Software Alternatives, Accelerators & Startups

Mathomatic VS MathJournal

Compare Mathomatic VS MathJournal and see what are their differences

Mathomatic logo Mathomatic

Mathomatic is a free general purpose computer algebra system that is an expert in solving and simplifying the algebraic and computation issues.

MathJournal logo MathJournal

MathJournal is a dedicated platform for the tablet PC for resolving the complex mathematical problems.
  • Mathomatic Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-08-17
  • MathJournal Landing page
    Landing page //
    2020-01-23

Mathomatic features and specs

  • Lightweight and portable
    Mathomatic is a small, portable computer algebra system (CAS) written in C that can run on a wide variety of platforms including Unix, Linux, Windows, and even embedded systems, requiring very minimal system resources.
  • Free and open source
    Mathomatic is released under the GNU Lesser General Public License (LGPL), making it freely available for anyone to use, study, modify, and distribute without any cost.
  • Simple and easy to use
    Mathomatic features a straightforward command-line interface with intuitive commands, making it accessible to users who need quick symbolic math computations without a steep learning curve common in more complex CAS tools.
  • Fast performance
    Due to its small codebase and efficient C implementation, Mathomatic performs symbolic algebra operations quickly, even on older or resource-constrained hardware.
  • Good for basic algebra tasks
    Mathomatic handles core algebraic operations well, including simplification, solving equations, polynomial arithmetic, calculus (differentiation and integration), and symbolic manipulation of mathematical expressions.

Possible disadvantages of Mathomatic

  • Limited advanced functionality
    Compared to major CAS tools like Mathematica, Maple, or even free alternatives like Maxima and SageMath, Mathomatic lacks many advanced mathematical capabilities such as advanced calculus, linear algebra, and specialized mathematical functions.
  • No longer actively maintained
    Mathomatic's development has been largely inactive since the passing of its primary developer, George Gesslein II, in 2018, meaning bugs are unlikely to be fixed and new features will not be added.
  • No graphical interface
    Mathomatic operates solely through a text-based command-line interface and does not offer a graphical user interface (GUI) or plotting capabilities, which limits its appeal for users who prefer visual interaction.
  • Small community and limited documentation
    Mathomatic has a relatively small user community compared to mainstream CAS software, which means limited community support, fewer tutorials, and less comprehensive documentation for troubleshooting.
  • Limited library and ecosystem integration
    Mathomatic lacks robust APIs and integration options with other programming languages, scientific libraries, or notebook environments, making it difficult to incorporate into larger scientific computing workflows.

MathJournal features and specs

  • Handwriting Recognition
    MathJournal offers advanced handwriting recognition, allowing users to write mathematical formulas naturally, which makes it user-friendly for those who prefer writing over typing.
  • Interactive Calculation
    The software provides interactive calculation capabilities, enabling users to manipulate and solve equations dynamically, which enhances the learning and problem-solving experience.
  • Graphical Representation
    MathJournal supports the graphical representation of mathematical expressions and functions, helping users visualize complex mathematical concepts.
  • Versatile Compatibility
    The application is compatible with various hardware, including tablets and stylus-based devices, offering flexibility in how users can engage with the software.
  • Educational Tool
    It serves as an excellent educational tool for both students and teachers, providing a platform for exploring and demonstrating mathematical concepts efficiently.

Possible disadvantages of MathJournal

  • Limited Platform Availability
    MathJournal may only be available for specific platforms, which can limit accessibility for users who do not have compatible devices.
  • Cost
    The software might come with a cost that could be a barrier for some individuals or institutions, particularly when free alternatives are available.
  • Learning Curve
    Despite its intuitive design, there may be a learning curve associated with mastering all features and functionalities of MathJournal, especially for new users.
  • Software Updates
    Users may experience delays or inconsistencies with software updates, affecting the performance and availability of new features.
  • Limited Collaboration Features
    MathJournal might have limited collaboration features, making it less ideal for group projects or environments where sharing and real-time collaboration are necessary.

Analysis of Mathomatic

Overall verdict

  • Mathomatic is a free, open-source computer algebra system that is lightweight and useful for basic to intermediate symbolic math, though it is not as powerful or actively developed as major CAS tools like Mathematica, Maple, or SymPy.

Why this product is good

  • It is free and open-source, making it accessible to anyone
  • Lightweight and simple to install, requiring minimal system resources
  • Capable of symbolic algebra including simplification, solving equations, and calculus operations
  • Portable and can run on various platforms including embedded systems
  • Simple command-line interface that is easy to learn for basic tasks
  • No licensing costs compared to commercial alternatives

Recommended for

  • Students learning algebra and basic symbolic computation
  • Hobbyists who want a lightweight CAS without installing large software
  • Users on resource-constrained or older systems needing simple symbolic math tools
  • Educators demonstrating basic algebraic concepts
  • Programmers who want to embed simple symbolic computation in other projects
  • Those who prefer open-source tools over commercial CAS software

Analysis of MathJournal

Overall verdict

  • MathJournal by xThink was a niche Windows Tablet PC application for handwriting and solving math equations, but it appears largely discontinued and outdated, making it a poor choice for most users today compared to modern alternatives.

Why this product is good

  • Offered handwriting recognition specifically tailored for mathematical notation and equations
  • Allowed users to write math problems naturally with a stylus rather than typing complex formulas
  • Provided step-by-step equation solving and graphing capabilities integrated with handwritten input
  • Was designed for Tablet PCs, filling a niche for pen-based math computation at the time

Recommended for

  • Users with legacy Windows Tablet PCs who already own the software
  • Nostalgic users or educators researching early handwriting-based math software
  • Not recommended for new users seeking modern, actively supported math tools
  • Better alternatives exist today like Microsoft Math Solver, GoodNotes with math tools, or Notability combined with computation apps

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to Mathomatic and MathJournal)
Technical Computing
51 51%
49% 49
Math Solver
50 50%
50% 50
Numerical Computation
50 50%
50% 50
Math Tools
50 50%
50% 50

User comments

Share your experience with using Mathomatic and MathJournal. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

What are some alternatives?

When comparing Mathomatic and MathJournal, you can also consider the following products

COMSOL Multiphysics - COMSOL is the developer of COMSOL Multiphysics software, an interactive environment for modeling and simulating scientific and engineering problems.

Mathcad - Mathcad is engineering calculation software that drives innovation and offers significant process...

Sage Math - Sage is a free open-source mathematics software system licensed under the GPL.

Maxima - Maxima is a fairly complete computer algebra system written in Lisp with an emphasis on symbolic computation.

SMath Studio - Tiny, powerful, free mathematical program with WYSIWYG editor and complete units of measurements support.

Wolfram Mathematica - Mathematica has characterized the cutting edge in specialized processingโ€”and gave the chief calculation environment to a large number of pioneers, instructors, understudies, and others around the globe.