Software Alternatives & Startups

3commas VS PropFirmPineScripts

Compare 3commas VS PropFirmPineScripts and see what are their differences

Note: These products don't have any matching categories. If you think this is a mistake, please edit the details of one of the products and suggest appropriate categories.

3commas logo 3commas

3commas.io provides tools for cryptocurrency traders and investors.

PropFirmPineScripts logo PropFirmPineScripts

Automated Pine Script strategies built to pass FTMO, Apex, Topstep, and MyFundedFutures evaluations. Real backtested edges, invite-only on TradingView, from $24/mo.
  • 3commas Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-07-31
  • PropFirmPineScripts PropFirmPineScripts homepage — plans and strategy overview
    PropFirmPineScripts homepage — plans and strategy overview //
    2026-08-11

PropFirmPineScripts sells TradingView Pine Script strategies built specifically for passing prop firm futures evaluations, rather than for discretionary trading.

Each strategy is written around the rules that actually fail most evaluation accounts: an end-of-day auto-flatten so no position is ever held overnight, and a daily loss kill switch that stops trading once a set loss threshold is hit. Strategies are tuned per instrument and per account size instead of being one generic script applied everywhere.

Plans: - Starter ($24/mo): one strategy for MES or MNQ, sized for 50k evaluation accounts. - Pro ($39/mo): one strategy for ES or NQ, sized for 100k-150k accounts. - 4-Pack Bundle ($70/mo): four strategies across CL, MES, MGC and MNQ on different timeframes. - Custom Build ($250 one-time): a bespoke strategy for any instrument, delivered as a .pine file in 3-5 business days with 14 days of revisions.

Subscription plans are delivered invite-only on TradingView, with access granted within 24 hours of signup. Full source code is provided, so buyers can read and modify the logic rather than run a locked black box.

Intended for traders taking evaluations with firms such as Apex Trader Funding, Topstep, FTMO and MyFundedFutures.

3commas

Website
3commas.io
$ Details
Release Date
2017 January
Startup details
Country
Canada
State
Ontario
City
Toronto
Founder(s)
Yuriy Sorokin
Employees
10 - 19

PropFirmPineScripts

$ Details
paid $24 / Monthly (Starter)
Release Date
-
Startup details
Country
United States
Employees
1 - 9

3commas features and specs

  • User-friendly Interface
    3Commas offers an intuitive and easy-to-navigate interface that caters to both novice and experienced traders.
  • Automated Trading Bots
    The platform provides various automated trading bots, such as DCA, GRID, and options bots, which help users maximize their trading opportunities.
  • Wide Exchange Support
    3Commas supports a broad range of cryptocurrency exchanges, enabling users to trade across multiple platforms from a single interface.
  • Smart Trade Terminal
    The smart trade terminal allows users to set advanced trading strategies, including trailing stop loss and take profit, which can help optimize gains and limit losses.
  • Social Trading Features
    Users can follow and copy the trades of successful traders through the social trading features, offering a way to learn and potentially profit from experienced traders' strategies.
  • Portfolio Management
    The platform offers comprehensive portfolio management tools, enabling users to track and analyze their asset performance in real-time.
  • Mobile App
    3Commas offers a mobile app, giving users the flexibility to manage their trades and monitor the market on-the-go.

Possible disadvantages of 3commas

  • Subscription Costs
    The platform operates on a subscription basis, which may be expensive for some users, particularly those just starting out in trading.
  • Learning Curve
    While user-friendly, some of the more advanced features and strategies may have a steep learning curve for novice traders.
  • Reliance on API
    Users need to grant API access to their exchange accounts, which carries inherent risks in terms of security and privacy.
  • Market Dependency
    Automated trading bots perform based on market conditions; during highly volatile or low-liquidity periods, the bots may not perform as expected.
  • Limited Free Features
    The free plan offers very limited functionality, pushing users towards paid subscriptions to access the more useful features and tools.
  • Technical Issues
    Like any software platform, users may occasionally encounter technical issues such as bugs, system outages, or slow performance.

PropFirmPineScripts features and specs

  • Niche Focus on Prop Trading
    The scripts are tailored specifically for traders attempting prop firm challenges, potentially including risk management tools, drawdown trackers, and rule-compliance indicators that generic Pine Script tools may not offer.
  • TradingView Integration
    Since it's built on Pine Script, the tools integrate directly into TradingView, a platform widely used by retail and prop traders, making it easy to apply without needing separate software.
  • Potential Time Savings
    Pre-built scripts can save traders time compared to coding custom indicators or risk management tools from scratch, especially for those without programming experience.
  • Community and Educational Value
    Such platforms often include tutorials, support communities, or educational content that can help traders better understand how to use Pine Script tools effectively for their trading strategies.
  • Customization Options
    Many Pine Script tool providers offer some level of customization, allowing traders to adjust settings to fit their specific prop firm's rules and their personal trading style.

