Software Alternatives, Accelerators & Startups

Asana VS CommCare

Compare Asana VS CommCare and see what are their differences

Asana logo Asana

Asana project management is an effort to re-imagine how we work together, through modern productivity software. Fast and versatile, Asana helps individuals and groups get more done.

CommCare logo CommCare

The digital platform for impactful frontline work everywhere
  • Asana Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-10-10
  • CommCare Landing page
    Landing page //
    2021-07-28

The most widely-deployed and evidence-based platform for enabling Frontline Workers, CommCare empowers organizations to build their own digital solutions to better deliver services, manage clients, and collect data. Built from the ground up to support the complexities and idiosyncrasies of frontline work, CommCare can meet nearly every frontline use case in any setting (including offline) at any scale, from pilot to nationwide programs. CommCare's unique value is its proven ability to deliver technology which is both highly impactful and highly scalable. More than one million Frontline Workers have used CommCare applications to deliver critical frontline services across numerous sectors, including health, agriculture, social services & more. CommCare is backed by the strongest evidence base of any digital platform for Frontline Workers, proving CommCare’s positive impact on organizational performance, frontline workers behaviors, and most importantly, client outcomes. CommCare’s technology grows with an organization’s needs. Users can rapidly launch production ready no-code applications in minutes, with confidence that their tools can be integrated into complex, at-scale ecosystems. Dimagi’s expert team delivers CommCare on an open source, professionally managed foundation which is best in its class for sustainability and top-tier security that meets rigorous standards including GDPR, HIPAA, and SOC-2.

Asana

Website
asana.com
$ Details
freemium $11.99 / Monthly (Per user - Premium)
Platforms
-
Release Date
-

CommCare

Website
dimagi.com
$ Details
freemium
Platforms
Web Android
Release Date
2008 January

Asana features and specs

No features have been listed yet.

CommCare features and specs

  • Unlimited data storage: All CommCare subscription plans provide unlimited data storage, including unlimited storage for data collected in form submission as well as all application data.
  • Surveys: Collect data via mobile surveys. CommCare supports dozens of question types, including text, multiple choice, numeric, media capture (image, audio, video, signature), and advanced questions (GPS, barcodes, android app callouts).
  • Lookup tables: Allow your mobile applications to “look up” information from an external data set. Lookup tables are useful for when you want to reference large amounts of information, such as Weight-for-Age Z Score tables for nutrition projects or extensive geographical locations.
  • Case Management: Basic case management enables users of the CommCare Mobile app to register an entity (people, items of interest, etc.), then collect additional data on that entity over time.
  • Case sharing: Case sharing allows groups of CommCare Mobile users to access data from each other's cases. Case sharing is a powerful tool for field teams that share data collection tasks across tracked entities. It also enables referral workflows by allowing team members to view and update shared cases.
  • Decision support: Complex workflows have the ability to track people and other entities over time and can include complex branching logic and rules for parsing and responding to messages. Organizations that support frontline workers or stock tracking often need complex workflows as opposed to simple workflows (which normally just support data collection).
  • Multiple Languages: Switch between multiple languages in your application, including non-roman character languages. For faster translations, use the “bulk upload” feature.
  • Multimedia Integration : CommCare applications can include multimedia such as images, audio, and video, which can be used for counseling or to aid low-literate users.
  • Data Export: Export your CommCare data—including form submissions and case data—for use in 3rd party tools. Leverage built-in tools to customize your exports by date, user group, and more.
  • Data exploration: View data submitted by your field staff with built-in reports showing case information and form submissions, complete with current and historical values.
  • Performance report: View pre-built reports to get a high-level overview of key indicators and drill down into your data.
  • Report builder: Create custom reports from data collected in your CommCare applications, and schedule automated emails to share those custom reports on a recurring schedule. Subscription plans with Report Builder include up to 5 saved reports.
  • Data cleaning: Ensure your CommCare data is clean and accurate using data cleaning features to edit erroneous or incorrect form submissions and archive test data.
  • Power BI & Tableaux integration: Send your CommCare data directly to Microsoft Power BI or Tableau for beautiful reporting and deep analytics. CommCare's integration employs OData feeds, enabling you to automatically refresh your data directly from Power BI and Tableau.
  • Excel dashboards: Set up a real-time link between a form or case export on HQ and a preconfigured Excel report. Excel calculations and graphs will update automatically on a regular basis as new data comes in.
  • Bulk user upload: Create and update your mobile worker groups, usernames, passwords, and other information in bulk through an easy excel import/export tool.
  • One way messaging: Configure outbound SMS systems that can be sent to both mobile workers and clients for broadcast messaging and targeted reminders.
  • SMS gateways: Sending and receiving automated SMS messages requires communicating with mobile networks. This is the job of SMS gateways. Dimagi’s SMS system comes with a gateway to a variety of countries worldwide. We provide a number of incoming and outgoing messages using our gateways included with each plan, Standard and above.
  • 3rd Party Integrations: CommCare has a whole ecosystem of integrations to explore.
  • Enterprise web apps: Manage complex case management use cases, on-click integration with AWS connect, automatic address capture, custom on-click integrations.
  • Enterprise management tools: Multiple tools, dashboards, and security features to enable global administration of CommCare throughout the organisation.
  • GDPR Compliance Ready: We are fully GPDR Complaint, and offer Data Processing Agreements on all plans. We offer customizations to our standardized DPA only on your Advanced plan. This is primarily because customizations creates additional and permanent overhead on our multiple teams.
  • Two Factor Authentication (2FA): Turn on two-factor authentication for your web user to add a second level of authentication and make your account more secure. For projects on Advanced plans, you can enforce two-factor authentication for all members of your project.
  • HIPAA compliance assurance: You might prefer or require HIPAA compliance if you are concerned about having the highest standards of security regarding your projects' personal health information. Standard hosting is also secure, but not signed off as officially compliant with HIPAA certified hosting. Under the Advanced and above plans, Dimagi ensures that all data that is collected and hosted on CommCareHQ meets the essential security and availability requirements for HIPAA compliance. Dimagi also gives access to signing a HIPAA Business Associate Agreement (BAA) for the Advanced and above plans.
  • Full support: Online academy, direct mail, phone, guaranteed response time, guaranteed follow-up time, bug-fixing support, paid onboarding, customer success team.

