Since then it's grown from a single-purpose utility into a link management platform: branded domains, click analytics with two years of retained history, editable destinations, QR codes, bulk creation and a REST API. It now serves over 4.4 million registered users and has created billions of links.

Postproxy's answer:

We were building a product for ads creation at scale with fancy templates management, different platforms with adaptive sizing. Then Nano Banana got released and made a product largely obsolete. Postproxy was basically a part of that product.

TinyURL's answer

TinyURL is a cloud-hosted web application, accessible from any browser with no install. Its public interface is a REST API (v2.4.2) published as an OpenAPI 3.0 specification and authenticated with bearer tokens, covering link creation, editing, destination changes, analytics retrieval and bulk batch processing.

TinyURL's answer

Twitter used TinyURL as its default URL shortener until May 2009.