Software Alternatives, Accelerators & Startups

ArchiveBox VS Instapaper

Compare ArchiveBox VS Instapaper and see what are their differences

ArchiveBox logo ArchiveBox

The open-source, self-hosted internet archiving solution

Instapaper logo Instapaper

Instapaper is a simple tool to save web pages for reading later.
  • ArchiveBox Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-06-13

ArchiveBox is a powerful, self-hosted internet archiving solution to collect, save, and view sites you want to preserve offline.

You can set it up as a command-line tool, web app, and desktop app (alpha), on Linux, macOS, and Windows.

You can feed it URLs one at a time, or schedule regular imports from browser bookmarks or history, feeds like RSS, bookmark services like Pocket/Pinboard, and more. See input formats for a full list.

It saves snapshots of the URLs you feed it in several formats: HTML, PDF, PNG screenshots, WARC, and more out-of-the-box, with a wide variety of content extracted and preserved automatically (article text, audio/video, git repos, etc.). See output formats for a full list.

The goal is to sleep soundly knowing the part of the internet you care about will be automatically preserved in durable, easily accessible formats for decades after it goes down.

  • Instapaper Landing page
    Landing page //
    2021-10-16

ArchiveBox

$ Details
free
Platforms
Linux Mac OSX Docker
Release Date
2017 May

Instapaper

$ Details
-
Platforms
-
Release Date
-

ArchiveBox features and specs

  • Offline website saving
  • Tagging
  • Scheduled archiving
  • Recursive crawling
  • Media extraction
  • Article text extraction
  • Static HTML exports
  • Full-text search

Instapaper features and specs

  • Offline Reading
    Instapaper allows users to save articles for offline reading, making it convenient for accessing content without an internet connection.
  • Text-to-Speech
    The app offers a text-to-speech feature, enabling users to listen to their saved articles on the go, which is ideal for multitasking.
  • Clean Reading Experience
    Instapaper provides a clutter-free, distraction-free reading environment by stripping away ads and extraneous elements from web pages.
  • Organizational Tools
    Users can organize saved articles using folders, highlights, and notes, making it easier to manage and reference content later.
  • Cross-Platform Compatibility
    Instapaper is available on multiple platforms including web, iOS, and Android, ensuring users can access their saved articles from any device.

Possible disadvantages of Instapaper

  • Limited Free Features
    Some advanced features, such as full-text search and unlimited highlights, require a premium subscription, which might be a drawback for some users.
  • Sync Issues
    Occasional sync issues have been reported, where articles do not always update across all devices promptly.
  • Basic Annotation Tools
    Compared to some competitors, Instapaperโ€™s annotation tools like highlighting and note-taking can be seen as somewhat basic.
  • No Native Video Support
    Instapaper is primarily focused on text content and does not offer native support for saving and viewing video content, limiting its utility for multimedia consumption.
  • Interface Design
    While functional, some users might find the user interface to be less modern and aesthetically appealing compared to other similar services.

Analysis of ArchiveBox

Overall verdict

  • ArchiveBox is a versatile and robust solution for individuals or organizations seeking to preserve web content. It provides a wide range of archiving options and allows for extensive customization. However, as a self-hosted tool, it requires some technical knowledge to set up and maintain, which may not be ideal for non-technical users. Overall, it is a good tool if you have the technical capability and need to consistently archive online assets.

Why this product is good

  • ArchiveBox is an open-source self-hosted tool designed to help users save and manage web content offline. It is appreciated for its ability to archive web content including static HTML, PDFs, and media files in a format that is easy to navigate and long-lasting, even if the source website becomes inaccessible. The tool supports multiple input methods, including browser integrations, and is capable of running on various platforms, thus offering flexibility and scalability for personal and professional use.

Recommended for

    ArchiveBox is recommended for digital archivists, researchers, journalists, and any individuals or organizations that need to reliably save and organize web content. It is particularly suitable for those with the technical expertise to manage a self-hosted setup and who require an offline, permanent record of online information.

Analysis of Instapaper

Overall verdict

  • Instapaper is generally considered good due to its user-friendly interface, robust feature set, and excellent readability. It stands out for its simplicity and effectiveness in fulfilling its primary purpose of helping users manage and enjoy their saved articles.

