Software Alternatives, Accelerators & Startups

github-elements VS Element UI

Compare github-elements VS Element UI and see what are their differences

github-elements logo github-elements

GitHub's Web Component collection. Contribute to github/github-elements development by creating an account on GitHub.

Element UI logo Element UI

A Desktop UI Library. Element, a Vue 2.0 based component library for developers, designers and product managers.
  • github-elements Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-08-20
  • Element UI Landing page
    Landing page //
    2018-09-29

github-elements features and specs

  • Official GitHub backing
    github-elements is maintained by GitHub itself, which means it benefits from the engineering expertise and resources of one of the largest developer platforms. This gives confidence in code quality, security practices, and long-term maintenance.
  • Web Components standard
    The library is built on native Web Components (Custom Elements), making the components framework-agnostic. They can be used with React, Vue, Angular, plain HTML, or any other framework without requiring additional wrappers or adapters.
  • Lightweight and focused
    Each element in the collection is a small, self-contained custom element with minimal dependencies. This allows developers to pick and choose only the components they need without pulling in a large monolithic library, keeping bundle sizes small.
  • Battle-tested in production
    These components are used on github.com itself, serving millions of users daily. This means they have been thoroughly tested at scale for performance, accessibility, and reliability in real-world production environments.
  • Good accessibility practices
    Since these elements are used on GitHub's production site, they follow solid accessibility (a11y) practices and patterns. This helps developers build more inclusive applications without needing to implement complex accessibility features from scratch.

Possible disadvantages of github-elements

  • Limited component variety
    The collection primarily covers utility-focused elements (like auto-complete, clipboard-copy, details-dialog, etc.) rather than offering a comprehensive UI component library. Developers needing a full design system will need to supplement with other libraries.
  • Minimal styling and theming
    The elements are largely unstyled or minimally styled, focusing on behavior rather than appearance. Developers need to handle their own CSS and theming, which adds extra work compared to fully styled component libraries like Material UI or Shoelace.
  • Documentation could be more comprehensive
    While each element has a README, the documentation can be sparse compared to major component libraries. Examples, guides, and API references are often minimal, which can increase the learning curve for some components.
  • Monorepo complexity
    The project is organized as a monorepo containing many individual packages. This can make it harder for contributors to navigate the codebase and understand build processes, and issues or PRs can sometimes be harder to track across the various sub-packages.
  • Limited community ecosystem
    Compared to popular component libraries like Lit-based or Stencil-based ecosystems, github-elements has a smaller community of third-party contributors, fewer tutorials, blog posts, and Stack Overflow answers, which can make troubleshooting more difficult.

Element UI features and specs

  • Comprehensive Component Library
    Element UI offers a wide range of well-designed components that cover most use cases, making it easier to develop complex interfaces.
  • Consistency
    The UI components maintain a consistent look and feel throughout the application, providing a professional and unified user experience.
  • Customization
    Element UI is highly customizable, allowing developers to easily modify the appearance and behavior of components to match their design requirements.
  • Documentation
    The library comes with comprehensive documentation, which includes examples and detailed guides to help developers quickly get up to speed.
  • Active Community
    It has an active community and regular updates, which means that any issues are quickly addressed, and new features are frequently added.
  • Integration with Vue.js
    Element UI is specifically designed for Vue.js, providing seamless integration and making it a go-to choice for Vue developers.

Possible disadvantages of Element UI

  • Bundle Size
    The complete library can be quite large, which may impact the performance and loading times of your application if not handled properly.
  • Limited to Vue.js
    Element UI is built specifically for Vue.js and is not easily compatible with other JavaScript frameworks, limiting its versatility.
  • Customizability Limitations
    While it is possible to customize the components, doing so can sometimes be complex and may require deep knowledge of the library and Vue.js.
  • Learning Curve
    For developers who are not familiar with Vue.js, there is a learning curve associated with both the framework and the Element UI components.
  • Dependency Management
    Managing dependencies and ensuring compatibility between different versions of Vue.js and Element UI can be challenging.
  • Scoped Stylings
    The styling of components may sometimes conflict with the scoped styles in your application, requiring additional adjustments.

