Software Alternatives, Accelerators & Startups

SELinux VS Whonix

Compare SELinux VS Whonix and see what are their differences

SELinux logo SELinux

A security enhancement to Linux which allows users and administrators more control over access...

Whonix logo Whonix

Whonix aims at preserving your privacy and anonymity by helping you use your applications...
  • SELinux Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-10-03
  • Whonix Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-01-20

SELinux features and specs

  • Enhanced Security
    SELinux provides a robust security model by enforcing mandatory access controls (MAC) on processes and system resources, minimizing the potential damage from vulnerabilities or compromises.
  • Granular Control
    The policy-driven approach allows fine-grained control over permissions, enabling administrators to specify precisely what system elements applications can interact with.
  • Policy Flexibility
    SELinux policies can be customized and tailored to the specific needs of different environments, allowing adaptability to a wide range of use cases.
  • Increased Isolation
    By compartmentalizing processes and restricting their access to resources, SELinux improves the isolation between different applications and the system itself, reducing the risk of security breaches.
  • Logging and Auditing
    SELinux provides comprehensive audit logs, making it easier to track and analyze security events, contributing to improved system accountability and forensic capabilities.

Possible disadvantages of SELinux

  • Complexity
    The initial setup and policy configuration can be complex and time-consuming, requiring a deep understanding of both the system's requirements and SELinux itself.
  • Performance Overhead
    Implementing SELinux can introduce some performance overhead due to the additional checks and enforcements, although this is often minimal with modern hardware.
  • Compatibility Issues
    Not all applications and services are fully compatible with SELinux out of the box, which may necessitate policy adjustments or even disabling SELinux in some cases.
  • Learning Curve
    Administrators need to invest time in learning how to effectively use and manage SELinux, which can be a barrier for teams without existing expertise.
  • Troubleshooting Challenges
    When SELinux is misconfigured, it can cause access issues that may be difficult to diagnose and resolve without proper knowledge and tools.

Whonix features and specs

  • Strong Anonymity
    Whonix is designed to provide strong anonymity by routing all internet connections through the Tor network, preventing IP leaks and making user activities difficult to trace.
  • Isolation
    The use of two virtual machines (Gateway and Workstation) enforces a separation between the network and application layers, adding an additional layer of security.
  • Reproducible Builds
    Whonix utilizes reproducible builds, which allow users to verify that their copy of the software matches the source code, enhancing trustworthiness.
  • Usable Tor Integration
    It provides a user-friendly way to route applications through Tor without requiring deep network knowledge.
  • Open Source
    Whonix is open-source software, allowing users to audit the code for security vulnerabilities and transparency.

Possible disadvantages of Whonix

  • Performance Overhead
    Running Whonix requires considerable system resources, as it involves running two virtual machines, which can lead to performance degradation.
  • Complex Setup
    Setting up Whonix can be difficult for users not familiar with virtual machines or Tor, requiring a steeper learning curve compared to more straightforward privacy tools.
  • Limited Software Availability
    Some software available in standard Linux distributions may not be readily available or perform well in Whonix, limiting functionality.
  • Network Speed
    Tor inherently slows down internet connections due to its relaying method, which can be further affected by the dual VM setup of Whonix.
  • Reliance on Tor
    Whonix's reliance on the Tor network means any issues or attacks on Tor can affect Whonix's performance and reliability.

SELinux videos

Introduction to Selinux Fundamentals Part I

More videos:

  • Review - Aaron Jones: Introduction To Firejail, AppArmor, and SELinux
  • Review - SELinux on Debian works (but there are things you should know): Quick Guide

Whonix videos

Whonix 15 - Anonymous Web Browsing

More videos:

  • Review - Internet Security Part II: Tor Whonix Tails Comparison and Review
  • Review - Whonix Linux 15.0.0.9.4

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to SELinux and Whonix)
Monitoring Tools
100 100%
0% 0
Operating Systems
12 12%
88% 88
Security
100 100%
0% 0
Linux
24 24%
76% 76

User comments

Share your experience with using SELinux and Whonix. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

Reviews

These are some of the external sources and on-site user reviews we've used to compare SELinux and Whonix

