Software Alternatives, Accelerators & Startups

Gestalt VS React Router

Compare Gestalt VS React Router and see what are their differences

Gestalt logo Gestalt

Gestalt is Pinterestโ€™s design system. It provides an extensive set of React components for use in building larger web experiences and patterns.

React Router logo React Router

React Router is a routing for React.js, that synchronizes the components of application with the URL & supports server side rendering.
  • Gestalt Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-09-17
  • React Router Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-09-26

Gestalt features and specs

  • Design Consistency
    Gestalt provides a comprehensive design system that ensures consistency across various user interfaces within Pinterest, allowing for uniformity in design elements and interaction patterns.
  • Component Reusability
    The system offers a library of reusable components, which accelerates development time and reduces the effort needed to maintain code, as developers can implement and update UI features more efficiently.
  • Responsive Design
    Gestalt components are designed to be responsive, ensuring that applications using this system provide an optimal viewing experience across different devices and screen sizes.
  • Accessibility
    The Gestalt system emphasizes accessibility, providing guidelines and features that help developers create interfaces that are accessible to users with disabilities.

Possible disadvantages of Gestalt

  • Limited Customization
    While Gestalt offers consistency, it may restrict designers and developers who need highly customized or unique design elements that do not fit within the predefined system components.
  • Learning Curve
    New users might face a learning curve as they become familiar with the system's components, guidelines, and best practices, especially if they are accustomed to different design systems.
  • Dependency on Pinterest Ecosystem
    Gestalt is tailored for Pinterest and its products, meaning that using it outside the Pinterest ecosystem may lead to challenges in adapting the system to different brands or business needs.
  • Potential Overhead
    Incorporating such a comprehensive system might introduce unnecessary overhead for smaller projects that donโ€™t require extensive design consistency or complex interfaces.

React Router features and specs

  • Declarative Routing
    React Router allows developers to define their routes in a declarative fashion using JSX, making the code more readable and easier to manage.
  • Dynamic Routing
    React Router enables dynamic route configuration, allowing routes to be created and changed at runtime based on application state.
  • Nested Routes
    It supports nested routes, allowing developers to build complex user interfaces with different layout components easily.
  • Components First
    Since routes are expressed as components, React Router integrates seamlessly with the rest of the React ecosystem, fostering a component-first development approach.
  • Rich Feature Set
    Offers a rich set of features, including route parameters, query strings, programmatic navigation, and route guards.
  • Community and Ecosystem
    Being a popular routing library, React Router is backed by a strong community with extensive resources, plugins, and third-party solutions.
  • Active Maintenance
    Continuously maintained and updated by Remix Software, ensuring compatibility with the latest React features and improvements.

Possible disadvantages of React Router

  • Learning Curve
    Although powerful, React Router has a relatively steep learning curve, especially for beginners who are new to React.
  • Complexity
    Implementing certain advanced features or configurations, like authentication guards or nested dynamic routes, can become complex and may lead to overly verbose code.
  • State Management Limitations
    React Router handles routing, but it needs to be integrated with a state management solution for handling application state across different routes, which can add complexity.
  • Overhead for Small Projects
    For smaller projects or simple applications, React Router might introduce unnecessary complexity, and a simpler routing solution may be more appropriate.
  • Dependency on React
    As a library specifically for React, it cannot be used with other frameworks or libraries directly, limiting flexibility if you wish to switch from React in the future.

Analysis of Gestalt

Overall verdict

  • Gestalt is a solid choice for teams building products within or in the style of Pinterest's ecosystem, offering a mature, well-documented design system, though it's most valuable to organizations aligned with Pinterest's design philosophy rather than general-purpose use.

