Gitit VS MDwiki

Wiki using happstack, git or darcs, and pandoc.

Static single file CMS/Wiki done purely with client-side Javascript and HTML5.

Lightweight and Simple
Gitit is lightweight and easy to set up due to its minimalistic design, making it an ideal choice for users who prefer simplicity and efficiency without complex configurations.
Version Control Integration
It integrates with Git, a powerful version control system, allowing easy tracking of changes and collaboration on wikis using Git's distributed versioning model.
Markdown Support
Supports a variety of lightweight markup languages such as Markdown, making it accessible and familiar to many users who are already accustomed to these formats.
Extensible through Plugins
It is highly extensible through plugins, which allows users to customize the functionality of their wiki according to their specific requirements.
Static Page Generation
Can generate static HTML pages that can be served by any web server, improving the site's performance and security by reducing server-side dependencies.

Limited User Interface
The user interface is quite basic compared to other advanced wiki platforms, which may not fulfill the needs of users who seek rich editing features and polished interfaces.
Haskell Dependency
Being written in Haskell, it requires a Haskell environment to be installed, which might be a barrier for users unfamiliar with this ecosystem.
Community and Support
Being a niche project, Gitit may have limited community support and fewer resources available online for troubleshooting compared to more popular wiki solutions.
Feature Limitations
May lack some advanced features provided by other wiki software, such as integrated access controls, user management, and advanced formatting tools.
Customization Complexity
Customization of Gitit might require Haskell programming knowledge, which can be a hurdle for users not familiar with the language.

Ease of Use
MDwiki runs entirely on client-side JavaScript, which allows easy setup without the need for a backend server. This makes it accessible for users with minimal technical knowledge.
Markdown Based
Utilizes Markdown for content creation, making it simple and intuitive to use for creating and editing web pages. Users familiar with Markdown can quickly develop content.
Portability
Since MDwiki doesn't require a server and is built from static files, it can be hosted on any static web host or even run locally, allowing for high portability.
No Dependencies
MDwiki doesn't require any additional dependencies or installations, which simplifies the process of setting up and maintaining a site.
Customizable Appearance
Offers customization options through CSS, allowing users to tailor the appearance of their site to fit their needs or branding.

Limited Functionality
Being a client-side application, MDwiki is limited in terms of dynamic content generation and server-side functionality, which might not be suitable for complex applications.
Scalability Issues
For larger websites, managing Markdown files can become cumbersome, and the lack of database support makes it less scalable for content-heavy sites.
SEO Limitations
Single-page applications like MDwiki may face challenges in SEO, as search engines may not effectively index JavaScript-rendered content.
Lack of Advanced Features
Features common in more robust CMS solutions, such as user authentication, role management, and content scheduling, are not available.
Community and Support
MDwiki may have limited community support and documentation compared to more widely-used CMS platforms, potentially leading to challenges in troubleshooting and extending functionality.