Software Alternatives, Accelerators & Startups
Register | Login

PostGIS VS Mapserver

Compare PostGIS VS Mapserver and see what are their differences

Preferred Patron
Preferred Patron is the top Customer Loyalty Software Program for businesses in any industry of any size. featured
Contents:
  1. » Base Details
  2. » Videos
  3. » Reviews
  4. » Alternatives

PostGIS logo PostGIS

Open source spatial database

Mapserver logo Mapserver

MapServer is an Open Source platform for publishing spatial data and interactive mapping...
  • PostGIS Landing page
    Landing page //
    2021-12-18
  • Mapserver Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-05-13

PostGIS features and specs

  • Open Source
    PostGIS is open-source, meaning it is free to use and has a strong community support for development and troubleshooting.
  • Integration with PostgreSQL
    PostGIS extends PostgreSQL, a robust relational database management system, providing powerful geospatial capabilities along with traditional SQL features.
  • Rich Geospatial Functions
    PostGIS offers a comprehensive range of geospatial functions and data types, making it suitable for complex spatial queries and analyses.
  • Cross-platform Support
    Being cross-platform, PostGIS can run on various operating systems including Windows, Linux, and macOS, offering flexibility in deployment.
  • Active Community and Documentation
    PostGIS benefits from an active user community and extensive documentation, which aids in learning and problem-solving.
  • Scalability
    Built on PostgreSQL, PostGIS inherits its scalability features, which support large datasets and extensive query capabilities.
  • Customization and Extension
    PostGIS's open architecture allows for customization and the development of extensions to meet specific geospatial needs.

Possible disadvantages of PostGIS

  • Complexity
    The setup and maintenance of PostGIS can be complex for users without prior experience in PostgreSQL or geospatial databases.
  • Performance Overhead
    For extremely large datasets and very high-performance needs, the additional geospatial functionality can introduce some performance overhead.
  • Learning Curve
    There is a significant learning curve associated with mastering PostGIS, particularly for users who are not familiar with GIS or SQL.
  • Resource Intensive
    Running intensive geospatial queries can be resource-intensive, requiring significant memory and processing power.
  • Limited Advanced GIS Features
    While PostGIS offers extensive GIS features, it may fall short compared to specialized GIS software for certain advanced spatial analytics or visualization tasks.
  • Dependency on PostgreSQL
    As PostGIS is an extension to PostgreSQL, users are dependent on PostgreSQL updates and limitations, which might not always align with geospatial needs.

Mapserver features and specs

  • Open Source
    MapServer is an open-source platform, which means it is free to use, modify, and distribute. This makes it accessible for many users and allows for customization according to project needs.
  • Flexibility
    MapServer supports a wide range of raster and vector data formats, providing flexibility in handling various types of geospatial data.
  • Performance
    Designed for high-performance rendering of maps, MapServer is capable of efficiently managing and serving large datasets.
  • Community Support
    MapServer has a robust community of users and developers who contribute to improvements and provide support, enhancing its development and troubleshooting resources.
  • Standards Compliance
    MapServer adheres to OGC standards such as WMS, WFS, and WCS, ensuring interoperability with other GIS systems and applications.

Possible disadvantages of Mapserver

  • Complex Setup
    The initial setup and configuration of MapServer can be complex and may require extensive knowledge of GIS systems and server management.
  • Limited User Interface
    MapServer primarily functions as an engine for serving maps over the web and does not provide a built-in graphical user interface, which can limit ease of use for non-technical users.
  • Documentation Quality
    While MapServer has extensive documentation, it can sometimes be inconsistent or outdated, making it challenging for new users to find accurate information.
  • Steeper Learning Curve
    Compared to some other GIS software, MapServer may have a steeper learning curve, particularly for users without prior experience in web mapping.

Analysis of PostGIS

Overall verdict

  • Yes, PostGIS is highly regarded for its capabilities in managing and analyzing spatial data. It is a powerful tool for those needing advanced spatial functionalities and is often recommended due to its open-source nature and extensive community support.