Analysis of 3commas

Overall verdict

  • Overall, 3Commas is considered a reputable platform with a solid track record in the crypto trading community. Many users appreciate its user-friendly interface, comprehensive feature set, and continuous updates. However, like any trading platform, success depends heavily on how effectively you utilize its tools and strategies.

Why this product is good

  • 3Commas is a popular cryptocurrency trading platform known for offering a wide range of tools for both novice and experienced traders. It provides features such as automated trading bots, smart trade terminal, portfolio management, and more. These tools aim to optimize trading strategies, minimize risks, and maximize profits, making it attractive for users looking to enhance their trading capabilities.

Recommended for

    3Commas is recommended for cryptocurrency traders who are looking for automation to improve their trading strategies. It is suitable for both beginners who are interested in simplified trading solutions and experienced traders who wish to leverage advanced features like trading bots and detailed analytics.

3commas videos

3Commas Review & Tutorial - Profit Easily With 3commas Smart Trade 2020

More videos:

  • Review - Is 3Commas The Best Cryptocurrency Trading Software Binance 2019
  • Tutorial - Make Max Profits Trading Bitcoin & Crypto - [ 3commas tutorial ]

PropFirmPineScripts videos

No PropFirmPineScripts videos yet. You could help us improve this page by suggesting one.

Add video

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to 3commas and PropFirmPineScripts)
Cryptocurrencies
100 100%
0% 0
Automated Trading
0 0%
100% 100
Cryptocurrency Trading
100 100%
0% 0
Futures Trading
0 0%
100% 100

Questions & Answers

As answered by people managing 3commas and PropFirmPineScripts.

What makes your product unique?

PropFirmPineScripts's answer:

Most Pine Script strategies sold online are built to look good on a backtest. These are built around a different constraint: the rules that actually fail prop firm evaluation accounts.

Every strategy ships with an end-of-day auto-flatten, so a position is never carried overnight, and a daily loss kill switch that stops trading once a set loss threshold is hit. Those two rules are what most evaluations are lost on, and here they are enforced by the script rather than by the trader's discipline in the moment.

Strategies are also tuned per instrument and per account size (MES/MNQ for 50k evaluations, ES/NQ for 100k-150k) instead of one generic script applied to every chart. Full Pine source code is included with every subscription, so the logic can be read and modified rather than run as a locked black box.

Which are the primary technologies used for building your product?

PropFirmPineScripts's answer:

The strategies themselves are written in TradingView Pine Script (v6), and run inside TradingView. Distribution is invite-only access to the published scripts rather than file downloads, which is how access control works on that platform.

The storefront is a Node.js application, with Stripe handling subscription billing and Supabase (PostgreSQL) storing accounts, subscription state and delivery status. It is deployed on Vercel.

Strategy development and validation is done outside Pine as well, using a Python backtesting stack (pandas, NumPy, DuckDB) for parameter sweeps, walk-forward testing and Monte Carlo simulation against each prop firm's specific drawdown and profit-target rules, before anything is ported to Pine and published.

Why should a person choose your product over its competitors?

PropFirmPineScripts's answer:

Indicator subscriptions give you signals to interpret. These are complete strategies: entry, exit, stop, position sizing, and the evaluation firm's own risk rules encoded directly in the script.

The scope is deliberately narrow rather than general purpose. It covers futures instruments (MES, MNQ, ES, NQ, CL, MGC) and prop firm evaluations specifically, instead of trying to be a toolkit for every market and every timeframe. That narrowness is the point, because the risk rules being automated are specific to how evaluation accounts are failed.

Practical differences: full Pine source code is provided rather than obfuscated or locked; pricing is a flat monthly subscription starting at $24 with no per-seat or per-instrument upsell inside a tier; and access is granted invite-only on TradingView within 24 hours of signup. A one-time $250 custom build is available for instruments outside the standard catalogue, delivered as a .pine file with 14 days of revisions.

How would you describe the primary audience of your product?

PropFirmPineScripts's answer:

Retail futures traders taking evaluation accounts with prop firms such as Apex Trader Funding, Topstep, FTMO and MyFundedFutures.

The typical user can already read a chart but keeps failing evaluations on rule violations rather than on strategy quality, most often by holding a position past the session close or by continuing to trade after a bad morning. That is the specific problem the scripts are built to remove.

Account sizes range from 50k evaluations (traded on micros, MES and MNQ) up through 100k and 150k accounts (traded on full-size ES and NQ). Users need a TradingView account, since delivery and execution both run through TradingView rather than a separate platform.