Asana videos

Asana Review + Demo: Top 5 Reasons Asana Is The Best Project and Team Management Tool

More videos:

  • Review - Asana: Full Review (2019) (with timestamps)
  • Review - Asana Warning! Top 5 Reasons To Avoid Asana Project Manager (Before You Buy Asana Review)

CommCare videos

CommCare Introduction Part 1: Your First Application

More videos:

  • Review - [CommCare Webinar] Using Case Management
  • Tutorial - CommCare Onboarding Video #1: How to Set Up Your First CommCare Mobile Application
  • Demo - About CommCare

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to Asana and CommCare)
Project Management
100 100%
0% 0
Form Builder
0 0%
100% 100
Task Management
100 100%
0% 0
Surveys
0 0%
100% 100

User comments

Share your experience with using Asana and CommCare. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

Reviews

These are some of the external sources and on-site user reviews we've used to compare Asana and CommCare

Asana Reviews

  1. Good, but not the best.

    While Asana is a robust task management and project planning tool, in my experience, it falls slightly short when compared to Trello, particularly in terms of user-friendliness and simplicity. Asana offers a variety of features such as multiple project views (list, board, timeline, calendar), custom fields, and reporting tools, which can be highly beneficial for complex project management. However, I found that the learning curve can be steep, especially for team members not familiar with this type of software. The interface, while feature-rich, can feel a bit cluttered and overwhelming for new users. On the other hand, Trello shines in its simplicity and straightforward design. The visual card and board system is intuitive and easy to grasp, making it a more accessible tool for team members of varying tech proficiency levels. Additionally, Trello's user interface is cleaner and more streamlined, which contributes to an overall more enjoyable user experience.

    In terms of collaboration, both tools provide good collaborative features like commenting, tagging, and task assignment. However, I appreciate Trello's flexibility with its Power-Ups, allowing integration with a wide array of apps which enhances its functionality. In conclusion, while Asana is a powerful tool with extensive features, I prefer Trello for its ease of use, simplicity, and intuitive design. However, I do see the value of Asana for larger teams or more complex projects.

    🏁 Competitors: Trello
  2. A Solid Project Management Tool, but Not the Best on the Market

    Asana is a popular project management tool that has a lot to offer. It is fast and versatile, making it easy for individuals and teams to collaborate and get things done. The interface is clean and user-friendly, and there are plenty of features to help you organise and track your projects.

    However, while Asana is a good tool, it is not the best on the market. One of its main weaknesses is its lack of advanced reporting and analysis capabilities. It can be challenging to get a comprehensive view of your projects and how they are progressing, especially if you have a large number of them.