Why this product is good

  • PostGIS is considered a robust spatial database extender for PostgreSQL, offering extensive support for geographic objects, which enables it to manage and analyze spatial data efficiently. It provides a wide range of functions for spatial queries, including geometry and geography data types, and it supports spatial indexing and topological relationships. Its integration with PostgreSQL ensures reliability, scalability, and performance, making it a popular choice for GIS professionals.

Recommended for

  • Geographic Information System (GIS) professionals
  • Organizations managing spatial databases
  • Developers building applications requiring spatial data processing
  • Environmental scientists and urban planners
  • Businesses needing location-based data analysis

PostGIS videos

+ Add

Como Instalar o PostgreSQL com PostGIS | ALL com GEO

More videos:

  • Review - Paul Ramsey: This Is PostGIS
  • Review - A New Dimension To PostGIS : 3D

Mapserver videos

+ Add

2019 - State of MapServer

More videos:

  • Review - Course Preview: Creating Geospatial Maps with MapServer and GDAL
  • Review - MapServer Project Status Report - Meet The Developers!

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to PostGIS and Mapserver)

PostGIS

Mapserver

Maps
51 51%
Maps
49% 49
Database Tools
100 100%
Database Tools
0% 0
Mapping And GIS
43 43%
Mapping And GIS
57% 57
Web Mapping
45 45%
Web Mapping
55% 55

User comments

Share your experience with using PostGIS and Mapserver. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

Reviews

These are some of the external sources and on-site user reviews we've used to compare PostGIS and Mapserver

PostGIS Reviews

The Top 10 Alternatives to ArcGIS
For those in the engineering and GIS community, PostGIS is a well-known open source extension for the PostgreSQL database that allows for spatial data to be stored, managed, and queried. The software enables users to conduct complex geospatial analyses and – because it is built on top of the powerful open-source database PostgreSQL – it can handle large datasets with ease....
Source: equatorstudios.com

Mapserver Reviews

We have no reviews of Mapserver yet.
Be the first one to post

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, Mapserver should be more popular than PostGIS. It has been mentiond 3 times since March 2021. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

PostGIS mentions (1)

  • Efficient Distance Querying in MySQL
    This is an interesting article about strategies to use when traditional indexes just won't do, but for the love of the index please use MySQL's (or postgres' or sqlite's) built in spatial index for this particular class of problems. It will does this sort of thing much, much more efficiently than 99% of in house solutions. https://dev.mysql.com/doc/refman/8.0/en/spatial-types.html... - Source: Hacker News / almost 4 years ago

Mapserver mentions (3)

  • GIS Developer career path
    If you want to get into web GeoDjango is a popular option for the backend, but you could also learn to roll your own with flask/FastAPI. You also have some choice of JavaScript libraries for the frontend, [Leaflet]() and [OpenLayers]() are likely the most popular frameworks, but there are others (personally I'd recommend OpenLayers as it's the only one backed by OSGeo as far as I know). It also wouldn't hurt to... Source: almost 3 years ago
  • Why do I need geoserver?
    GeoServer and MapServer both have full OGC services, WMS, WMTS, WFS, etc. They have caching and tiling. Accessing OGC services through a web server will require an OGC server. Source: over 3 years ago
  • Welcome to the MapServer subreddit!
    Welcome here, fellow MapServer user! 🗺️. Source: over 3 years ago

What are some alternatives?

When comparing PostGIS and Mapserver, you can also consider the following products

Slick - A jquery plugin for creating slideshows and carousels into your webpage.

Maptitude - Maptitude is a mapping software that is fitted with GIS features that avail maps and other forms of data regarding the surrounding geographical areas. Read more about Maptitude.

Sequel Pro - MySQL database management for Mac OS X

ArcGIS Pro - Explore ArcGIS Pro resources such as tutorials, videos, documentation, instructor-led classes & more. Find answers, build expertise and connect with the ArcGIS Pro community.

ArcGIS - ArcGIS software is a data analysis, cloud-based mapping platform that allows users to customize maps and see real-time data ranging from logistics support to overall mapping analysis.

OSGeo - QGIS is a desktop geographic information system, or GIS.

Loading...