Jekyll

Website

jekyllrb.com

$ Details

Release Date

-

Categories

#CMS #Blogging #Blogging Platform #Static Site Generators

MkDocs

Website

mkdocs.org

$ Details

Release Date

2014 October

Categories

#Documentation #Documentation As A Service & Tools #Knowledge Base #Internal Knowledgebase

Jekyll features and specs

• Speed and Performance
  Jekyll generates static websites, which means they load faster compared to dynamic websites. No database queries are required, reducing server overhead and improving performance.
• Security
  Static sites have a smaller attack surface compared to dynamic sites because they don't rely on databases or server-side code. This means fewer vectors for potential compromises.
• Simplicity
  Jekyll setups are relatively straightforward, especially if you are comfortable writing in Markdown and HTML. This can make it easier to manage and maintain your website.
• Integration with GitHub Pages
  Jekyll is designed to work seamlessly with GitHub Pages, allowing you to host your website for free with automatic deployment directly from your GitHub repository.
• Customizability
  Jekyll allows for extensive customization through its support for plugins, themes, and templates. This can be helpful to create a unique look and functionality for your website.

Possible disadvantages of Jekyll

• Learning Curve
  While Jekyll is simpler than some other static site generators, it does require some familiarity with the command line, version control (Git), and YAML configuration.
• Build Time
  For large websites, the build times can become lengthy, which can slow down the development process, especially if you are making frequent updates.
• Lack of Real-time Content Updates
  Since Jekyll generates static sites, real-time content updates (e.g., comments, dynamic forms) aren't natively supported and require third-party services or additional tooling.
• Dependence on Ruby
  Jekyll is built with Ruby, so you will need to have Ruby installed and occasionally deal with Ruby-specific issues. This might be a drawback for developers who are not familiar with the Ruby ecosystem.
• Limited Built-in Functionality
  While Jekyll is very flexible, it doesn’t have built-in support for many features out of the box, which might require you to manually implement or rely on plugins.

MkDocs features and specs

• User-Friendly
  MkDocs is designed to be easy to use, making it accessible for users with varying levels of technical expertise. It uses simple Markdown syntax for content creation and has a straightforward configuration file.
• Static Site Generation
  MkDocs generates static HTML pages, which are fast to load and easy to deploy. This makes it a good choice for documentation sites that need to be scalable and secure.
• Customizable Themes
  MkDocs supports custom themes, allowing users to tailor the look of their documentation to fit their branding and design requirements. The built-in themes like 'MkDocs' and 'ReadTheDocs' are visually appealing and functional.
• Built-in Search
  MkDocs comes with built-in search capabilities, making it easy for users to find the information they are looking for within the documentation.
• Integration with CI/CD
  MkDocs can be easily integrated into Continuous Integration/Continuous Deployment (CI/CD) pipelines, enabling automated builds and deployments.

Possible disadvantages of MkDocs

• Limited Plugin Ecosystem
  While MkDocs has some plugins available, its plugin ecosystem is not as extensive as some other static site generators. This might limit advanced customization options for some users.
• Markdown Limitations
  MkDocs relies on Markdown for content creation, which can be limiting for users who need more complex formatting and features that Markdown does not support out of the box.
• Learning Curve for Advanced Features
  While basic usage is straightforward, leveraging advanced features such as custom themes, plugins, and configuration can have a steeper learning curve.
• Performance on Large Sites
  For very large documentation sites, build times can become longer and navigation might not be as smooth as needed, which can affect the user experience.
• Dependency on Python
  MkDocs is a Python-based tool, which means that users need to have a Python environment set up. This can be a barrier for users who are not familiar with Python or do not want to deal with additional dependencies.

Getting Started With Jekyll, The Static Site Generator

Alternatives to MkDocs

More videos: