Software Alternatives, Accelerators & Startups

Apache Thrift VS SignalR

Compare Apache Thrift VS SignalR and see what are their differences

Apache Thrift logo Apache Thrift

An interface definition language and communication protocol for creating cross-language services.

SignalR logo SignalR

SignalR is a server-side software system designed for writing scalable Internet applications, notably web servers.
  • Apache Thrift Landing page
    Landing page //
    2019-07-12
  • SignalR Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-09-20

Apache Thrift features and specs

  • Cross-Language Support
    Apache Thrift supports numerous programming languages including Java, Python, C++, Ruby, and more, enabling seamless communication between services written in different languages.
  • Efficient Serialization
    Thrift offers efficient binary serialization which helps in reducing the payload size and improves the communication speed between services.
  • Service Definition Flexibility
    Thrift provides a robust interface definition language (IDL) for defining and generating code for services with strict type checking, fostering strong contract interfaces.
  • Scalability
    Due to its lightweight and efficient serialization mechanisms, Apache Thrift can handle a large number of simultaneous client connections, making it suitable for scalable distributed systems.
  • Versioning Support
    Thrift supports service versioning which helps in evolving APIs without disrupting existing services or clients.

Possible disadvantages of Apache Thrift

  • Steep Learning Curve
    For new users, especially those not familiar with RPC frameworks, learning and understanding Thrift’s IDL and operations can be complex and time-consuming.
  • Documentation and Community Support
    Compared to some alternative technologies, Apache Thrift's documentation and community support can be less robust, which might pose challenges in troubleshooting or seeking guidance.
  • Lack of Advanced Features
    Thrift does not support some advanced features like streaming or multiplexing out of the box, which could limit its use in complex systems requiring these functionalities.
  • Infrastructure Overhead
    Integrating Thrift into an existing system might introduce infrastructure overhead both in initial setup and ongoing maintenance, especially when dealing with multiple languages.
  • Protocol Limitations
    While Thrift is highly efficient, its protocol limitations might require additional workarounds for certain data structures or transport mechanisms, complicating development.

SignalR features and specs

  • Real-time communication
    SignalR enables real-time web functionality, allowing server-side code to push content to connected clients instantly. This is crucial for applications like live chat, real-time notifications, and live data feeds.
  • Simplified development
    SignalR provides a high-level API that abstracts much of the complexity involved in creating real-time web applications, making the development process easier and more efficient.
  • Automatic Reconnection
    SignalR includes automatic reconnection capabilities, so if a client connection is lost, it can automatically try to re-establish the connection without manual intervention.
  • Cross-platform support
    Being part of the ASP.NET Core suite, SignalR works across different platforms including Windows, macOS, and Linux, providing greater flexibility in deployment.
  • Transport fallback
    SignalR supports multiple transport protocols (WebSocket, Server-Sent Events, and Long Polling) and can smoothly fall back to a lesser protocol if the preferred one is not available.
  • Security
    SignalR comes with built-in support for authentication and authorization mechanisms to ensure that only authorized users can connect and communicate through the service.

Possible disadvantages of SignalR

  • Scalability concerns
    While SignalR works well for small to medium applications, scaling to a large number of concurrent connections can require significant investments in infrastructure, such as deploying a SignalR backplane.
  • Performance overhead
    The abstraction provided by SignalR can introduce performance overhead, which may not be suitable for applications demanding high performance and low latency.
  • Limited PaaS support
    Although SignalR can be hosted on various platforms, its integration with some Platform as a Service (PaaS) offerings is less mature compared to other technologies designed for real-time communication.
  • Complex deployment
    Setting up a SignalR application, especially with considerations for scaling and high availability, can be complex and require deep knowledge of the underlying infrastructure.
  • Client compatibility
    While SignalR supports multiple clients including JavaScript, .NET, and Java, it may still face compatibility issues with less commonly used technologies or older client systems.
  • Debugging challenges
    Debugging real-time applications built with SignalR can be more challenging compared to traditional web applications due to their asynchronous nature and multiple transport protocols.

Apache Thrift videos

Apache Thrift

SignalR videos

SignalR Tutorial 1 - What is SignalR?

More videos:

  • Review - SignalR Deep Dive: Building Servers - David Fowler & Damian Edwards
  • Tutorial - SignalR Tutorial 3 - Why Use SignalR?
  • Review - Real-time web applications with ASP.NET Core SignalR

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to Apache Thrift and SignalR)
Web Servers
100 100%
0% 0
Developer Tools
18 18%
82% 82
Web And Application Servers
App Development
0 0%
100% 100

User comments

Share your experience with using Apache Thrift and SignalR. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

Reviews

These are some of the external sources and on-site user reviews we've used to compare Apache Thrift and SignalR

Apache Thrift Reviews

We have no reviews of Apache Thrift yet.
Be the first one to post

SignalR Reviews

Essential .NET Core Libraries that Every Programmer should know
You can include it in your code by configuring the SignalR API, which creates remote procedure calls for the server-client architecture. In addition, it manages the communication channel and resources for seamlessly transferring data during high traffic.
Source: positiwise.com
12 Most Preferred latest .NET Libraries of 2022
SignalR offers real-time web integration for .NET core apps through its SignalR .NET core library. Using it, developers can push/add data from the server into their applications. Features: Automatic connection management. Simultaneous message-sending to all clients. Scalable to handle increasing traffic. A group of clients can be notified at once with a message.
Source: www.bigscal.com
SignalR Alternatives
SignalR is basically used to allow connection between client and server or vice-versa. It is a type of bi-directional communication between both the client and server. SignalR is compatible with web sockets and many other connections, which help in the direct push of content over the server. There are many alternatives for signalR that are used, like Firebase, pusher,...
Source: www.educba.com

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, Apache Thrift should be more popular than SignalR. It has been mentiond 13 times since March 2021. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

Apache Thrift mentions (13)

  • Show HN: TypeSchema – A JSON specification to describe data models
    I once read a paper about Apache/Meta Thrift [1,2]. It allows you to define data types/interfaces in a definition file and generate code for many programming languages. It was specifically designed for RPCs and microservices. [1]: https://thrift.apache.org/. - Source: Hacker News / 6 months ago
  • Delving Deeper: Enriching Microservices with Golang with CloudWeGo
    While gRPC and Apache Thrift have served the microservice architecture well, CloudWeGo's advanced features and performance metrics set it apart as a promising open source solution for the future. - Source: dev.to / about 1 year ago
  • Reddit System Design/Architecture
    Services in general communicate via Thrift (and in some cases HTTP). Source: about 2 years ago
  • Universal type language!
    Protocol Buffers is the most popular one, but there are many others such as Apache Thrift and my own Typical. Source: about 2 years ago
  • You worked on it? Why is it slow then?
    RPC is not strictly OO, but you can think of RPC calls like method calls. In general it will reflect your interface design and doesn't have to be top-down, although a good project usually will look that way. A good contrast to REST where you use POST/PUT/GET/DELETE pattern on resources where as a procedure call could be a lot more flexible and potentially lighter weight. Think of it like defining methods in code... Source: over 2 years ago
View more

SignalR mentions (5)

  • Get Started with Serverless Architectures: Top Tools You Need to Know
    Azure Functions integrates with most tools in the Microsoft ecosystem, including Azure Queue (adding messages to a queue) and SignalR (sending real-time updates). This makes Azure Functions the perfect choice for real-time applications like chat apps. Here are the top features:. - Source: dev.to / about 1 month ago
  • How can I achieve client-server communication as seamless as Blazor Server for Blazor WebAssembly?
    Blazor Server basically has the server remote control puppet everything on the client through SignalR. Source: almost 2 years ago
  • Creating a Lightweight Connection Between C# and Python - Over Internet
    SignalR is a layer over websockets, and is available for python. Source: about 2 years ago
  • I'm new to C#, have a little C++ and Java experience from high school and college. My goal is to make an application for two players to play Go.
    Since Go is a pretty simple game and not very graphic intensive, a simple approach would be to use SignalR on ASP.NET, where the server maintains the game board state and just sends minimal messages (for example, piece X moved to location Y, and whose turn it is now) to each player after their respective move in turn. Source: about 2 years ago
  • .NET Modern Task Scheduler
    SignalR and Pinia for real-time stat updates in the dashboard UI. Source: about 2 years ago

What are some alternatives?

When comparing Apache Thrift and SignalR, you can also consider the following products

Docker Hub - Docker Hub is a cloud-based registry service

Socket.io - Realtime application framework (Node.JS server)

Eureka - Eureka is a contact center and enterprise performance through speech analytics that immediately reveals insights from automated analysis of communications including calls, chat, email, texts, social media, surveys and more.

Firebase - Firebase is a cloud service designed to power real-time, collaborative applications for mobile and web.

Traefik - Load Balancer / Reverse Proxy

Pusher - Pusher is a hosted API for quickly, easily and securely adding scalable realtime functionality via WebSockets to web and mobile apps.