Software Alternatives, Accelerators & Startups

Perforce VS AWS CodeCommit

Compare Perforce VS AWS CodeCommit and see what are their differences

Perforce logo Perforce

Self-hosted Version Control Software

AWS CodeCommit logo AWS CodeCommit

AWS CodeCommit is a fully-managed source control service that makes it easy for companies to host secure private Git repositories.
  • Perforce Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-04-21
  • AWS CodeCommit Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-04-22

Perforce

Release Date
1995 January
Startup details
Country
United States
State
Minnesota
Founder(s)
Christopher Seiwald
Employees
250 - 499

Perforce features and specs

  • Performance
    Perforce offers high performance, particularly with large codebases and binary files. It can handle large repositories efficiently, providing quick access and version control.
  • Scalability
    Perforce is highly scalable, making it suitable for large enterprises with numerous users and extensive projects. It can handle thousands of users and massive amounts of data without significant performance degradation.
  • Security
    Perforce provides robust security features, including detailed permissions and audit trails, ensuring that sensitive data is protected and that changes are well-documented.
  • Code Review and Collaboration
    Perforce includes integrated code review tools and collaboration features that help teams work together more effectively, streamlining the development process.
  • Binary File Handling
    Perforce excels in managing binary files, which can be a challenge for other version control systems. This makes it suitable for game development, multimedia projects, and other fields that work extensively with non-text files.
  • Branching and Merging
    Perforce offers advanced branching and merging capabilities, making it easier to manage complex development workflows, such as feature development, bug fixes, and releases.

Possible disadvantages of Perforce

  • Cost
    Perforce can be expensive, particularly for small teams or organizations. The licensing costs can be a significant investment compared to other version control systems, such as Git.
  • Complexity
    Perforce has a steep learning curve and can be complex to set up and manage. This may require dedicated personnel or training for team members to utilize it effectively.
  • Administrative Overhead
    Managing a Perforce server can require considerable administrative effort, including hardware maintenance, backups, and updates. This may not be ideal for organizations with limited IT resources.
  • Centralized Model
    Perforce uses a centralized version control model, which can be a disadvantage compared to distributed version control systems like Git, where developers can work offline and have a full copy of the repository.
  • Less Popular
    Perforce is less popular than other version control systems like Git, which means there may be fewer community resources, third-party integrations, and developers familiar with the system.
  • Integration with Modern Tools
    While Perforce does offer integrations, it may not be as seamlessly integrated with modern CI/CD pipelines and DevOps tools compared to more widely adopted systems like Git, potentially limiting automation possibilities.

AWS CodeCommit features and specs

  • Scalability
    AWS CodeCommit scales automatically, so it can handle projects of all sizes without any need for manual intervention.
  • High Availability
    The service is hosted on AWS, which offers high availability and durability thanks to its reliable infrastructure.
  • Security
    AWS CodeCommit integrates with AWS Identity and Access Management (IAM), providing fine-grained access control and encryption capabilities.
  • Cost Efficiency
    For small teams, CodeCommit is cost-effective as it doesn't charge for the first 5 active users per month.
  • Integration
    Seamlessly integrates with other AWS services like CodePipeline, CodeBuild, and CodeDeploy, promoting a streamlined CI/CD pipeline.
  • Fully Managed
    Because AWS CodeCommit is a fully managed service, you don't need to worry about maintaining a version control server yourself.

Possible disadvantages of AWS CodeCommit

  • Learning Curve
    New users, especially those not familiar with AWS, might face a steep learning curve due to the complexity of AWS services.
  • Limited Ecosystem
    Compared to more mature platforms like GitHub or GitLab, the ecosystem around AWS CodeCommit is relatively limited in terms of third-party integrations and extensions.
  • User Interface
    The web interface of CodeCommit is not as user-friendly or feature-rich as competitors like GitHub or Bitbucket.
  • Regional Availability
    While AWS CodeCommit is available in many AWS regions, it might not be available in all regions, limiting its use for some global teams.
  • Storage Limitations
    Though generally adequate for standard use cases, larger teams or heavily data-driven projects may find the repository storage limitations to be a constraint.

Analysis of Perforce

Overall verdict

  • Yes, Perforce is considered a good solution for version control, especially in environments with demanding requirements for speed and scale. While it may have a steeper learning curve compared to some other version control systems, its powerful features and performance make it well worth considering for enterprise-level projects.

Why this product is good

  • Perforce, known for its version control system Helix Core, is highly regarded for its robust performance, scalability, and capability to handle large files and large repositories effectively. It is particularly useful for development environments where collaboration and version management are critical. Its powerful branching and merging capabilities, speed in handling massive amounts of data, and strong security features make it a popular choice among large enterprises and teams working on complex projects.

Recommended for

  • Large development teams
  • Organizations handling large files and extensive codebases
  • Game development companies
  • Industries with rigorous compliance requirements
  • Teams needing high-speed version control

Perforce videos

Perforce Configuration with CodeCollaborator and PeerReview Complete

More videos:

  • Review - Perforce with shelving operation, Perforce with shelve code review system

AWS CodeCommit videos

AWS Codecommit Hands On

More videos:

  • Review - Introduction to AWS CodeCommit
  • Review - Introduction to AWS CodeCommit: Setting Up Permissions

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to Perforce and AWS CodeCommit)
Git
46 46%
54% 54
Code Collaboration
54 54%
46% 46
Version Control
100 100%
0% 0
Git Tools
45 45%
55% 55

User comments

Share your experience with using Perforce and AWS CodeCommit. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

Reviews

These are some of the external sources and on-site user reviews we've used to compare Perforce and AWS CodeCommit

Perforce Reviews

We have no reviews of Perforce yet.
Be the first one to post

AWS CodeCommit Reviews

The Top 10 GitHub Alternatives
AWS CodeCommit eliminates the need for hosting, maintaining, backing up, and scaling your source control servers. It also allows you to customise access for each user to your repositories, with automatically encrypted files in transit. Additionally, it keeps your repositories highly available and accessible with a scalable, redundant, and durable architecture.
Top 7 GitHub Alternatives You Should Know (2024)
AWS CodeCommit is a fully managed source control service provided by Amazon Web Services (AWS) to host secure, scalable, and private Git repositories.
Source: snappify.com

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, AWS CodeCommit seems to be a lot more popular than Perforce. While we know about 22 links to AWS CodeCommit, we've tracked only 1 mention of Perforce. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

Perforce mentions (1)

  • Repo Structures
    It absolutely is in every industry that isn't games. In games, Perforce is king. Source: almost 4 years ago

AWS CodeCommit mentions (22)

View more

What are some alternatives?

When comparing Perforce and AWS CodeCommit, you can also consider the following products

Git - Git is a free and open source version control system designed to handle everything from small to very large projects with speed and efficiency. It is easy to learn and lightweight with lighting fast performance that outclasses competitors.

Mercurial SCM - Mercurial is a free, distributed source control management tool.

Atlassian Bitbucket Server - Atlassian Bitbucket Server is a scalable collaborative Git solution.

Apache Subversion - Mirror of Apache Subversion. Contribute to apache/subversion development by creating an account on GitHub.

GitKraken - The intuitive, fast, and beautiful cross-platform Git client.

GitHub Desktop - GitHub Desktop is a seamless way to contribute to projects on GitHub and GitHub Enterprise.