Dinit VS Upstart

Compare Dinit VS Upstart and see what are their differences

Cyclr

Powerful SaaS integration toolkit for SaaS developers - create, amplify, manage and publish native integrations from within your app with Cyclr's flexible Embedded iPaaS. featured

Contents:

» Base Details
» Videos
» Reviews
» Alternatives

Dinit

Dinit is a service supervisor with dependency support which can also act as the system "init" program.

Upstart

Upstart is an event-based replacement for the /sbin/init daemon which handles starting of tasks and...

Landing page //
2023-09-06

Landing page //
2021-09-26

Upstart

Website: upstart.ubuntu.com

Edit details

Dinit features and specs

Lightweight
Dinit is designed to be a lightweight system service manager, which means it consumes fewer resources compared to more comprehensive init systems. This makes it suitable for systems where resource usage is a critical concern.
Simple Configuration
Dinit offers a relatively straightforward configuration, making it easier for users to set up and manage services compared to other complex init systems.
Fast Startup
Due to its minimalist design, Dinit can provide quicker system startup times, which is beneficial in environments where boot speed is important.
Parallel Service Starting
Dinit supports parallel starting of services, which can improve system boot times by allowing multiple services to be started simultaneously.
Dependency Management
Dinit has built-in support for specifying dependencies between services, ensuring that services are started in the correct order.

Possible disadvantages of Dinit

Limited Features
As a lightweight init system, Dinit may lack some of the advanced features found in more full-featured systems like systemd, such as extensive logging and sophisticated networking service management.
Smaller Community
Dinit has a smaller user and developer community compared to widely adopted init systems, which can result in fewer resources, tutorials, and community support.
Less Mature
Being a newer system, Dinit may not have gone through as extensive testing and usage in production environments as older init systems, potentially leading to undiscovered bugs or edge cases.
Compatibility
Dinit might not be compatible with some existing scripts and services designed for more established init systems, requiring additional effort to migrate or maintain compatibility.
Limited Distribution Support
Dinit may not be officially supported by many Linux distributions out of the box, requiring manual installation and configuration.

Upstart features and specs

Event-based Architecture
Upstart uses events for starting and stopping services, enabling services to be more responsive to system events and changes.
Parallel Execution
It allows for parallel starting of system services, which can lead to faster boot times.
Dynamic Services Management
Services can be started or stopped based on dependencies like hardware availability, making it flexible for dynamic environments.
Backward Compatibility
Upstart is designed to be backward compatible with existing sysvinit scripts, easing the transition for users and administrators.

Possible disadvantages of Upstart

Complexity
The event-driven model can be more complex to configure and troubleshoot, especially for those unfamiliar with it.
Limited Adoption
Upstart has been largely replaced by systemd in many Linux distributions, leading to less community support and updates.
Documentation
Some users find the documentation to be less comprehensive compared to other init systems, making it harder to master.
Legacy System
As many systems transition to systemd, Upstart is increasingly considered a legacy system, reducing its long-term viability.

Dinit videos

+ Add

SystemD Runit Dinit OpenRC Boot Time #Void #Arch #Artix #Alpine #Linux

Upstart videos

+ Add

Upstart Personal Loan Review: Is It The Right Loan For You?

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to Dinit and Upstart)

Upstart

Log Management

57 57%

Log Management

43% 43

Fintech

41 41%

Fintech

59% 59

Monitoring Tools

55 55%

Monitoring Tools

45% 45

Finance

0 0%

Finance

100% 100

User comments

Share your experience with using Dinit and Upstart. For example, how are they different and which one is better?

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, Dinit should be more popular than Upstart. It has been mentiond 10 times since March 2021. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

Dinit mentions (10)

are there any good reasons for me to avoid systemd
Still, I applaud efforts like s6 and Dinit as competition is a good thing in general. I hope they'll continue to be improved upon until they've become viable alternatives to systemd for most users. Source: over 2 years ago
Gentoo 66 init or dinit
You can download dinit from github https://github.com/davmac314/dinit. (also read everything about it) Do a simple make && make install which should install it to /sbin/dinit No need to remove systemd or openrc. /sbin/init should be symlinked to whatever init system you use. Read the instructions on dinits page. All the services go into /etc/dinit.d. And you can "dinitctl enable servicename" to enable it. I... Source: over 2 years ago
A discussion about the Ultimate Linux Desktop
It got mass-adopted while being imperfect, so that's to be expected. Thankfully its inception and the criticism that followed have paved the way for the likes of dinit and s6. Source: over 2 years ago
Run a script when connection is established and ready?
I use dinit do manage services on my home server. One of them is Caddy, that shares TLS/SSL cert state with my remote server by using Redis on said remote server. However, since this means that I need to have established a remote connection first before starting Caddy, I would like to know of a method to check if tailscale has in fact finished connecting. Source: over 2 years ago
Fastest way to boot Void Linux?
I've used a ton of improvements but I know this community knows a lot more about some parts than me. So here I come. I'm currently using efibootmgr to create an efistub to bypass grub. Using base-minimal with ncurses so terminal apps work. Also I use this in my /etc/dracut.conf.d/local.conf: Hostonly="yes" Omit_dracutmodules=" network plymouth " And that works perfectly. Don't know exactly what network or... Source: over 2 years ago

Upstart mentions (1)

X12
The problem is that systemd vs sysv-init is a false dichotomy. Systemd took over a ton of important non-init functionality, like DNS, logging, and interactive sessions. That could be fine if systemd did so in a nice and rock-solid way, but it was unpleasantly bug-ridden for years after being thrust on mainstream distros via a hard Gnome dependency. SysV-init sucks in many ways, it's well known, and I can... - Source: Hacker News / over 2 years ago

What are some alternatives?

When comparing Dinit and Upstart, you can also consider the following products

runit - runit is a cross-platform Unix init scheme with service supervision, a replacement for sysvinit...

systemd - systemd is a replacement for the init daemon for Linux (either System V or BSD-style).

s6 - s6 is a small suite of programs for UNIX, designed for process supervision. It can be used as an init system, or as separate supervision components.

sysvinit - Savannah is a central point for development, distribution and maintenance of free software, both GNU and non-GNU.

Lending Club - Credit marketplace for peer-to-peer lending

procd - procd is a process and system init service for OpenWRT.

Lending Club vs Dinit