Minimalism Surf is extremely lightweight and focuses on offering a minimalistic web browsing experience, which can result in faster performance and lower resource usage.
Customizability Users can tailor Surf to their specific needs through patches and configuration. This makes it highly adaptable for those who are comfortable with a bit of coding.
Integration with Suckless Tools Surf fits seamlessly into the Suckless ecosystem, integrating well with other minimal and efficient tools like the DWM window manager.
Privacy By default, Surf doesn't include many of the tracking features found in mainstream browsers, potentially offering a more privacy-conscious browsing experience.
Compliance with UNIX Philosophy Surf adheres to the UNIX philosophy of doing one thing well, focusing solely on web browsing without additional, potentially unwanted, features.
Possible disadvantages
Steep Learning Curve Customizing and configuring Surf can be challenging for users who are not familiar with programming or the command line.
Limited Features Due to its minimalistic design, Surf lacks many modern features like extensions, tabs, and a built-in password manager that are standard in other browsers.
Manual Updates Users need to manually update the browser, which can be a hassle compared to automatic updates provided by mainstream browsers.
Compatibility Issues Surf may have trouble rendering some modern web pages correctly, as it lacks some of the compatibility layers found in more feature-complete browsers.
Community Support Being a niche and minimalist browser, Surf does not have as large a user base or as much community support compared to more popular browsers.
Modern C++ Implementation Vaev is built using modern C++ practices as part of the skift-org ecosystem, providing a clean and well-structured codebase for a web rendering engine with contemporary language features and design patterns.
Modular Architecture The project is organized into clearly separated modules (vaev-markup, vaev-style, vaev-layout, vaev-paint, vaev-driver) which promotes separation of concerns and makes the codebase easier to understand and maintain.
Lightweight and Embeddable Unlike major browser engines like Blink or Gecko, Vaev aims to be a lightweight web rendering engine that can be embedded in other projects, particularly targeting the skift operating system, making it suitable for resource-constrained environments.
Educational Value As a from-scratch implementation of a web rendering engine, Vaev serves as an excellent educational resource for understanding how HTML/CSS parsing, layout, styling, and painting work together in a browser engine.
Open Source and Community-Driven Vaev is fully open source under the skift-org organization, allowing developers to contribute, learn from, and adapt the code for their own purposes, fostering community collaboration around browser engine development.
Possible disadvantages
Incomplete Web Standards Support As a work-in-progress rendering engine, Vaev does not support the full range of HTML, CSS, and web standards that mature engines like Blink, Gecko, or WebKit do, limiting its practical use for rendering real-world web pages.
Small Community and Limited Contributors Being part of the niche skift-org ecosystem, Vaev has a relatively small contributor base, which can lead to slower development progress and fewer eyes reviewing code for bugs and security issues.
Limited Documentation The project appears to have minimal documentation for developers who want to understand, use, or contribute to it, making the onboarding process more difficult for newcomers.
No JavaScript Support Vaev focuses on HTML and CSS rendering but does not include a JavaScript engine, which severely limits its ability to render modern interactive web content that relies heavily on scripting.
Niche Target Platform Vaev is primarily designed for the skift operating system, which means it may not be straightforward to build and run on mainstream platforms, and its development priorities may not align with general-purpose usage needs.
Analysis
An editorial look at what each product does well and who it suits.
S
SurfVaev
Overall verdict
Surf can be considered 'good' for users who value simplicity, minimal system resource usage, and the ability to customize their browsing experience via external scripts or patches. However, it might not be suitable for those who rely heavily on modern web features and extensions available in mainstream browsers.
Why this product is good
Surf is a minimalist web browser created by the Suckless community, known for developing software that adheres to the philosophy of simplicity and clarity. It is designed to be lightweight and efficient, making it suitable for users who prefer minimalism and are comfortable using a browser without a graphical user interface (GUI) for settings or extensions.
Recommended for
Users who are familiar with Unix-like operating systems and command-line interfaces.
Individuals who prefer lightweight and efficient software.
Those willing to customize their browser through external tools and scripts.
Minimalists who do not require a plethora of features and extensions.
Overall verdict
Vaev is a promising open-source project (a browser engine / rendering engine written from scratch) that demonstrates strong technical ambition, but as an early-stage experimental effort it is best viewed as an exploratory and educational tool rather than a production-ready solution.
Why this product is good
It is an ambitious from-scratch browser/rendering engine, showcasing deep engineering effort and a willingness to tackle a notoriously complex domain
Being open source on GitHub, it allows developers to study, learn from, and contribute to the codebase
It represents a fresh, modern take rather than a fork of existing engines, which is valuable for experimentation and diversity in the ecosystem
Active development and clear technical goals make it an interesting project to follow for those curious about how browsers work under the hood
Recommended for
Developers and students interested in learning how browser and rendering engines are built
Open-source contributors looking to work on a challenging, low-level systems project
Researchers and hobbyists experimenting with alternative web engines
Enthusiasts who want to follow or support innovative independent engine development rather than needing a stable production browser
Share your experience with using Surf and Vaev.
For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Social recommendations and mentions
Recommendations tracked on public social media and blogs since March 2021.
S
Surf47 mentionsVaev0 mentions
Teal – A statically-typed dialect of Lua
Observation: Teal would make a great scripting language for a simpler web browser, one not based on JavaScript... Maybe something like the 'Surf' web browser: (https://surf.suckless.org/). Also, there should exist the capability to...
- Source: Hacker News
/
about 1 month ago
My server is a phone now
When I read about the browser 'surf', I first thought of the browser from suckless: https://surf.suckless.org/.
- Source: Hacker News
/
3 months ago
How to build a circular LCD clock
Interesting, surf is based off WebKit2. https://surf.suckless.org/.
- Source: Hacker News
/
4 months ago