SELinux Reviews

We have no reviews of SELinux yet.
Be the first one to post

Whonix Reviews

Best Linux distro for privacy and security of 2024
As it runs in a virtual machine, Whonix is compatible with all operating systems that can run Virtualbox. Virtual machines can only use a portion of your real system's resources, so Whonix will not necessarily perform as fast as an OS that has been installed to a local hard drive.
Top 5 Secure Operating Systems for Privacy and Anonymity
Meanwhile, the Whonix-Workstation provides a safe, isolated workspace so you can carry out your online activities. This virtual machine is intentionally kept separate from the host operating system and the Whonix-Gateway, establishing a highly secure environment. As a result, even if the Whonix-Workstation were to be compromised, an attacker would still be unable to access...
The 5 Best Privacy-Focused Operating Systems
Developed by the Tor Project, Whonix is another privacy-focused OS that relies on virtualization, but it's specifically designed for use within a virtual machine. This Linux distribution routes all your internet traffic through the Tor network, ensuring strong anonymity and privacy.
Avoid The Hack: 11 Best Privacy Friendly Operating Systems (Desktops)
Whonix focuses on privacy, security, and anonymity. It aims to realistically addresses common attack vectors, possibly protecting users from zero-day vulnerability exploitation. Whonix can be figured to run in a "live mode" similar to TAILS, though this is not Whonix's default.
Best Secure Linux Distros for Enhanced Privacy & Security
Whonix has recently added an amnesic live mode that โ€œforgetsโ€ userโ€™ activities - not leaving traces on disk. The distro is currently working to create a unified desktop experience. Whonix developer Patrick Schleizer explains, โ€œOur upcoming Whonix-Host extends many of our usability and hardening features to the entire desktop.โ€

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, Whonix seems to be more popular. It has been mentiond 13 times since March 2021. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

SELinux mentions (0)

We have not tracked any mentions of SELinux yet. Tracking of SELinux recommendations started around Mar 2021.

Whonix mentions (13)

  • When downloading and exmaning files from the darkweb, what is the safest option for opening a file in virtualbox tails.
    Virtual box Tails is pointless. Just use Whonix.. To examine files also use VirusTotal. Source: almost 3 years ago
  • currently running tails over vm on the most secure settings for both programs what could be a point of weakness like would u recommend a vpn a proxy chain? what would u recommend for extra anonymity?
    Running TAILS in a virtual machine for anonymity is a fools errand. Research Whonix and its independent gateway and workstation VM. Configured correctly the only network interface of the workstation is the gateway over Tor providing a higher assurance of security. Source: almost 3 years ago
  • Firefox with tor?
    Whonix is a Linux-based environment that can theoretically transport any TCP/IP application over Tor and greatly reduces the potential for IP leaks by having a secondary 'gateway' that runs Tor independent from the client device over a private network. Source: over 3 years ago
  • How to Code Anonymously, Part 2: Network Security
    The previous strategy is great, but it's actually easier and more effective to just use Whonix. Whonix is a Linux distro - designed to be run out of VirtualBox - that implements all the goodness of the previous strategy. Even better, it comes with a novel network architecture that involves two virtual machines for extra protection:. - Source: dev.to / over 3 years ago
  • Qubes os Team - issue report
    Since this appears in sys-whonix, I suggest reporting this to the Whonix team. Source: almost 4 years ago
View more

What are some alternatives?

When comparing SELinux and Whonix, you can also consider the following products

TOMOYO Linux - TOMOYO Linux is a Mandatory Access Control (MAC) implementation for Linux that can be used to increase the security of a system, while also being useful purely as a syst...

Tails - Tails is a Debian based live CD/USB with the goal of providing complete Internet anonymity for the...

AppArmor - A Mandatory Access Control (MAC) system which is a kernel (LSM) enhancement to confine programs to...

Qubes OS - Qubes is a security-oriented, free and open-source operating system for personal computers that allows you to securely compartmentalize your digital life.โ€ŽDownload Mirrors ยทย โ€ŽQubes R4.

grsecurity - Role-based access control system, least privilege memory protection, chroot restriction, etc.

Kali Linux - Kali Linux is a Debian-derived Linux distribution designed for digital forensics and penetration...