Surge for Mac VS vimode

• Comprehensive Network Debugging
  Surge for Mac provides advanced network debugging features, including HTTP/HTTPS proxy, capture and analysis of network traffic, and robust filtering options. This makes it easy to diagnose and fix network issues.
• Rule-based Configuration
  Surge supports complex, rule-based configurations, which are highly customizable. This allows for precise control over network behavior, aiding in development, testing, and deployment scenarios.
• API Request Analysis
  The tool provides detailed insights into API requests and responses, helping developers and testers to understand and optimize backend API communications.
• Advanced Proxy Capabilities
  Surge offers robust proxy capabilities, including support for SOCKS5, HTTP CONNECT, and rewrite rules, making it versatile for various network environments and use cases.
• User-Friendly Interface
  Surge boasts a user-friendly interface which simplifies the process of setting up and managing complex network configurations, making it accessible even for users who are not network experts.
• Automation and Scripting Support
  The platform supports automation and scripting, allowing users to automate repetitive tasks and integrate Surge into their workflows using JavaScript.

Possible disadvantages

• Cost
  Surge for Mac is a paid software, which can be relatively costly compared to some other network debugging tools or open-source alternatives.
• Learning Curve
  Due to its advanced features and capabilities, there can be a steep learning curve for new users. Understanding all of its functions and configurations may require some time and effort.
• Resource Intensive
  Running Surge, particularly with extensive network traffic analysis and debugging features enabled, can be resource-intensive, potentially affecting the overall performance of your Mac.
• Overwhelming for Simple Use Cases
  For users with simpler needs, the extensive features of Surge may be overwhelming. In such cases, a more straightforward tool might be a better fit.
• Compatibility Issues
  Some users have reported compatibility issues with certain applications and services, which may require troubleshooting or alternative configurations to resolve.

• Efficient Navigation
  Vimode allows users to navigate web pages quickly using keyboard shortcuts, enhancing productivity for those familiar with Vim-like keybindings.
• Customizable
  Users can customize keybindings to suit their preferences, making the browsing experience more personalized and efficient.
• Improved Accessibility
  With keyboard navigation, users can access various page functions without relying on a mouse, which can be beneficial for power users and those with limited mobility.

Possible disadvantages

• Steep Learning Curve
  Users unfamiliar with Vim-style navigation may find the extension difficult to use initially, requiring a learning period to become proficient.
• Compatibility Issues
  Some websites may have unexpected behavior or conflicts due to the keybindings, requiring adjustments or temporary disabling of the extension.
• Limited Audience
  The extension primarily benefits users who are already familiar with Vim, which may limit its appeal to a broader audience.

• Charles Proxy

  Https://nssurge.com is available on macOS & iOS and has seemed superior to Fiddler in many ways. - Supports a pseudo-VPN mode (~tap and socket filter) that intercepts any traffic that doesn't go through the HTTPS/SOCKS proxies, including... - Source: Hacker News / 10 months ago

Tracking vimode since Feb 2022.