Software Alternatives, Accelerators & Startups

PlayCanvas VS melonJS

Compare PlayCanvas VS melonJS and see what are their differences

PlayCanvas logo PlayCanvas

PlayCanvas is an open-source game engine built on WebGL and WebVR.

melonJS logo melonJS

melonJS is an open source HTML5 game engine that empowers developers and designers to focus on...
  • PlayCanvas Landing page
    Landing page //
    2021-09-22
  • melonJS Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-01-30

PlayCanvas features and specs

  • Browser-Based
    PlayCanvas is entirely browser-based, which means you don't need to install any additional software. This allows for easy access from any computer with a web browser.
  • Real-Time Collaboration
    Multiple developers can work on the same project simultaneously, thanks to PlayCanvas's real-time collaboration features, similar to what you find in Google Docs.
  • Cross-Platform
    Games developed in PlayCanvas can be played across different platforms, including desktop, mobile, and VR with little modification.
  • Open Source Engine
    The PlayCanvas engine is open-source, which allows developers to understand, modify, and improve the underlying code to better suit their needs.
  • Fast Load Times
    The engine is highly optimized for performance, offering fast load times and an efficient execution of game code.
  • WebGL Support
    PlayCanvas leverages the power of WebGL, allowing for advanced 3D graphics directly in the web browser without needing plugins.

Possible disadvantages of PlayCanvas

  • Subscription Costs
    While there is a free tier, certain advanced features and additional storage require a paid subscription, which may be a barrier for smaller studios or hobbyists.
  • Internet Dependency
    Because it's browser-based, you need an internet connection to access the editor and some collaborative features, which can be a limitation in areas with poor connectivity.
  • Limited Asset Store
    PlayCanvas’s asset store is not as extensive as some competitors, meaning developers might need to spend more time creating or sourcing assets from third parties.
  • Learning Curve
    For those new to browser-based game development or the PlayCanvas engine specifically, there might be a steeper learning curve compared to other more established engines like Unity or Unreal.
  • Performance Limitations
    While PlayCanvas is optimized for web performance, it might not handle very large or complex games as well as some native engines.
  • Community and Support
    The user community and official support resources for PlayCanvas are smaller compared to larger engines like Unity or Unreal, potentially making it harder to find solutions to specific issues.

melonJS features and specs

  • Lightweight
    melonJS is known for being lightweight, which makes it ideal for simple games and faster loading times. It eliminates the bloat commonly found in more extensive game engines, ensuring better performance in resource-limited environments.
  • 2D Game Focus
    The engine is designed specifically for 2D games, providing tailored features and optimizations that help developers create efficient 2D applications without the unnecessary complications of a 3D engine.
  • HTML5 Compatibility
    melonJS is an HTML5 game engine that runs smoothly in modern browsers without needing plugins. This makes it an excellent choice for web-based games and applications.
  • Open Source
    Being open-source, melonJS provides developers the opportunity to contribute to the engine’s development or modify it based on their needs, promoting community engagement and flexibility.
  • Community Support
    The engine has an active community that shares resources, tutorials, and support, making it easier for new users to learn and work with melonJS.

Possible disadvantages of melonJS

  • Limited 3D Support
    As a 2D-focused engine, melonJS has minimal to no support for 3D graphics and features, which can be a limitation for developers looking to expand into the third dimension.
  • Smaller Feature Set
    Compared to larger engines like Unity or Unreal, melonJS offers a more limited set of features and tools, which might impede highly complex game development.
  • Steeper Learning Curve for Beginners
    Some users might find melonJS's structure and setup challenging if they are accustomed to more visual scripting environments, as a solid understanding of JavaScript is required.
  • Less Extensive Documentation
    While there is documentation available, it may not be as exhaustive or detailed as that of more popular game engines, potentially making it harder to find answers for specific issues.
  • Lower Popularity
    melonJS is not as widely known or used as some other game engines, which can limit the availability of third-party plugins and assets tailored specifically for this engine.

Analysis of PlayCanvas

Overall verdict

  • PlayCanvas is regarded as a robust and flexible tool for developing web-based 3D games and applications. Its ease of use, cloud-based collaboration, and extensive feature set make it a strong choice, especially for projects that prioritize accessibility and collaboration.