Why this product is good

  • Instapaper is a well-regarded read-it-later service that allows users to save articles and other content for later reading. It offers a clean, distraction-free reading experience, making it ideal for users who want to focus on the content. Additionally, it provides features such as offline reading, text-to-speech, annotation, and organization tools like folders and tags. Its cross-platform availability ensures you can access your saved content on various devices seamlessly.

Recommended for

  • Individuals who frequently encounter articles or content online that they want to read later.
  • Users who appreciate a simple and distraction-free reading experience.
  • People who require or desire offline access to their reading material.
  • Anyone looking for a way to organize and manage content across different devices.

ArchiveBox videos

Archiving the Internet Before it All Rots Away (talk by by ArchiveBox founder)

More videos:

  • Tutorial - Installing ArchiveBox On Ubuntu 20.04 Using A Hyper-V VM To Preserve OSINT Investigation Findings

Instapaper videos

Instapaper Review

More videos:

  • Review - A "Smart" Pocket/Instapaper in Notion
  • Review - App of the Week: Instapaper

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to ArchiveBox and Instapaper)
Bookmark Manager
43 43%
57% 57
Bookmarks
37 37%
63% 63
Utilities
100 100%
0% 0
Productivity
19 19%
81% 81

Questions and Answers

As answered by people managing ArchiveBox and Instapaper.

Which are the primary technologies used for building your product?

ArchiveBox's answer

  • Django
  • SQLite
  • Wget
  • Chromium
  • Youtube-dl / yt-dlp
  • singlefile
  • readability
  • mercury
  • git
  • ripgrep
  • sonic

Who are some of the biggest customers of your product?

ArchiveBox's answer

What's the story behind your product?

ArchiveBox's answer

ArchiveBox aims to enable more of the internet to be saved from deterioration by empowering people to self-host their own archives. The intent is for all the web content you care about to be viewable with common software in 50 - 100 years without needing to run ArchiveBox or other specialized software to replay it.

Vast treasure troves of knowledge are lost every day on the internet to link rot. As a society, we have an imperative to preserve some important parts of that treasure, just like we preserve our books, paintings, and music in physical libraries long after the originals go out of print or fade into obscurity.

Whether it's to resist censorship by saving articles before they get taken down or edited, or just to save a collection of early 2010's flash games you love to play, having the tools to archive internet content enables to you save the stuff you care most about before it disappears.

Image from WTF is Link Rot?... The balance between the permanence and ephemeral nature of content on the internet is part of what makes it beautiful. I don't think everything should be preserved in an automated fashion--making all content permanent and never removable, but I do think people should be able to decide for themselves and effectively archive specific content that they care about.

Because modern websites are complicated and often rely on dynamic content, ArchiveBox archives the sites in several different formats beyond what public archiving services like Archive.org/Archive.is save. Using multiple methods and the market-dominant browser to execute JS ensures we can save even the most complex, finicky websites in at least a few high-quality, long-term data formats.

Why should a person choose your product over its competitors?

ArchiveBox's answer

ArchiveBox differentiates itself from similar self-hosted projects by providing both a comprehensive CLI interface for managing your archive, a Web UI that can be used either independently or together with the CLI, and a simple on-disk data format that can be used without either.

ArchiveBox is neither the highest fidelity nor the simplest tool available for self-hosted archiving, rather it's a jack-of-all-trades that tries to do most things well by default. It can be as simple or advanced as you want, and is designed to do everything out-of-the-box but be tuned to suit your needs.

If you want better fidelity for very complex interactive pages with heavy JS/streams/API requests, check out ArchiveWeb.page and ReplayWeb.page.

If you want more bookmark categorization and note-taking features, check out Archivy, Memex, Polar, or LinkAce.

If you need more advanced recursive spider/crawling ability beyond --depth=1, check out Browsertrix, Photon, or Scrapy and pipe the outputted URLs into ArchiveBox.

How would you describe your primary audience?

