Instructables VS GoodBrief

GoodBrief

A random generator for design briefs.

Landing page //
2023-10-09

Landing page //
2022-07-20

Instructables

Website: instructables.com

Edit details

Instructables features and specs

Diverse Range of Projects
Instructables offers a wide variety of projects across multiple categories, including technology, crafts, cooking, and more, catering to diverse interests and skill levels.
Community Engagement
The platform fosters a strong sense of community with user-generated content, allowing individuals to share their projects, comment on others, and collaborate with like-minded hobbyists.
Step-by-Step Instructions
Most projects come with detailed step-by-step guides and pictures, making it easier for users to follow along and successfully complete projects.
Educational Resource
Instructables serves as a valuable educational tool, providing tutorials that can help users learn new skills and gain knowledge in various fields.
Free Access
A significant portion of the content on Instructables is accessible for free, allowing users to explore and create without any financial commitment.

Possible disadvantages of Instructables

Quality Variation
The quality of projects can vary greatly, as the content is user-generated. Some instructions may lack clarity or be incomplete, leading to potential frustration.
Ad Distractions
The free version of the site includes advertisements, which can be distracting and hinder the user experience while browsing or following instructions.
Premium Membership
Access to some of the more advanced features or ad-free browsing requires a premium membership, which can be a downside for users looking for a completely free experience.
Overwhelming Choices
With a vast number of projects available, users might find it overwhelming to locate the most suitable or high-quality instructions for their needs.
Inconsistent Updates
Not all categories or projects are consistently updated, which might lead to outdated information or limited new project inspirations in certain areas.

GoodBrief features and specs

Free to Use
GoodBrief is a free tool, making it accessible to a wide range of users without any financial commitment.
Randomized Briefs
It provides randomized design briefs, which can help designers practice and improve their skills in a variety of project scenarios.
Customizable Options
Users can customize the type of brief they receive based on the desired industry, type of work (e.g., logo, web design), and client type, improving the relevance of practice projects.
Quick and Easy to Use
The interface is straightforward, allowing users to generate a brief quickly and efficiently, saving time on preparation.
Idea Generation
It can serve as a source of inspiration, helping designers overcome creative blocks by offering new and diverse project ideas.

Possible disadvantages of GoodBrief

Lack of Depth
Randomized briefs may lack the depth and specific requirements often found in real client briefs, limiting the extent of practical, real-world experience.
Limited Customization
Customization options, while helpful, are still relatively basic, and might not cover specific niche markets or highly detailed scenarios.
No Real Feedback
Since the briefs are generated randomly and not tied to actual clients, designers do not receive real-world feedback or critique, which is essential for professional growth.
Generic Scenarios
The prompts can be somewhat generic and may not always simulate the unique challenges of actual client projects.
Over-Simplified Issues
Some briefs may simplify client problems, not adequately preparing designers for the complexity of real-world projects and client interactions.

Analysis of GoodBrief

Overall verdict

GoodBrief is generally considered a useful tool for designers and agencies looking for efficient ways to kickstart their creative projects. While it may not replace the depth of a custom-made brief developed through in-depth client consultation, it provides a solid starting point for many design endeavors.

Why this product is good

GoodBrief is an online tool that generates creative briefs for designers, helping streamline the initial stages of creative projects. It is appreciated for its ability to quickly produce comprehensive briefs that set clear project guidelines, helping creatives save time and focus on the design process. Users value its simple and user-friendly interface as well as its adaptability to different types of design projects.

Recommended for

GoodBrief is recommended for freelance designers, design students, and agencies seeking an efficient method to generate initial project briefs. It is particularly beneficial for those who need to quickly establish project guidelines without extensive consultation or resource allocation.

Instructables videos

+ Add

Instructables Electronics Class: Project Review

GoodBrief videos

+ Add

GoodBrief: a Design Brief Generator

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to Instructables and GoodBrief)

Instructables

GoodBrief

Additive Manufacturing

100 100%

Additive Manufacturing

0% 0

Design Tools

0 0%

Design Tools

100% 100

Digital Fabrication

100 100%

Digital Fabrication

0% 0

Logo Maker

0 0%

Logo Maker

100% 100

User comments

Share your experience with using Instructables and GoodBrief. For example, how are they different and which one is better?

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, GoodBrief should be more popular than Instructables. It has been mentiond 56 times since March 2021. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

Instructables mentions (37)

Broken Samsung charger
Note that I could not find much documentation on references written on these components and that I am pretty new to electronics but it's something I'm interested in and I love to experiment (I have already went through hackster.io and instructables.com tutorials). Source: about 2 years ago
A compilation of bragging about how much money Beggy claims she has taken (read: scammed) her followers for. All of these have been posted in the past 3 DAYS. Her smug desperation is positively RANCID. Poor little Audrey-Prop is just dangling there.
This person would have better luck participating in contests run by Instructables. Write a tutorial, submit it to one of the contests that are run every 6 weeks(themes and subjects vary from cooking, computer themed, design) for a chance to win an Amazon gift card worth $100-500 depending on the contest. Source: about 2 years ago
Over 11 hrs since she posted this and not a single 🔥 in the comments - I really do love that for her. She's now offering to help you figure out what you are passionate about/want to sell courses on 🙄
Want to know how to make a tutorial? Go to Instructables. Source: over 2 years ago
Help me validate my idea for StrideDoc - an all-in-one solution for creating interactive demos, step-by-step tutorials, and product documentation!
From your comment, I would say that we will work in a completely different niche than the one instructables.com tried to work. Source: over 2 years ago
looking for good free plans to build a shed/barn
Instructables.com is a good place to start. Source: over 2 years ago

GoodBrief mentions (56)

Building first portfolio
It depends on what sort of clients/industry you are targeting, use this to generate ideas: (https://goodbrief.io). Source: almost 2 years ago
what's the best way to get experience as a beginning designer?
Take a look at the kind of company youd want to work at as a junior designer. Then go over to https://goodbrief.io/ and try to do a full project. Source: almost 2 years ago
Portfolio critique(trying to find a job)
Hi - I personally like your personal brand work and your Digimune piece. As a young designer, you're doing a good job of showing your thought process..if im looking for a mid-level designer thats what I'm looking for. The porfolio is a bit light...So I would use some off time to add personal projects. Some great tools out there can help you speed up the process. I use https://goodbrief.io/ on occasion to help me... Source: about 2 years ago
Where can I find practice projects?
So far I've been working with Good Brief, https://goodbrief.io, for logo design but find the briefs are limited with information. Source: about 2 years ago
This is my first kinda serious logo design, what do you think?
It's been a while that I wanted to make my own portfolio but of course, I needed some work first so I worked on this fictional project, Wine. (I took a brief from that site goodbrief.io) Wine is a company that has a chain of stores where they sell second-hand clothing, they stand out for their quality and uniqueness, they want to communicate innocence and at the same time being fresh. Also, their main target is a... Source: about 2 years ago