Phabricator

Website

phacility.com

$ Details

Categories

#Git #Code Collaboration #Project Management #Software Development

Reviewable

Website

reviewable.io

$ Details

Categories

#Code Collaboration #Developer Tools #Software Development #Code Review

Phabricator features and specs

• Comprehensive Toolset
  Phabricator offers a wide range of tools including code review, repository hosting, bug tracking, project management, and more, all integrated into one platform.
• Customizability
  Users can customize workflows, forms, and other aspects to fit the specific needs of their projects.
• Powerful Code Review
  Phabricator provides advanced code review features like inline comments, custom fields, and audit trails, making it a robust tool for maintaining code quality.
• Open Source
  Being open-source, Phabricator allows organizations to host their instance, providing control over data and customizations without licensing fees.
• Multi-repository Support
  It supports multiple version control systems (Git, Mercurial, and Subversion) and allows managing multiple repositories within the same project.

Possible disadvantages of Phabricator

• Complex Setup
  Phabricator can be challenging to install and configure, requiring a good level of technical knowledge and infrastructure.
• Steep Learning Curve
  New users might find it difficult to navigate and use all the features due to its extensive functionalities and less intuitive user interface.
• Limited Third-Party Integrations
  Compared to other platforms, Phabricator has fewer integrations with third-party tools, which might be a limitation for some teams.
• Dependency on Phacility's Future
  Phacility announced that they will cease operations, which means the future maintenance and updates of Phabricator could be uncertain.
• Performance Issues
  For large-scale projects with many users and repositories, Phabricator may experience performance issues and could require significant resources to run smoothly.

Reviewable features and specs

• Detailed Review Process
  Reviewable offers a highly customizable review process that allows teams to define their own criteria for code reviews. This flexibility can enhance the quality of code by ensuring thorough checks and balances.
• Integration with GitHub
  The platform integrates seamlessly with GitHub, which is beneficial for developers already using GitHub as their primary code repository. This integration enables streamlined workflows without the need to switch between multiple tools.
• Real-time Collaboration
  Reviewable supports real-time collaboration, allowing team members to see changes and comments as they happen. This feature can enhance communication and the speed of the review process.
• Advanced Commenting Features
  The tool offers advanced commenting features, such as single-threaded discussions and the ability to mark issues as resolved, which can help keep feedback organized and clear.
• High Customizability
  Users can tailor the review process with various configurations, such as review state tracking and custom checklists. This customizability allows teams to adapt the tool to their workflow needs.

Possible disadvantages of Reviewable

• Complex Setup
  The initial setup of Reviewable can be complex and time-consuming, especially for teams not familiar with configuring such tools. This can create a steep learning curve for new users.
• Cost
  Reviewable is a paid service, and the cost can be a concern for small teams or individual developers, especially when considering other free or cheaper code review options.
• Limited to GitHub
  As Reviewable is designed specifically for use with GitHub, teams using other version control systems like GitLab or Bitbucket won't be able to integrate the tool into their workflows.
• Overwhelming Feature Set
  While Reviewable offers numerous features, this extensive set can be overwhelming for new users who may not need all of the functionalities, leading to potential underutilization.
• User Interface Complexity
  Some users may find the user interface complex, with a high amount of information displayed at once. This can make it difficult to navigate for those who prefer simpler, more straightforward interfaces.

Phabricator code review session at Wikimedia Hackathon Zurich

More videos:

Reviewable -- what is the fastest way to check out your review code?