Software Alternatives, Accelerators & Startups

Mailvelope VS Tutanota

Compare Mailvelope VS Tutanota and see what are their differences

Mailvelope logo Mailvelope

Mailvelope open source project. OpenPGP in your browser.

Tutanota logo Tutanota

Get your encrypted mailbox for free.
  • Mailvelope Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-01-20
  • Tutanota Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-07-22

Tuta Mail is the secure email provider with automatic encryption built in. It focuses on security, privacy and open source. Tuta Mail is known as the best ProtonMail alternative as it is the largest encrypted email service in the European Union. German data protection laws which are even better than [Swiss privacy laws]({https://tuta.com/blog/swiss-privacy-is-an-illusion}) make Tuta a great contender in the field of secure communications.

Mailvelope features and specs

  • User-Friendly Interface
    Mailvelope offers an intuitive interface, making it easy for users to encrypt and decrypt their emails directly within their webmail client.
  • Integration with Webmail
    Mailvelope seamlessly integrates with popular webmail services like Gmail, Yahoo Mail, and Outlook, enhancing email security without needing to change email providers.
  • Open Source
    Being open-source, Mailvelope's code can be reviewed and audited by the community, ensuring transparency and enhancing trust in its security.
  • Cross-Platform Compatibility
    As a browser extension, Mailvelope can be used on any operating system that supports the Chrome or Firefox web browsers, providing flexibility for users across different platforms.
  • PGP Encryption
    Mailvelope uses PGP (Pretty Good Privacy) encryption, which is a well-respected method of securing email communications, ensuring messages remain private between sender and recipient.

Possible disadvantages of Mailvelope

  • Requires Technical Knowledge
    Users need a basic understanding of public-key cryptography and PGP to effectively use Mailvelope, which may be challenging for non-technical users.
  • Limited to Webmail
    Mailvelope is specifically designed for webmail services, so it may not be suitable for those who use desktop email clients.
  • Manual Key Management
    Users are responsible for generating, managing, and sharing their encryption keys, which can be cumbersome and prone to user error.
  • No Support for Attachments
    Mailvelope does not natively support encrypting email attachments, which may require additional steps for users who need to send files securely.
  • Potentially Vulnerable to Browser Exploits
    As a browser extension, Mailvelope may be vulnerable to browser-based security threats, such as malicious extensions or exploits that could compromise its functionality.

Tutanota features and specs

  • Privacy-Focused
    Tutanota is renowned for its strong privacy measures. It offers end-to-end encryption for emails and encrypts email subject lines, ensuring that even Tutanota cannot read your emails.
  • Open Source
    Being open-source allows for transparency and community trust. The source code is publicly available, enabling security experts to audit and review the code.
  • GDPR Compliant
    Tutanota is based in Germany and adheres to strict GDPR regulations, assuring users of strong data protection laws and practices.
  • Ad-Free Experience
    Tutanota operates without ads, thus enhancing user experience and ensuring that users' data is not mined for advertising purposes.
  • Custom Domains
    Supports custom domain usage for email, which can be useful for organizations and individuals looking to use Tutanota with their own domain names.

Possible disadvantages of Tutanota

  • Limited Third-Party Integrations
    Due to its strong focus on security and privacy, Tutanota offers fewer third-party integrations compared to other email services.
  • Storage Limitations
    The free version of Tutanota offers limited storage, which could be restrictive for users with high storage needs.
  • No POP or IMAP Support
    Tutanota does not support POP or IMAP, meaning users cannot access Tutanota emails through other email clients, which some users may find limiting.
  • Feature Limitations in Free Tier
    Some advanced features, such as multiple aliases and support for custom domains, are only available in the paid plans.
  • Desktop App Limitations
    The desktop app can sometimes lack features and polish compared to its web and mobile counterparts, which might affect user experience.

Analysis of Tutanota

Overall verdict

  • Tutanota is considered a good email service, particularly for those who prioritize privacy and security.

Why this product is good

  • It features end-to-end encryption for emails and a strong focus on user privacy. Tutanota does not display ads or collect user data for advertising. Additionally, it's open source, allowing for transparency and scrutiny by the community.

Recommended for

    Tutanota is recommended for individuals and organizations looking for a secure and privacy-focused email service. It's particularly suitable for those concerned about data privacy and surveillance.

Mailvelope videos

Mailvelope Demonstration

More videos:

  • Review - Rob Fuller Shows Us Weaknesses With Mailvelope, Hak5 1417.3

Tutanota videos

Tutanota Review - Good as They Say?