Why this product is good

  • PlayCanvas is considered good because it is a powerful open-source WebGL game engine that allows developers to create interactive and visually appealing 3D applications directly in the browser. It offers a user-friendly interface and supports collaborative editing, making it ideal for teams. PlayCanvas also includes a comprehensive set of features such as physics integration, real-time lighting, and support for VR and AR, enhancing the development experience.

Recommended for

    PlayCanvas is recommended for indie developers, small to medium-sized teams, and educational purposes. It is especially suited for those who are looking to create web-based 3D content quickly and efficiently without needing extensive proprietary tools. It's also beneficial for projects that require real-time collaborative development environments.

PlayCanvas videos

PlayCanvas Turns 1.0! Open Source 3D HTML5 Game Engine Is All Grown Up

More videos:

  • Tutorial - PlayCanvas Revisited -- Bowling With PlayCanvas Tutorial
  • Review - WebGL R&D: Unity vs Unreal vs PlayCanvas Comparison.

melonJS videos

No melonJS videos yet. You could help us improve this page by suggesting one.

Add video

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to PlayCanvas and melonJS)
Game Development
86 86%
14% 14
Game Engine
88 88%
12% 12
3D Game Engine
91 91%
9% 9
Javascript UI Libraries
0 0%
100% 100

User comments

Share your experience with using PlayCanvas and melonJS. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

Reviews

These are some of the external sources and on-site user reviews we've used to compare PlayCanvas and melonJS

PlayCanvas Reviews

Best Game Engines for Linux in 2021
PlayCanvas is an advanced WebGL game engine. With PlayCanvas, you can create interactive VR and 3D games. This game engine runs directly from the browser.
Source: kerneltips.com

melonJS Reviews

We have no reviews of melonJS yet.
Be the first one to post

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, PlayCanvas seems to be a lot more popular than melonJS. While we know about 29 links to PlayCanvas, we've tracked only 1 mention of melonJS. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

PlayCanvas mentions (29)

  • Normal Map Interpolation on Deferred Shading
    For some reason that I cannot understand in my case the calculated shading normals are pixelated. Compared to playcanvas.com (probably a forward renderer), mine is like utter shit. Source: almost 2 years ago
  • Migrating from WordPress After 12 Years
    PlayCanvas has been using WordPress for 12 years now. Generally speaking, it's been fine. However, after much consideration, we have migrated away to Jekyll + GitHub Pages. I thought our experience might be of interest to other WordPress users (if only to confirm why you wouldn't consider switching): Https://blog.playcanvas.com/moving-from-wordpress-to-jekyll-a-case-study/ Interested to hear peoples' thoughts... Source: almost 2 years ago
  • I made a 3D editor that models in pure CSS+HTML
    It's just a cool tech demo that pushes CSS to its limits, but it's completely useless if you want to create usable 3d models. If you want to model in the browser, you can check out vectary, playcanvas, or spline. Source: about 2 years ago
  • I made a 3D editor that models in pure CSS+HTML
    The model in the video has no spheres, which is why the performance is decent. In any case, I agree with you for the most part, I'm just lazy and didn't expect anyone to actually want to use this for serious modelling. You should check out playcanvas or vectary if you are serious about in-browser 3D modelling. Source: about 2 years ago
  • Help With Web AR App Project Completion?
    Hey, I do not have any experience with deepar.ai so I’m not super familiar with the process using that platform. In my opinion I’d probably recommend another platform to try and accomplish this. Since you mentioned that you have everything set up in a engine already (lens studio) I’d recommend you just use a webxr engine. In my experience the two best engines are https://playcanvas.com and... Source: about 2 years ago
View more

melonJS mentions (1)

What are some alternatives?

When comparing PlayCanvas and melonJS, you can also consider the following products

Unity - The multiplatform game creation tools for everyone.

Phaser - Desktop and Mobile HTML5 game framework. A fast, free and fun open source framework for Canvas and WebGL powered browser games.

Unreal Engine - Unreal Engine 4 is a suite of integrated tools for game developers to design and build games, simulations, and visualizations.

PixiJS - Fast and flexible WebGL-based HTML5 game and app development library.

Blender - Blender is the open source, cross platform suite of tools for 3D creation.

Construct 2 - Scirra Construct is a 2D game development engine with a focus on building games visually.