Software Alternatives & Reviews

CMail VS KumoMTA

Compare CMail VS KumoMTA and see what are their differences

CMail logo CMail

CMail is a free Windows command line mailer with advanced message formatting options.

KumoMTA logo KumoMTA

KumoMTA is the world's first Open-Source MTA designed from the ground-up for large-volume senders. Get a fast, flexible, supported solution.
  • CMail
    Image date //
    2024-03-09

CMail is a command line e-mail sending tool. It was originally developed to assist with testing mail server and content analysis software. As a result, CMail provides many more message formatting and SMTP session control options than similar software.

Features

  • Flexible configuration via files or the command line and optional GUI provided by CMailGUI.
  • TLS/SSL (including TLS 1.3) via STARTTLS or SMTPS (SSL-enabled version). Built-in, stunnel not required.
  • Support for adding multipart/alternative HTML message bodies (UTF-8) and embedded images.
  • SMTP authentication using CRAM-MD5, PLAIN, LOGIN, OAUTHBEARER and XOAUTH2.
  • Unlimited attachments using base64, quoted printable or uuencoding.
  • Wildcard attachment support to attach directory content.
  • Unlimited To/Cc/Bcc recipients, with aliases and DSN options for each if desired.
  • Message bodies using plain text, base64, or quoted printable encoding.
  • IPv6 support.
  • DKIM signing (RSA and Ed25519).
  • Delivery Status Notification and Message Disposition Notification (Read receipt) support.
  • Read message body from command line, stdin or file.
  • Sending via SOCKS or HTTPS proxies.
  • Works with GMail using App Passwords or user-supplied OAUTHBEARER/XOAUTH2 tokens.
  • Written entirely in C - no need for .NET libraries, Java, or other prerequisites.
  • No installation required. Download, extract, use.
  • Free for private and commercial use.
Not present

The History of KumoMTA

KumoMTA is an open source Message Transfer Agent (MTA) designed to provide high performance outbound email functionality.

The KumoMTA project was founded by a group of email industry veterans with decades of experience building and managing high-performance On-Prem MTAs and is supported by a community of some of the largest senders in the world. While paying attention to the lessons of history, KumoMTA was designed from the ground up with new tech as opposed to modifying something that already existed. We specifically avoided making a modification of Postfix or Exim or some other existing MTA and instead wrote entirely new code in Rust.

What is a "Kumo"?

So how did we come up with the name KumoMTA? We set out to build a cloud deployable on-premises MTA that was flexible enough to install both on bare metal and in a public or private cloud. Kumo means cloud in Japanese, so "KumoMTA" is a Cloud MTA.

Why Open Source?

High volume commercial MTAs tend to have closed source code and steep license fees. Neither of these are particularly bad as long as the software is maintained and is flexible enough to modify. However, the kind of people who typically install very complex high-volume MTAs usually want to modify it or integrate it into other systems. Providing an open source option allows people to modify the code as needed, and contribute modifications easily to the community. The email community is full of very smart, creative people who now have an avenue to contribute to a wider community project.

CMail

$ Details
free
Platforms
Windows
Release Date
2006 January

KumoMTA

$ Details
free
Platforms
Ubuntu Rocky Linux Docker Marlin AWS Azure Google Compute
Release Date
2023 February

CMail features and specs

No features have been listed yet.

KumoMTA features and specs

  • Performance: Over 10mm/hr per Server
  • Config As Code: Yes - Lua
  • DKIM: Yes
  • Policy Engine: Yes - Lua

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to CMail and KumoMTA)
SMTP Server
70 70%
30% 30
Email
68 68%
32% 32
MTA
100 100%
0% 0
Email Delivery
0 0%
100% 100

Questions and Answers

As answered by people managing CMail and KumoMTA.

What makes your product unique?

KumoMTA's answer:

KumoMTA is the only high-performance, highly flexible MTA built for senders that is Open-Source with a free license.

What's the story behind your product?

KumoMTA's answer:

KumoMTA was built by a team of industry veterans to address a need in the market for an Open-Source solution that has the performance and flexibility of the commercial MTA offerings but without the restrictive licensing that the industry has grown weary of.

Which are the primary technologies used for building your product?

KumoMTA's answer:

KumoMTA is built on Rust, with Lua used for its Config as Code engine, making extensive customization and integrations straightforward while providing extreme performance and safety.

Why should a person choose your product over its competitors?

KumoMTA's answer:

When an organization needs to send up to millions of messages per hour, or needs deep integration in a modern DevOps environment, but doesn't want to be bound by restrictive license agreements and mandatory annual fees.

Who are some of the biggest customers of your product?

KumoMTA's answer:

  • Taguchi Marketing

How would you describe your primary audience?

KumoMTA's answer:

High-volume multi-tenant senders.

User comments

Share your experience with using CMail and KumoMTA. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, KumoMTA seems to be more popular. It has been mentiond 1 time since March 2021. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

CMail mentions (0)

We have not tracked any mentions of CMail yet. Tracking of CMail recommendations started around Mar 2021.

KumoMTA mentions (1)

What are some alternatives?

When comparing CMail and KumoMTA, you can also consider the following products

blat - Blat is a small, efficent SMTP command line mailer for Windows.

PowerMTA - PowerMTA is an industrial-strength software for high-volume email delivery.

mailsend-go - mailsend-go is a command line tool to send mail via SMTP protocol, written with golang.

MailerQ - MailerQ is a high performance Mail Transfer Agent (MTA) designed for delivering large volume email messages at very high speeds.

sendEmail - sendEmail is a lightweight, command line SMTP email client.

Halon MTA - Scriptable and scalable SMTP server and email framework designed for service providers.