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to Mailvelope and Tutanota)
Email
9 9%
91% 91
Email Clients
10 10%
90% 90
Email Service Provider
100 100%
0% 0
Enterprise Communication

User comments

Share your experience with using Mailvelope and Tutanota. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

Reviews

These are some of the external sources and on-site user reviews we've used to compare Mailvelope and Tutanota

Mailvelope Reviews

We have no reviews of Mailvelope yet.
Be the first one to post

Tutanota Reviews

  1. Scotty
    · Analyst at Beta-Test Solutions ·
    Excellent application for free

    Great app for a free service. Standard security features. Hosted in Germany.

    👍 Pros:    Free basic plan|Data protection and security|Well designed
    👎 Cons:    Nothing, so far

5 Of The Best Alternatives To Proton Mail
Tuta comes with automatic end-to-end encryption with post-quantum safe cryptography, two-factor authentication, and zero-knowledge architecture, so your data is never stored in plain text on its servers. You get this protection for Tuta Mail and Calendar. As expected from a secure email service, there are no tracking or personalized ads, and they don't scan your emails. The...
The Top 4 ProtonMail Alternatives
They and their servers are based in Germany where they’ve put a focus on sustainability. Their offices and servers are powered by 100% renewable energy so you can remain secure and help out the planet. Tutanota offers both person and business-tiered packages to get the right fit for you.
Best ProtonMail Alternatives for Secure Communications
Overall, Tuta Mail is very similar to ProtonMail in what it offers. Like ProtonMail, Tuta Mail offers a completely ad-free experience with a set of standard email management features, some email organization options, and a built-in calendar.
Source: canarymail.io
CTemplar Email Shutting Down – Try These Alternatives
This specific court case involved Tutanota and it required them to log and record incoming and outgoing emails and provide this data directly to authorities. We discussed the situation in the Tutanota review, but it was also covered in various news reports:

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, Tutanota seems to be more popular. It has been mentiond 180 times since March 2021. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

Mailvelope mentions (0)

We have not tracked any mentions of Mailvelope yet. Tracking of Mailvelope recommendations started around Mar 2021.

Tutanota mentions (180)

  • European Alternatives to Popular SaaS
    You can also try https://tuta.com/ and see if it works for you. - Source: Hacker News / 2 months ago
  • About Google Chrome's "This extension may soon no longer be supported"
    The essentials for me are private email, calendar & cloud storage. Here is my post-Google setup: https://tuta.com/ is a German privacy-focused alternative that I'm currently using for email & calendar. Easy switch, although I was already using web clients rather than IMAP before the switch. I looked at Proton Drive for cloud storage, but their CEO Andy Yen is a Trump supporter... - Source: Hacker News / 3 months ago
  • Ask HN: Who is hiring? (October 2024)
    Tuta | Hannover/Munich, Germany | ONSITE | https://tuta.com/ Tuta is an encrypted email provider based in Germany. We focus on building privacy and security oriented apps for communication and productivity. We are currently hiring software engineers (Frontend/Backend/Full-Stack) for our locations in Hannover and Munich. We also sponsor visas for prospective team members not currently living in the EU and help with... - Source: Hacker News / 8 months ago
  • Please move away from Amazon for Tuta's Domain Name System
    A look at tuta.com and tutanota.com demonstrates that Tuta is using an Amazon Start of Authority (SOA) DNS record and 4 corresponding Amazon Name Server (NS) DNS records. Source: over 1 year ago
  • Is there a place to suggest software you'd like to be on the AUR? If not, let it be here!
    I've moved on to Ferdium by the way via the ferdium-electron AUR package. I also use Tuta, Skiff, Google Messages and YouTube Music with it. Source: over 1 year ago
View more

What are some alternatives?

When comparing Mailvelope and Tutanota, you can also consider the following products

ProtonMail - Secure email with absolutely no compromises. Get your free encrypted email account today.

Enigmail - Security extension to Mozilla Thunderbird and SeaMonkey

Gmail - Gmail is available across all your devices Android, iOS, and desktop devices. Sort, collaborate or call a friend without leaving your inbox.

Skizzle Email - Skizzle is the most secure way to share end-to-end encrypted files through email, backed by blockchain

Microsoft Outlook - Organize your world. Outlook’s email and calendar tools help you communicate, stay on top of what matters, and get things done.

mailbox.org - mailbox.org offers a secure e-mail account for home and business use. The domain name, me@mailbox.