Software Alternatives, Accelerators & Startups

Scoop VS GNU Make

Compare Scoop VS GNU Make and see what are their differences

Scoop logo Scoop

A command-line installer for Windows

GNU Make logo GNU Make

GNU Make is a tool which controls the generation of executables and other non-source files of a program from the program's source files.
  • Scoop Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-08-02
  • GNU Make Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-03-12

Scoop features and specs

  • Simple Installation
    Scoop allows for simple installation of software packages using easy-to-remember commands, making it accessible even to users with limited technical knowledge.
  • No Admin Rights Required
    Scoop doesn't require administrative privileges for installation, making it convenient for users in restricted environments.
  • No Path Pollution
    Packages are installed in a structured directory and don't pollute the system PATH, reducing the risk of environmental conflicts.
  • Dependencies Management
    Scoop manages dependencies automatically, ensuring that all required libraries and dependencies are installed along with the main package.
  • Portable Packages
    Many Scoop packages are portable, allowing users to install, use, and remove them without leaving traces behind on the system.
  • Customizable
    Scoop allows users to create and maintain their own buckets (collections of app manifests), facilitating the management of custom or private software.

Possible disadvantages of Scoop

  • Limited GUI Integration
    Scoop is primarily command-line based and lacks a graphical user interface, which may be a disadvantage for users who prefer visual interaction.
  • Windows-Only
    Scoop is designed specifically for Windows, limiting its applicability for users who work across multiple operating systems.
  • Smaller Repository
    Compared to package managers like Chocolatey, Scoop has a smaller repository, potentially limiting the availability of certain software through its platform.
  • Dependency on PowerShell
    Scoop relies on PowerShell, which means it cannot be used on systems where PowerShell is restricted or unavailable.
  • Learning Curve for Non-Technical Users
    While straightforward, Scoop still requires users to be comfortable with command-line operations, which might present a learning curve for non-technical users.

GNU Make features and specs

  • Portability
    GNU Make is highly portable and can be used across various Unix-like operating systems as well as on Windows.
  • Dependency Management
    It efficiently handles complex dependencies between various parts of the software, ensuring that changes are propagated properly.
  • Open Source
    Being open-source software, GNU Make is freely available and can be modified according to user needs.
  • Wide Adoption
    It is widely adopted in the industry, which means that there is extensive documentation and a large community for support.
  • Efficiency
    GNU Make speeds up the build process by only recompiling the necessary parts of the codebase.

Possible disadvantages of GNU Make

  • Complex Syntax
    The syntax of GNU Makefiles can become very complex, especially for large projects, making them hard to read and maintain.
  • Limited Cross-Platform Scripting
    While the tool itself is cross-platform, Makefiles can sometimes include shell commands that are not portable.
  • Steep Learning Curve
    Beginners may find it challenging to grasp the concepts and syntax of GNU Make, leading to a steep learning curve.
  • Debugging Difficulty
    Debugging Makefiles can be difficult, with limited tools available to trace or step through the make process.
  • Performance Bottlenecks
    For extremely large projects, performance can become an issue, as the evaluation of dependencies might become slow.

Analysis of Scoop

Overall verdict

  • Scoop is considered a good tool for developers and power users who are comfortable using the command line and wish to have efficient control over their software installations on Windows. It provides ease of use similar to package managers available on other operating systems, like Homebrew on macOS.

Why this product is good

  • Scoop is a command-line installer for Windows designed to simplify the process of managing software packages. It offers a simple approach to installation by downloading and unpacking software in a well-defined directory structure, which minimizes common Windows issues like dependency hell and admin access requirements. Scoop is particularly effective because it focuses on user space installation, avoiding the need for administrator rights, and it integrates easily with PowerShell and Windows Command Prompt.

Recommended for

    Scoop is highly recommended for developers, system administrators, and advanced Windows users who regularly work with a variety of software tools and require an efficient, lightweight means of managing these tools. It is particularly beneficial for users who prefer using the command line for software management and wish to automate installations and updates.

Analysis of GNU Make

Overall verdict

  • Yes, GNU Make is a robust and reliable tool for managing build processes. Its long-established reputation and widespread use in both open-source and commercial projects underline its effectiveness and flexibility.