Analysis of github-elements

Overall verdict

  • GitHub is a solid, industry-leading platform for hosting Git repositories and managing software development workflows, widely trusted by individuals and enterprises alike.

Why this product is good

  • Robust Git repository hosting with excellent version control support
  • Strong collaboration features like pull requests, issues, and code review tools
  • Integrated CI/CD through GitHub Actions
  • Large community and ecosystem with extensive third-party integrations
  • Reliable uptime and scalable infrastructure backed by Microsoft
  • Free tier available for public and private repositories
  • Comprehensive project management tools like Projects and Discussions
  • Strong security features including Dependabot and code scanning

Recommended for

  • Individual developers managing personal or open-source projects
  • Software development teams needing collaborative version control
  • Enterprises requiring scalable DevOps and CI/CD pipelines
  • Open-source contributors and maintainers
  • Students and educators using GitHub Education tools
  • Organizations needing integrated project management and issue tracking

Analysis of Element UI

Overall verdict

  • Yes, Element UI is considered to be a good choice for Vue.js applications, particularly for those who need a robust and mature set of UI components.

Why this product is good

  • Element UI is a popular UI library for Vue.js because it provides a comprehensive set of components that are both aesthetically pleasing and highly functional. It has a well-documented API and a wide range of customizable options, making it easy for developers to create professional-looking applications quickly. The active community and frequent updates ensure that it remains compatible with the latest versions of Vue.js and incorporates feedback from its users.

Recommended for

    Element UI is recommended for developers and teams building web applications with Vue.js who need a wide array of ready-to-use components, value a clean design, and appreciate a component library maintained by an active community.

github-elements videos

No github-elements videos yet. You could help us improve this page by suggesting one.

Add video

Element UI videos

Vue.js Element UI Component Library | Demo & Review

More videos:

  • Review - Element UI Vue Introduction (Component Framework) On Basics (First Look)

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to github-elements and Element UI)
Languages & Frameworks
100 100%
0% 0
Design Tools
0 0%
100% 100
UI Components
100 100%
0% 0
Developer Tools
0 0%
100% 100

User comments

Share your experience with using github-elements and Element UI. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

Reviews

These are some of the external sources and on-site user reviews we've used to compare github-elements and Element UI

github-elements Reviews

We have no reviews of github-elements yet.
Be the first one to post

Element UI Reviews

14 Best Vue UI Component Libraries 2023
This library is developed mostly by Chinese contributors and the original documentation was written in Chinese. Itโ€™s highly suggested to check out the internationalization guide before starting a project, as the default language of the project is Chinese. Element is a great kit for developing complex desktop UIs by teams of developers, designers, and product managers.
Source: athemes.com
15 of the Most Interesting Vue UI Component Libraries for 2023
Element, too, has significant documentation in Chinese, although Spanish and English translations are provided. Non-native Chinese speakers should go through the internationalization documentation before using Element in their projects.

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, Element UI should be more popular than github-elements. It has been mentiond 2 times since March 2021. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

github-elements mentions (1)

  • What Web Frameworks Solve And How To Do Without Them
    Take a look at github's web components: https://github.com/github/github-elements it's similar. There is no library there, it's just a collection of separate components, the only difference there is that their collection is split into different github repositories, I could have done the same, but I chose to put them all into the same github repository. Source: over 4 years ago

Element UI mentions (2)

What are some alternatives?

When comparing github-elements and Element UI, you can also consider the following products

Material UI - A CSS Framework and a Set of React Components that Implement Google's Material Design

Ionicons - Ionicons offers fonts for Ionic Framework.

Bootstrap - Simple and flexible HTML, CSS, and JS for popular UI components and interactions

Ant Design - An enterprise-class UI design language and React implementation with a set of high-quality React components, one of best React UI library for enterprises

Semantic UI - A UI Component library implemented using a set of specifications designed around natural language

Chakra UI - Simple, modular and accessible UI components for your React applications.