ArchiveBox's answer

  • journalists
  • lawyers
  • librarians
  • digital preservation specialists
  • researchers
  • students
  • homelab / self-hosting community

User comments

Share your experience with using ArchiveBox and Instapaper. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

Reviews

These are some of the external sources and on-site user reviews we've used to compare ArchiveBox and Instapaper

ArchiveBox Reviews

We have no reviews of ArchiveBox yet.
Be the first one to post

Instapaper Reviews

Top 10 browser-independent bookmark managers for efficient web surfing
Instapaper is a beloved browser-independent bookmark manager for avid online readers. Create custom libraries to save articles, videos, notes, and more. With a browser extension, you can easily save webpages to your Instapaper feed with just one click.
Source: www.save.day
Best Read-It-Later Apps in 2024: Top Ways to Save Web Pages & Content
Instapaper is available across all major platforms including macOS, iOS and Android for phones, and provides browser extensions for Chrome, Safari and Firefox. Its integration for Kindle is also a little bit more traditional, requiring a USB connection or send-to-Kindle functionality. Unfortunately, the ability to directly share articles to Kindle is limited to the Premium...
11 Pocket Alternatives You Must Try Out!
With a plain and simple appearance, it entirely fosters enhanced readability for its users. So for distraction-free reading, start off with Instapaper. With this, you can also send articles to e-readers like Kindle! Isnโ€™t it amazing?
Source: blog.elink.io
10 Best Apps like Pocket in 2021 - Pocket Alternatives
Instapaper has a fantastic offline feature, you can read your articles at your own speed. The text-to-speech feature comes in handy when you want to rest your eyes or read long articles more comfortably. In terms of cost, Instapaper is significantly less expensive than its competitor. In short, it is one of the best pocket alternatives available right now.
Source: asoftclick.com
Del.icio.us is closing down. Time for a roundup of alternative bookmark managers.
You can favorite links, add them to folders, archive them and take notes from their text. And that last feature is pretty useful. If you're on iOS then you can just select any text and tap "Highlight" and that text snippet will be then saved to your Instapaper library. Good for taking notes from tutorials and other interesting articles.
Source: serafin.io

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, ArchiveBox seems to be a lot more popular than Instapaper. While we know about 91 links to ArchiveBox, we've tracked only 2 mentions of Instapaper. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

ArchiveBox mentions (91)

  • YouTube downloaders (and how Google silenced the press)
    Https://archivebox.io/ could be a solution for that. - Source: Hacker News / 15 days ago
  • Linkwarden: FOSS self-hostable bookmarking with AI-tagging and page archival
    I've used https://historio.us since 2011 and still pay for it to keep access to all the pages I've archived over the years. The price has been kept low enough that I can't bring myself to cancel it even though I've been using self-hosted https://archivebox.io/ for the last few years. I always include an archived link whenever I reference something in documentation. That's my main use at the moment. However, I... - Source: Hacker News / 5 months ago
  • Ask HN: How Do You Bookmark?
    2. Drop the link into my instance of ArchiveBox [0] and will return to it a few weeks/months later or, more often than not, never again [0] https://archivebox.io/. - Source: Hacker News / 9 months ago
  • Internet Archive breached again through stolen access tokens
    Is anyone using ArchiveBox regularly? It's a self-hosted archiving solution. Not the ambitious decentralized system I think this comment is thinking of but a practical way for someone to run an archive for themselves. https://archivebox.io/. - Source: Hacker News / 12 months ago
  • Tell HN: The Wayback Machine is up, in read-only mode
    I used to solely depend on Wayback machine to automate archiving pages, now I am archiving webpages using selenium python package on https://archive.ph/ and https://ghostarchive.org/ This told me not to depend on 3rd party parties. Might self-host https://archivebox.io/. - Source: Hacker News / 12 months ago
View more

Instapaper mentions (2)

  • How to become an avid reader without reading
    Instapaper is a bit simpler to use than pocket. It has a straightforward user interface and it will accept most forms of online content that you throw at it. - Source: dev.to / over 3 years ago
  • How I keep up with the latest Front-End Development news, without scrolling my life away
    Here's my workflow: I open the email, scan the list, save the links that look interesting to me in my Instapaper, and delete the email. Later, when I have time to read, I go ahead and read the saved articles in Instapaper. - Source: dev.to / about 4 years ago

What are some alternatives?

When comparing ArchiveBox and Instapaper, you can also consider the following products

HTTrack - HTTrack is a free (GPL, libre/free software) and easy-to-use offline browser utility.

Raindrop.io - All your articles, photos, video & content from web & apps in one place.

wallabag - Save the web, freely.

Email This - Save ad-free articles and web pages and articles to your email inbox for reading later.

Archive.org - Internet Archive is a non-profit digital library offering free universal access to books, movies...

Pinboard - Pinboard is a personal archive for things you find online and don't want to forget.