What's the story behind your product?

PropFirmPineScripts's answer:

PropFirmPineScripts came out of a fairly narrow observation: prop firm evaluations are usually failed on risk rules, not on entries. Traders hold something through the close, or keep trading after a bad morning, and the account is gone regardless of whether the underlying idea was any good.

Most Pine Scripts sold for that audience do not encode those rules at all. They are entry-and-exit logic, with the risk management left to the trader in the exact moment they are least able to apply it.

The product is a small, solo-run catalogue built the other way around: the evaluation constraints go into the script first (end-of-day auto-flatten, daily loss kill switch, per-account-size position sizing), and the entry logic is fitted to those constraints. It launched in 2026, sells directly to traders as a monthly subscription, and every strategy ships with readable source code rather than a locked build.

User comments

Share your experience with using 3commas and PropFirmPineScripts. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

Reviews

These are some of the external sources and on-site user reviews we've used to compare 3commas and PropFirmPineScripts

3commas Reviews

  1. 3commas

    easy to use


10 BEST Crypto Trading Bots for Automated Trading (2023)
3Commas is committed to helping traders reap maximum profit success by minimizing investor risks and limiting exposure to losses. With no need to install additional software and already integrated across a large number of exchanges, 3Commas is a favorite among traders. Focussing primarily on providing useful tools and easily customizable features, traders can create, connect...
Source: www.guru99.com
10 Best Crypto Bots
One of the best bots for buying cryptocurrency and its transactions, which is active in a completely intelligent way in short-term, medium-term, and long-term transactions, is the 3Commas. This robot has a very simple and smooth user interface and works great for digital asset protection and profitability.
Source: barterify.org
Best crypto trading bots 2020
3commas is a cloud-based service for cryptocurrency automated trading. While trading with the platform’s automation tools, you can do either manual trading or automated trading. Also, the platform gives you access to 30+ indicators and 90+ candle patterns.
Source: tradesanta.com

PropFirmPineScripts Reviews

We have no reviews of PropFirmPineScripts yet.
Be the first one to post

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, 3commas seems to be more popular. It has been mentiond 51 times since March 2021. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

3commas mentions (51)

  • Show HN: I built an AI portfolio manager and entrusted it with $50k
    Is your crypto only EFT traded or anything like https://3commas.io/ in it? - Source: Hacker News / 9 months ago
  • Show HN: Stock assessment from multiple AIs (Building in Public)
    Pretty cool. I've been wondering about DO: https://undervalued.ai/analysis/DOCN how can they keep going with AWS and GCP. Would be cool to pick 10 sample portfolios and keep running them thru this 24/7 with fake money and publish how good it is. Reminds me of https://3commas.io/ for coins. - Source: Hacker News / over 1 year ago
  • 🌟 Cyber Monday is here - 💸 Get 50% off annual subscriptions to our feature-packed Pro and Expert plans
    Choose your plan: https://3commas.io/. Source: almost 3 years ago
  • Unauthorized Signin
    Friendly reminder: Check that your API keys are inactive. I lost a lot of cash from the illegal use of my api keys. It's my fault for trusting 3commas.io encryption. This would not trigger sign in notices, but it is just another thing I wish someone would have told me. Coinbase takes zero responsibility for loss of access to your account if you leave your password on a third-party trading system. Source: about 3 years ago
  • 3commas or Tafabot which one should I go with?
    Both Tafabot and 3commas provide traders with powerful tools to automate trades and maximize profits. Source: over 3 years ago
View more

PropFirmPineScripts mentions (0)

We have not tracked any mentions of PropFirmPineScripts yet. Tracking of PropFirmPineScripts recommendations started around Aug 2026.

What are some alternatives?

When comparing 3commas and PropFirmPineScripts, you can also consider the following products

Cryptohopper - Cryptohopper is the best crypto trading bot currently available, 24/7 trading automatically in the cloud. Easy to use, powerful and extremely safe. Trade your cryptocurrency now with Cryptohopper, the automated crypto trading bot.

AlgoWay - PineConnector alternative for TradingView alerts → MT5, cTrader, crypto exchanges. Fast webhook routing & risk controls.

Coinrule - Coinrule empowers traders to compete with professional algorithmic traders and hedge funds.

Pineify App - Easily create buy/sell indicators and custom strategies for TradingView Pine Script code creator. The best indicator and strategy backtest builder.

TradeSanta - Trade Santa is a cloud software platform that automates crypto trading strategies. Cryptocurrency trading bots are available for Binance, Huobi, Upbit, Bittrex, Bitfinex, and Hitbtc.

PineReady - Generate Indicator and Strategy Scripts in the Pine Script language for the TradingView platform, without requiring any programming skills