    Another issue is the cost. Asana can be expensive for teams with a lot of members, especially when compared to other project management tools that offer similar features at a lower price point.

    🏁 Competitors: Trello
    👍 Pros:    Fast|Clean ui|Excellent features
    👎 Cons:    No reporting|Expensive
  3. Coordinate and manage in teams the tasks and the circulation of work of a plan.

    Asana is a very representative app for the work environment I'm a part of with team members and users it's stellar for: • To manage it on the web and portable devices • With option and manageability on the web • To set up projects and invite team members. • The projects have a roadmap to know the displacement of each activity. • Tasks can contain subtasks to keep track of work • Allows granting tasks, define expiration periods. • Effective and useful for adding files, making comments, and tags.

    🏁 Competitors: Trello, Wrike
    👍 Pros:    Asana proceeds effectively by promoting and supporting the work plan process for each project in terms of: • to arrange and establish the work to be executed for a given project. • to distribute and share among the members the tasks of a project. • flexible to locate and work those minimum activities of a task. • to fix and assign who will be in charge of the tasks. • it is consistent to fix the structured tasks and visualize the phases and their movements. • to set dates for a project from start to finish. • with the option to handle related tasks that in one way or another are dependent on each other.
    👎 Cons:    Asana, is substantial to give continuity to the acquired commitments, it gathers everything necessary for the satisfactory completion of the work plans, being so it is a fantastic application as long as i have no adverse consequences while i am using it.

The Ultimate List of 20 Best AI Work Management Tools
Asana Intelligence: Asana leverages AI algorithms to provide task recommendations, goal-based resource management, and health checks based on historical data and user behavior, helping users prioritize and manage tasks more efficiently.
Source: ppm.express
12 Best ClickUp Alternatives for Innovative Management in 2023
Benefits of Asana compared to ClickUp: Asana has a simpler layout, which most users love compared to ClickUp. ClickUp lacks visibility of team workload, while Asana has a dedicated feature that gives valuable insights into how projects develop. Asana also lets managers track goals and monitor team performance which is essential for reporting.
Source: ayanza.com
Breeze vs. Asana - The best Asana alternative is Breeze
What is the difference between Breeze and Asana? The main reason to use Breeze instead of Asana is because it is faster, simpler and easier. When using Breeze you can talk to a real person about everything - we listen to your feedback, add features you need, and evolve with our users.
Source: www.breeze.pm
12 BEST Wrike Alternatives for Project Management in 2022
Asana is an ideal project management software for small teams. It is available in three different versions Free, Premium & Enterprise.
Source: www.guru99.com
14 Best Wrike Alternatives For Project Management In 2022
Asana and Wrike are similar in their “freemium” payment model, but differ in some other basic capacities. Wrike has more of a set structure for project management, whereas Asana has greater flexibility, similar to Hive. Project views in Asana include list, boards, timeline and portfolios, whereas Wrike has a Gantt view, timelog view, table view, analytics view, file view,...
Source: hive.com

CommCare Reviews

We have no reviews of CommCare yet.
Be the first one to post

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, Asana seems to be a lot more popular than CommCare. While we know about 86 links to Asana, we've tracked only 1 mention of CommCare. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

Asana mentions (86)

View more

CommCare mentions (1)

  • Custom Fillable Form Help
    These are mainly used for collecting research data, however their flexibility could make them useful for your need. Redcap (https://projectredcap.org/about/) you can design a complex form, has a mobile app KoboToolbox - the we form builder can handle complex forms, has a mobile app CommCare (https://dimagi.com/commcare/) a you can design and track cases over a long processes. Source: over 1 year ago

What are some alternatives?

When comparing Asana and CommCare, you can also consider the following products

Trello - Infinitely flexible. Incredibly easy to use. Great mobile apps. It's free. Trello keeps track of everything, from the big picture to the minute details.

SurveyCTO - Collect data you can trust Offline or online, in the field, on the street, or in the lab.

Wrike - Wrike is a flexible, scalable, and easy-to-use collaborative work management software that helps high-performance teams organize and accomplish their work. Try it now.

Open Data Kit - The Open Data Kit community produces free and open-source software for collecting, managing, and using data in resource-constrained environments.

Basecamp - A simple and elegant project management system.

DHIS2 - Manage aggregate data with a flexible data model which has been field-tested for more than 15 years.