UI Playbook VS React Boilerplate

UI Playbook

The documented collection of UI components

React Boilerplate

Offline-first, highly scalable foundation for your next app

Landing page //
2021-08-17

Landing page //
2023-09-18

UI Playbook features and specs

Comprehensive Guide
UI Playbook offers a thorough and well-organized guide on user interface principles, providing valuable insights and best practices for designers at all levels.
Accessible Format
The information is presented in a simple, easy-to-understand format, making it accessible to a wide range of users, from beginners to seasoned professionals.
Visual Examples
The playbook includes visual examples that help in better understanding the implementation of UI concepts, making it easier to grasp complex ideas quickly.
Free Resource
Being a free resource allows anyone to access high-quality information without any financial barrier, which is beneficial for students and novice designers.
Community Contribution
Open to contributions from the community, allowing continuous improvement and updates based on the latest design trends and user feedback.

Possible disadvantages of UI Playbook

Limited Depth
Some users may find the content lacking in depth, as it primarily focuses on basic and intermediate concepts rather than advanced UI design strategies.
Technical Limitations
While the playbook is excellent for visual guidance, it lacks specific technical implementations and code snippets that developers may need.
Design Opinion Bias
The guidance provided might reflect specific design philosophies that do not cater to all styles or industries, potentially limiting its adaptability.
Update Frequency
As a freely accessible tool relying on community updates, it might not always reflect the very latest industry changes as quickly as premium platforms.
Navigation Challenges
Users may find navigating through the large amount of content challenging, especially if they're searching for specific information among multiple sections.

React Boilerplate features and specs

Established Structure
React Boilerplate provides a well-organized and consistent project structure, making it easier for developers to follow best practices and maintain a scalable codebase.
Advanced Configuration
The boilerplate offers a comprehensive setup with support for modern JavaScript features, including Webpack, Babel, and ESLint, reducing the need for manual configuration.
Redux Integration
React Boilerplate comes with built-in support for Redux, helping manage application state efficiently and seamlessly.
Performance Optimization
The boilerplate includes performance-focused tools and configurations such as code splitting, which helps in optimizing the application's performance.
Community and Documentation
Being a popular project, React Boilerplate has extensive documentation and an active community, providing plenty of resources and support.
Testing Setup
It includes testing frameworks like Jest and Enzyme, which facilitate writing and running tests for your React components and applications.

Possible disadvantages of React Boilerplate

Complex Initial Setup
The extensive initial setup and configuration process might be daunting for beginners or developers unfamiliar with advanced React and Webpack configurations.
Overhead for Small Projects
For small or simple projects, the boilerplate might feel like overkill, introducing unnecessary complexity and overhead.
Steep Learning Curve
Due to its comprehensive nature and numerous built-in features, there can be a steep learning curve for developers who are new to the ecosystem.
Maintenance
Keeping up with updates and changes in all included libraries and tools can be time-consuming and may require regular maintenance to ensure compatibility and security.
Customization Difficulties
Altering the default configurations and structures to fit unique needs can sometimes be challenging and may require in-depth knowledge of the underlying tools.

Analysis of React Boilerplate

Overall verdict

React Boilerplate is a solid choice for developers looking to kickstart their React projects with a robust and comprehensive setup. It is particularly beneficial for projects that require scalability and performance optimizations from the start. However, it might be overkill for small or simple applications, where a lighter setup could be more efficient.

Why this product is good

React Boilerplate is considered good by many developers because it provides a well-structured framework for building scalable and maintainable React applications. It includes best practices and optimizations out of the box, such as Redux for state management, code splitting for performance, and built-in tools for testing, linting, and transpiling. This allows developers to focus more on building features rather than configuring and setting up the infrastructure.

Recommended for

React Boilerplate is recommended for mid to large-scale React projects, teams that value architecture and maintainability, and developers who want to enforce coding standards and best practices from the beginning. It's also ideal for projects that anticipate a need for additional features, as its modular structure allows for easier expansion.

UI Playbook videos

+ Add

Vdo UI playbook

React Boilerplate videos

+ Add

React Boilerplate com Redux e TypeScript

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to UI Playbook and React Boilerplate)

UI Playbook

React Boilerplate

Design Tools

73 73%

Design Tools

27% 27

Developer Tools

30 30%

Developer Tools

70% 70

React

0 0%

React

100% 100

User Experience

100 100%

User Experience

0% 0

User comments

Share your experience with using UI Playbook and React Boilerplate. For example, how are they different and which one is better?

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, React Boilerplate seems to be more popular. It has been mentiond 10 times since March 2021. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

UI Playbook mentions (0)

We have not tracked any mentions of UI Playbook yet. Tracking of UI Playbook recommendations started around Mar 2021.

React Boilerplate mentions (10)

Redux developers, please stop doing this!
I worked on a React project in 2019, I believe it was built on top of the react-boilerplate template, and the developer experience with Redux was so bad that I became a Vue developer. - Source: dev.to / 9 months ago
Top 5 React Boilerplates to Know in 2023
2 React Boilerplate is a reliable and well-designed boilerplate in the Javascript UI Libraries, with 28.2k ratings on GitHub. The super-rich component and font base, together with Redux, Mocha, Redux-Saga, Jest, React Router, PostCSS, and reselect are all included. They support SEO indexing. Concentrating on app development and performance is more than enough. - Source: dev.to / over 2 years ago
Redux Sagas firing multiple times if injected in different containers
We are using https://github.com/react-boilerplate/react-boilerplate and have a classic store layout with multiple components. Source: about 3 years ago
react-boilerplate authentication login page flashes on page reload
I'm working on an app with a login page and the rest of the pages of the app (should be logged in to view). I'm using react-boilerplate. From this example, I edited my asyncInjectors.js file to have redirectToLogin and redirectToDashboard methods:. Source: about 3 years ago
Identity Server 4 Social Login for SPA
I'm working on application using a Web API(asp.net core) and a SPA (react-boilerplate). I'm starting work in user registration/login and one of the requirements is to allow for user to sign in with facebook, google, etc. Source: about 3 years ago