pkgsrc VS Shorewall

• Cross-Platform Support
  pkgsrc is designed to be a portable package management system and can be used on a variety of Unix-like operating systems, including NetBSD, Solaris, Linux, and macOS. This cross-platform capability makes it a versatile tool for developers working in diverse environments.
• Consistency Across Systems
  Using pkgsrc allows for a consistent package management experience regardless of the underlying operating system, reducing the learning curve and maintenance overhead for administrators managing multiple systems.
• Comprehensive Package Collection
  pkgsrc offers a wide range of software packages, providing a robust collection that can meet diverse user needs from scientific libraries to web applications.
• Quarterly Releases
  With quarterly releases, pkgsrc provides a balanced approach between stability and keeping software up to date, offering users new features regularly while maintaining reliability.
• Flexible Build Options
  pkgsrc supports a flexible build system, allowing users to customize package builds with specific options or dependencies, tailored to their specific needs or system requirements.

Possible disadvantages

• Smaller Community
  Compared to other popular package management systems like apt (Debian/Ubuntu) or yum (RedHat/CentOS), pkgsrc has a relatively smaller community, which might affect the availability of support and community-driven improvements.
• Potentially Older Software
  While pkgsrc maintains stable quarterly releases, it may occasionally lag behind other systems in terms of offering the very latest versions of certain software, which might not be ideal for users needing the newest features.
• Manual Configuration
  Setting up pkgsrc might require manual interventions and configurations, which could pose a hurdle for users unfamiliar with its setup process or those who prefer more automated solutions.
• Dependency Management
  Although pkgsrc is quite capable in dependency handling, some users may find its dependency resolution to be less automatic or seamless compared to other systems which offer more integrated solutions.
• Performance Overhead
  Because it is designed to be cross-platform, there can be some performance overhead associated with using pkgsrc compared to native package managers that are optimized for specific operating systems.

• Comprehensive Configuration
  Shorewall offers a comprehensive framework for configuring firewall rules, allowing for detailed network management and control over traffic flow.
• Rule Management
  It provides powerful rule management capabilities, with the ability to define rules based on zones, interfaces, and IP addresses.
• Flexible Deployment
  Shorewall can be deployed in various environments, supporting both IPv4 and IPv6, with options for advanced configurations like VPNs and port forwarding.
• Strong Community Support
  The tool is backed by strong community support with extensive documentation, forums, and user-contributed scripts.
• Compatibility
  Shorewall is highly compatible with Linux-based systems and leverages netfilter/iptables which is built into the Linux kernel.

Possible disadvantages

• Complexity
  The comprehensive configuration options can be complex, posing a steep learning curve for users unfamiliar with advanced networking concepts.
• Dependency on Command Line
  Shorewall primarily relies on command-line interfaces for configuration, which may not be intuitive for all users, especially those accustomed to graphical interfaces.
• Limited GUI Options
  While there are some third-party GUIs available, Shorewall does not provide native graphical user interface tools for managing firewall rules, which could limit usability for some users.
• Resource Intensive
  Depending on the complexity and number of rules, Shorewall can become resource-intensive, potentially affecting system performance.
• Targeted for Advanced Users
  The tool caters more to advanced users or system administrators, with less focus on novices or users requiring simpler configurations.

pkgsrc on ChromeOS

More videos

Shorewall sobre CentOS 7.7

• Debian isn't waiting for 2038 to blow up, switches to 64-bit time for everything

  > Most open source software packages are also compiled for BSD variants, they switched to 64 bit time_t a long time ago and reported back upstream any problems. * NetBSD in 2012:... - Source: Hacker News / about 1 year ago

• Our Audit of Homebrew

  > https://pkgsrc.smartos.org/install-on-macos/ Note that Pkgsrc is a NetBSD-derived project. * https://pkgsrc.org The Joyent folks leveraged it to allow their customers, who were perhaps not as familiar with Solaris/SmartOS, a... - Source: Hacker News / about 2 years ago

• Show HN: Brioche – A new Nix-like package manager

  Https://pkgsrc.org/ from netbsd runs on many systems. - Source: Hacker News / over 2 years ago

View more

• DHCP is not blocked by ufw/iptables

  All mentioned items have side-channel borked firewall and route rules in the past. Some bugs intermittently silently block local daemon instances from (re)loading like magic (some bugs only happen when the system is brought up). If your... - Source: Hacker News / about 3 years ago

• Life After Shorewall: Replacement Options?

  I've been using Shorewall for the last decade or so on everything from custom OpenWRT firewall/gateway solutions to servers running Debian or Ubuntu. It's great software that makes managing iptables/netfilter a breeze. Alas after many... Source: over 3 years ago

• Tunneling private networked host to the internet through public-facing server?

  Shorewall (https://shorewall.org/) can do the job easily. Source: over 3 years ago

View more