Why this product is good

  • Open-source design system actively maintained and used by Pinterest itself, ensuring real-world battle-testing
  • Comprehensive component library covering common UI patterns like buttons, forms, modals, and data visualization
  • Strong accessibility (a11y) considerations built into components by default
  • Detailed documentation with usage guidelines, do's and don'ts, and design rationale for each component
  • Built with React, making it easy to integrate into modern JavaScript/TypeScript codebases
  • Consistent visual language that promotes design coherence across large product teams
  • Regular updates and version control through npm, allowing easy dependency management

Recommended for

  • Engineering and design teams building React-based web applications
  • Companies seeking a proven, production-grade design system to bootstrap their UI development
  • Teams that value accessibility as a core requirement in their component library
  • Organizations wanting to reduce design-engineering friction with well-documented component APIs
  • Startups or teams looking for inspiration or a foundation to fork and customize for their own design system
  • Products with visual and interaction patterns similar to content discovery or social media platforms

Gestalt videos

No Gestalt videos yet. You could help us improve this page by suggesting one.

Add video

React Router videos

React Router v5: Philosophy and Introduction

More videos:

  • Review - React router with hooks ( useHistory useParam useLocation )
  • Review - Nested routes with React Router v5

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to Gestalt and React Router)
Developer Tools
100 100%
0% 0
Javascript UI Libraries
0 0%
100% 100
Design Tools
100 100%
0% 0
JavaScript Framework Components

User comments

Share your experience with using Gestalt and React Router. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

Reviews

These are some of the external sources and on-site user reviews we've used to compare Gestalt and React Router

Gestalt Reviews

React UI Components Libraries: Our Top Picks for 2023
Gestalt is a UI library that helps you create amazing user interfaces that people love using. Itโ€™s Pinterestโ€™s design tool as well and comes with many features and components. Its interface is also smooth to allow developers quickly get started with the tool.
Source: kinsta.com

React Router Reviews

React UI Components Libraries: Our Top Picks for 2023
React Router comes with documentation that you can refer to know how to get started with this tool. You can also access the tutorial available on the official home page to learn more. It has 2.4 million GitHub users, 3..6 million npm downloads, and boasts 600+ contributors from across the world.
Source: kinsta.com

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, React Router seems to be more popular. It has been mentiond 12 times since March 2021. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

Gestalt mentions (0)

We have not tracked any mentions of Gestalt yet. Tracking of Gestalt recommendations started around Sep 2023.

React Router mentions (12)

  • We moved Railway's front end off Next.js. Builds went from 10 minutes to under 2
    That's... Not quite right :) React Router, which belongs to Remix, which was acquired by Shopify, is here: https://github.com/remix-run/react-router Tanstack Router is an entirely new router. - Source: Hacker News / 5 months ago
  • I Built an App with Remix in 30ย Minutes
    Remix is built on top of React Router, which is an easy-to-use routing library that integrates seamlessly into your React applications. React Router supports nested routes, so you can render the layout for child routes inside parent layouts. This is one of the things I love. Done this way, routing just makes sense. Itโ€™s easy and intuitive to implement. - Source: dev.to / over 2 years ago
  • 13 Must Know Libraries for a React Developer
    React Router is the most popular library to implement routing in React apps. It has more than 50K stars on GitHub and more than 10 million weekly downloads on NPM and it's built by the same team behind the popular Remix framework of React. - Source: dev.to / almost 4 years ago
  • Few static pages and react for dashboard setup
    This would be easiest with a router library, like react-router (the most popular one for React apps). Here's a good tutorial for implementing authenticated routes that includes industry-standard details like if the user opens the app to an authenticated route and gets redirected to the login page and then logs in, redirect them back to the authenticated page they first attempted to access. Source: over 3 years ago
  • The Complete Guide for Setting Up React App from Scratch (feat. TypeScript)
    React-router-dom(v6.4.4): contains bindings for using React Router in web applications. - Source: dev.to / over 3 years ago
View more

What are some alternatives?

When comparing Gestalt and React Router, you can also consider the following products

Material UI - A CSS Framework and a Set of React Components that Implement Google's Material Design

styled-components - styled-components is a visual primitive for the component age that also helps the user to use the ES6 and CSS to style apps.

Blueprint - http://bit. ly/bY8LhR Once your keyword research has identified a Site Concept (i. e., theme) and several related ..

React - A JavaScript library for building user interfaces

Retool - Build custom internal tools in minutes.

Ant Design - An enterprise-class UI design language and React implementation with a set of high-quality React components, one of best React UI library for enterprises