InCommon VS ShellNewHandler

Overall verdict

• InCommon is a well-established trust and identity federation service operated by Internet2, widely used by higher education, research institutions, and their technology partners to enable secure, federated single sign-on (SSO) access across thousands of organizations. It's considered a reliable, mature, and highly trusted solution within the academic and research IT community, though it's a specialized service rather than a general consumer product.

Why this product is good

• Backed by Internet2, a respected non-profit consortium with deep expertise in research and education networking
• Provides a trusted framework for federated identity and access management, reducing the need for multiple logins across institutions
• Widely adopted by universities, research organizations, and their service providers, creating a large, interoperable trust ecosystem
• Uses SAML-based standards ensuring compatibility with major identity providers and service providers
• Strong governance and certification processes (e.g., Baseline Expectations program) that enhance security and trustworthiness
• Reduces administrative overhead for IT departments by enabling seamless access to external resources and services

Recommended for

• Universities and colleges needing single sign-on across multiple internal and external services
• Research institutions collaborating with other academic organizations
• IT administrators managing identity and access management for federated services
• Software vendors and service providers targeting the higher education and research market
• Organizations seeking a standardized, trusted framework for cross-institutional authentication

Overall verdict

• ShellNewHandler is a niche, lightweight utility hosted on SourceForge designed to give users more control over the Windows 'New' context menu (the ShellNew menu). It can be considered good for its specific narrow use case, but it is an older, minimally maintained tool that may not suit all users, especially those on modern Windows versions.

Why this product is good

• Provides direct control over customizing the Windows right-click 'New' menu, allowing users to add or remove file type entries
• Lightweight and free, without bundled bloatware typical of some other free utilities
• Simple and focused in scope, making it easy to understand for its specific purpose
• Open distribution via SourceForge allows transparency and no-cost access

Recommended for

• Power users who want to declutter or customize the Windows New context menu
• IT administrators managing standardized desktop environments across multiple machines
• Users comfortable with older utility-style tools and Windows registry-related tweaks
• Not recommended for casual users seeking modern, actively supported software with regular updates