Software Takes Command VS Eloquent JavaScript

• Pioneering media theory
  Lev Manovich offers a groundbreaking theoretical framework for understanding how software has become the fundamental layer through which we create, distribute, and experience all media, making it essential reading for media studies and digital humanities scholars.
• In-depth analysis of cultural software
  The book provides a thorough and detailed examination of key cultural software applications like Photoshop, After Effects, and other media authoring tools, exploring how their design shapes creative possibilities and cultural production.
• Builds on influential earlier work
  As a continuation and expansion of Manovich's earlier landmark book 'The Language of New Media,' this work deepens and updates his theoretical contributions, offering a more mature and comprehensive understanding of software's role in culture.
• Historically grounded perspective
  Manovich traces the intellectual history of software back to visionaries like Alan Kay and the Xerox PARC team, providing valuable historical context that helps readers understand how and why software evolved the way it did.
• Interdisciplinary relevance
  The book is valuable across multiple disciplines including media studies, computer science, design, art history, and cultural studies, making connections that encourage cross-disciplinary thinking about technology and culture.

Possible disadvantages

• Dense and academic writing style
  The book is written in a highly academic style that can be difficult for general readers or newcomers to media theory, often requiring familiarity with prior theoretical frameworks and terminology to fully engage with the arguments.
• Narrow software focus
  Despite the broad title, the book focuses primarily on a limited set of media authoring software (especially Adobe products), which may not fully represent the vast and diverse landscape of software that shapes culture today.
• Dated examples and references
  Some of the software examples and case studies discussed in the book have become somewhat outdated since publication, particularly given the rapid pace of technological change in areas like mobile apps, social media, and AI-driven tools.
• Repetitive argumentation
  Several reviewers and readers have noted that the book can feel repetitive, with key points about software's role in media being reiterated across multiple chapters without sufficient new insight to justify the repetition.
• Limited engagement with social and political dimensions
  The book focuses heavily on the formal and technical properties of software while giving comparatively less attention to the social, political, and economic power structures that shape software development and its cultural impact.

• Comprehensive Learning Resource
  Eloquent JavaScript covers a wide range of topics, from basic syntax to advanced concepts like asynchronous programming and web development. This depth makes it a valuable resource for both beginners and advanced programmers.
• Interactive Code Examples
  The book contains numerous interactive code examples that allow readers to see the effects of their code in real-time. This hands-on approach reinforces learning and helps solidify concepts.
• Free Online Access
  Eloquent JavaScript is available for free online, making it accessible to anyone with an internet connection. This allows learners from around the world to benefit from its content without financial barriers.
• Engaging Writing Style
  The author, Marijn Haverbeke, writes in an engaging and clear style, making complex topics more understandable and keeping readers interested.
• Good Balance of Theory and Practice
  The book strikes a good balance between theoretical explanations and practical exercises, allowing readers to apply what they have learned immediately.

Possible disadvantages

• Steep Learning Curve
  Some readers may find the book's progression to be rapid, especially if they are complete beginners. The book quickly moves from basic to more complex topics, which can be overwhelming.
• Lacks Visual Aids
  While the text is clear and the code examples are helpful, the book could benefit from more visual aids like diagrams and illustrations to explain complex concepts.
• Assumes Some Prior Knowledge
  Although it's aimed at beginners, the book sometimes assumes that readers have some prior programming experience, which can make it less accessible to absolute novices.
• Limited Coverage of Latest ES Features
  The book may not cover some of the latest features and best practices introduced in newer versions of JavaScript (e.g., ES2019 and beyond), meaning readers might need to supplement their learning with additional resources.
• Web Development Sections Could Be More Detailed
  While the book does touch on web development, the sections on this topic are not as in-depth as some readers might hope. Those looking to get a more thorough grounding in web development may need to consult other sources.

No Software Takes Command videos yet. You could help us improve this page by suggesting one.

Eloquent JavaScript A Modern Introduction to Programming 3rd Edition by Marijn Haverbeke review

More videos

Tracking Software Takes Command since May 2026.

• My Azure Cloud Resume Challenge Journey

  If you haven’t read Eloquent JavaScript , go check it out. It’s one of my all-time favourite programming books — hands down. - Source: dev.to / about 1 year ago

• How do we learn to get good at programming

  Videos, blogs, text-based teachings, YouTube project-based learning, books, and the like are all examples of various methods and mediums of acquiring skills, especially in the software engineering industry. As I continue to navigate... - Source: dev.to / almost 2 years ago

• Ask HN: Changing my mind about JavaScript

  Seconded. I won't recommend it and no one I know has recommended it for a decade. It's hard for someone who doesn't know JS to know which parts has changed and is no longer the way to do things. https://github.com/getify/You-Dont-Know-JS... - Source: Hacker News / about 2 years ago

View more