Why this product is good

  • GNU Make is widely used because it automates the build process, efficiently handling dependencies and detecting minimal sets of changes in source files. It is highly customizable, supports non-recursive builds, and integrates well into various development environments.

Recommended for

  • Software developers working on C/C++ projects
  • Teams looking to automate build processes
  • Projects that require cross-platform build capabilities
  • Developers who prefer command-line tools
  • Open-source project maintainers

Scoop videos

5 Ice Cream Scoops Compared!

More videos:

  • Review - Hamilton Beach Coffee Maker "The Scoop" Exclusive Review
  • Review - The Scoop: Lateral trainer review
  • Review - SCOOP Review
  • Review - Game Scoop! 698: Spoiler-Free God of War Ragnarok Opinions

GNU Make videos

No GNU Make videos yet. You could help us improve this page by suggesting one.

Add video

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to Scoop and GNU Make)
Windows Tools
100 100%
0% 0
Front End Package Manager
Package Manager
100 100%
0% 0
JS Build Tools
0 0%
100% 100

User comments

Share your experience with using Scoop and GNU Make. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

Reviews

These are some of the external sources and on-site user reviews we've used to compare Scoop and GNU Make

Scoop Reviews

5 Best Windows package manager to use via command line
Furthermore, we don’t need admin rights to use Scoop, I mean no evaluated Powershell or Command prompt to install packages as we do in Chocolatey. However, when it comes to the range of packages available in its repository it couldn’t compete with Choco, moreover, the gist of using Scoop is different. Most of the users use it to get mostly command-line tools such as MongoDB,...
6 Best Windows Package Manager to Auto-Update Apps (2020)
The problem with package management is that the cmdlets are complex. This brings Scoop in the picture. Scoop is a small open-source utility for PowerShell. You need to have a minimum of version 3.0. So, the commands to install software is as simple as scoop install firefox. To install Scoop, you just need to type the following in the Powershell.
Source: techwiser.com

GNU Make Reviews

We have no reviews of GNU Make yet.
Be the first one to post

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, Scoop seems to be more popular. It has been mentiond 162 times since March 2021. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

Scoop mentions (162)

  • Is Using Linux for Web Development Actually Necessary? Short answer: No.
    Package managers – With tools like Scoop or Chocolatey, installing dev tools on Windows feels almost like using apt or brew. - Source: dev.to / 4 days ago
  • Configuring LazyVim and Python on Windows with WSL
    You can use Scoop package manager to install various packages. If you want to skip this step, you can install WezTerm manually. Open a PowerShell terminal and type. - Source: dev.to / 2 months ago
  • Microsoft to force Windows 11 24H2 on Home and Pro users
    I don’t know about winget, but you may be able to install the portable build of Terminal via scoop: https://scoop.sh/#/apps?q=Terminal&id=269082ead77af63e0e77c98c80bef9429504ac23. - Source: Hacker News / 4 months ago
  • Create Your Custom WSL from any Linux Distribution (Part-1)
    While the ArchWSL and Fedora WSL at MS Store may seem great at first before installing, these distros have often showed compatibility issues and sometimes very weird bugs; even conflicts with scoop or chocolatey apps. - Source: dev.to / 6 months ago
  • Git Bash Is My Preferred Windows Shell
    My favourite shell environment for windows thus far is combining Git For Windows with scoop[1]. A simple "scoop install git" will get the environment installed, and give you a bash shell and full access to all sorts of windows-native utilities from scoop. Some would say I'd be better off with msys2 or cygwin, but the former is meant more as a development environment and lacks misc utilities, and the latter has... - Source: Hacker News / 9 months ago
View more

GNU Make mentions (0)

We have not tracked any mentions of GNU Make yet. Tracking of GNU Make recommendations started around Mar 2021.

What are some alternatives?

When comparing Scoop and GNU Make, you can also consider the following products

Chocolatey - The sane way to manage software on Windows.

CMake - CMake is an open-source, cross-platform family of tools designed to build, test and package software.

Ninite - Ninite is the easiest way to install software.

SCons - SCons is an Open Source software construction tool—that is, a next-generation build tool.

Just Install - just-install - The stupid package installer for Windows.

SBT - SBT is a build tool for Scala, like Ant or Maven but with hieroglyphics.