Software Alternatives & Reviews

Metacritic VS itch.io

Compare Metacritic VS itch.io and see what are their differences

Metacritic logo Metacritic

Metacritic aggregates music, game, tv, and movie reviews from the leading critics. Only Metacritic.com uses METASCORES, which let you know at a glance how each item was reviewed.

itch.io logo itch.io

An online game marketplace and community.
  • Metacritic Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-07-23
  • itch.io Landing page
    Landing page //
    2022-07-22

Metacritic videos

Metacritic Reviews - Celeste

More videos:

  • Review - Metacritic Reviews - Hollow Knight
  • Review - I HATE METACRITIC

itch.io videos

What is… ITCH.IO & GAMEJOLT?! - Softlocked

More videos:

  • Review - Top 10 FREE Games on Itch.io
  • Review - ITCH.IO FREE Games Jampack Review!!! [23 reviews]

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to Metacritic and itch.io)
Movie Reviews
100 100%
0% 0
Games
5 5%
95% 95
Movie Ratings
100 100%
0% 0
Online Games
0 0%
100% 100

User comments

Share your experience with using Metacritic and itch.io. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

Reviews

These are some of the external sources and on-site user reviews we've used to compare Metacritic and itch.io

Metacritic Reviews

Best Sites For Rating Movies: 6 Top Movie Review Websites
Metacritic is distinguished by its methodology of aggregating reviews. Unlike other sites that simply calculate an average, Metacritic assigns a weight to each critic’s review based on their prominence and track record, offering a more nuanced overall score.
IMDb Alternatives
Metacritic is a website which can be used for reviewing a movie, TV show, or video game. The reviews are based on a Metacritic scorecard in which the range of scores lies between 1 and 100. You can find movies from different streaming web suites No film files are available on this platform. No apps and pop−ups can be seen while streaming a movie.

itch.io Reviews

The best Steam alternatives for PC gamers
The independent PC gaming platform, equivalent to the eccentric bric-a-brac shop selling obscurities from stuffed animals to crystal skulls. Itch.io is exclusively committed to indie games, and there’s a good chance that some of your favourite indie titles on Steam actually started life on Itch.io before growing to become fully-fledged commercial products. This makes it one...
The 7 Best Steam Alternatives
Itch.io has a strange name but a great premise: a place for independent PC game developers to sell their work with a pay-what-you-want model. Some games come with minimum prices, but you can pay more than this amount to help support the creators. Many free games are also available, which you can pay nothing or as much as you want for. Itch.io does offer some indie titles you...
10 Alternatives to Steam for Buying Cheap PC Games
Itch.io is all about the indies. Though most of the games offered on the site and download client are free (thanks to a mobile-style open submission policy), developers can add a price to their games, and many popular independent developers now use Itch.io as a primary distribution platform. There are zero games to be had from major publishers, but anyone who appreciates a...

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, itch.io seems to be a lot more popular than Metacritic. While we know about 7498 links to itch.io, we've tracked only 18 mentions of Metacritic. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

Metacritic mentions (18)

  • What Happened to this Once Great Site?
    It's Thursday night. I'm considering going to see 'Five Nights at Freddies' but not if it has bad reviews. I go to metacritic.com and it's not in the first row. Not in any of the rows on this horrendous website design. What the actual fuck? Source: 6 months ago
  • Any games out there
    Go to metacritic.com and search for highest rated for your platform. With a request that broad that's your best option. Source: 11 months ago
  • What console should I get?
    Go to metacritic.com look at the PS5 and Xbox lists of "best games" do a count of the top 20 for each system and see what system has more games you want to play. Source: about 1 year ago
  • Is there a place that tracks/reports on all new MP game releases?
    Metacritic may be what you're looking for. Source: over 1 year ago
  • Reviews are currently plummeting.
    I think we should always question corporations and whether something is a fluff piece, but I find metacritic.com's critical review scores to be extremely realistic and helpful. Source: over 1 year ago
View more

itch.io mentions (7498)

  • Featured Mod of the Month: Phil Ashby
    Publishing on platforms like itch.io are a great way to get feedback (but see comments about comments earlier!) and to see if an idea is worth pursuing. Self-published mini-games are also a good way to scratch that gamedev itch when it isn't your day job too - I should push a couple myself actually! - Source: dev.to / 15 days ago
  • I randomly got MK11 booster when I haven't played the game for almost 4 years. Is my account compromised or something?
    This guy might not be farming. I'm not, but I have hundreds of cheap games from early humble bundles, huge itch.io fund raiser bundles, etc. Source: 5 months ago
  • [SUGGESTION] If you liked The Painscreek Killing and Obra Dinn...
    I just found this game on itch.io and it's SO GOOD! Source: 5 months ago
  • System Suggestions
    Combat is as gritty as the GM makes it. Healing is TOUGH out of the box, so by default it is already pretty gritty. In fact, part of the crew premise is players can have a few 'cast of characters' that sub in when a PC is in a rough spot. You as the GM choose what type of physical harm to give out, and how often - so it's pretty controllable. Like I said, look at itch.io for some alternate healing ideas if you... Source: 5 months ago
  • Civitai dropped by its cloud computing provider after reports of possible CSAM
    I have just registered at itch.io and paid $10 for kudos. I don't have a GPU-equipped PC, I am just curious about the Horde system. Downloaded the client to my Windows laptop and ran it to generate a 512x512 picture of Julia fractal (my test prompt) with the Midjourney model, there seemed to be no SDXL models to choose from. It took about a minute to generate. The 2nd generation (with the same prompt), which took... Source: 5 months ago
View more

What are some alternatives?

When comparing Metacritic and itch.io, you can also consider the following products

IMDb - Internet Movie Database

GOG.com - DRM-free game store, selling both new and old titles. No clients required.

Letterboxd - Letterboxd is a social site for sharing your taste in film, now in public beta.

OpenGameArt.org - A site dedicated to sharing artwork & other assets for game development.

Simkl - Simkl is a TV, anime, and movie tracker that keeps a history of all the shows and movies you watch in one, central location. It’s a mobile app, a website, Google Chrome extension to keep track of everything you watch and integrates with many TV apps

IsThereAnyDeal - "When the price is right, you will play all night."