Software Alternatives, Accelerators & Startups

Ansible VS PowerShell

Compare Ansible VS PowerShell and see what are their differences

Ansible logo Ansible

Radically simple configuration-management, application deployment, task-execution, and multi-node orchestration engine

PowerShell logo PowerShell

Download WMF. Windows Management Framework contains the latest versions of PowerShell, DSC, WMI, and WinRM for older versions of Windows. PowerShell Module Browser. Search for PowerShell modules and cmdlets.
  • Ansible Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-02-05
  • PowerShell Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-03-14

We recommend LibHunt PowerShell for discovery and comparisons of trending PowerShell projects.

Ansible features and specs

  • Agentless
    Ansible is agentless, meaning it doesn't require any software to be installed on the remote nodes. This simplifies management and reduces overhead.
  • Ease of Use
    Ansible uses a simple, easy-to-read YAML syntax for its playbooks, reducing the learning curve and making it accessible to those without extensive programming experience.
  • Scalability
    Ansible is designed to handle large-scale deployments, making it suitable for managing numerous machines or services efficiently.
  • Extensive Modules
    Ansible has a rich library of modules that support a wide variety of system tasks, cloud providers, and application deployments, offering great versatility.
  • Strong Community
    There is a large and active Ansible community that contributes to its development and provides support, which can be valuable for troubleshooting and learning best practices.
  • Idempotency
    Tasks in Ansible are idempotent, meaning they can be run multiple times without changing the system beyond the intended final state, ensuring reliable deployments.

Possible disadvantages of Ansible

  • Performance Overhead
    Being agentless, Ansible relies on SSH for communication with nodes, which can add performance overhead, especially when managing a large number of hosts.
  • Limited Windows Support
    Ansible's core is primarily designed for Unix-like systems, and while there is support for Windows, it's not as robust or as seamless as it is for Unix/Linux systems.
  • Lack of Built-in Error Handling
    Ansible's error handling is somewhat rudimentary out-of-the-box. Complex error handling scenarios often require custom solutions, which can complicate playbooks.
  • Learning Curve for Complex Scenarios
    While simple tasks are easy to set up, more complex configurations can become challenging quickly and may require a deep understanding of Ansible's modules and templating.
  • Reliance on YAML
    The use of YAML, while human-readable, can be prone to syntax errors such as incorrect indentation, which can potentially lead to hard-to-track-down bugs.
  • Dependency on Python
    Ansible requires Python to be installed on managed nodes. This could be an issue in environments where it's not feasible or desired to have Python installed.

PowerShell features and specs

  • Integration with Windows
    PowerShell is tightly integrated with the Windows operating system, allowing for easy manipulation of system components such as the registry, file system, and event logs.
  • Object-oriented output
    PowerShell outputs objects rather than plain text, making it easier to manipulate and pass data between different commands and scripts.
  • Rich Scripting Capabilities
    PowerShell includes robust scripting capabilities, supporting loops, conditionals, and error handling, which allows for the automation of complex tasks.
  • Extensibility
    PowerShell can be extended with custom cmdlets and modules, and it supports .NET Framework libraries, enabling powerful and flexible functionalities.
  • Remote Management
    PowerShell offers remote management capabilities through PowerShell Remoting, allowing administrators to run commands and scripts on remote systems efficiently.
  • Cross-Platform Support
    With the introduction of PowerShell Core, it has become cross-platform, running on Windows, macOS, and Linux.

Possible disadvantages of PowerShell

  • Steep Learning Curve
    PowerShell's syntax and concepts can be challenging for beginners, especially those without prior programming or scripting experience.
  • Performance Issues
    PowerShell scripts can be slower compared to compiled code, making it less suitable for performance-critical applications.
  • Complexity
    The rich feature set and extensive capabilities can make PowerShell scripts complex and harder to maintain, especially for large-scale operations.
  • Security Risks
    If not properly managed, PowerShell can be used to execute malicious scripts, posing security risks in environments where execution policy and script signing are not enforced.
  • Dependency on .NET Framework
    PowerShell's dependency on the .NET Framework may pose compatibility issues for specific modules or scripts, especially when operating in environments where the .NET Framework is not fully supported.
  • Limited GUI support
    PowerShell is primarily a command-line tool and lacks the native GUI capabilities found in some other scripting environments or management consoles.

Analysis of Ansible

Overall verdict

  • Ansible is a powerful and versatile tool for automation, suited to a variety of use cases, from configuration management to application deployment. Its simplicity, flexibility, and broad community support make it a popular choice among DevOps professionals.

Why this product is good

  • Ansible is considered good because it is an open-source automation tool that is simple to set up and use. It uses a straightforward language (YAML) for its playbooks, which makes it accessible to both developers and IT operations. Ansible is agentless, meaning it connects to nodes using SSH, which simplifies management and enhances security. It also has strong community support and thorough documentation.

Recommended for

  • System administrators seeking to automate configuration management
  • DevOps teams looking to streamline application deployment processes
  • Organizations aiming to implement Infrastructure as Code (IaC)
  • IT professionals who prefer an agentless approach to automation
  • Teams interested in a tool with strong community support and extensive integrations

Analysis of PowerShell

Overall verdict

  • Yes, PowerShell is highly regarded as a reliable and effective tool for automation and management tasks, particularly in Windows environments. The detailed documentation on learn.microsoft.com makes it accessible and useful for both beginners and experienced users.

Why this product is good

  • PowerShell, as documented on learn.microsoft.com, is a versatile and powerful scripting language designed by Microsoft for task automation and configuration management. It's particularly beneficial due to its deep integration with Windows and other Microsoft products, allowing users to automate complex administrative tasks, manage system resources efficiently, and handle various IT environments. The official documentation provides comprehensive resources, tutorials, and examples that facilitate learning and mastering the tool effectively.

Recommended for

  • System Administrators
  • IT Professionals
  • Developers working with Windows environments
  • Individuals looking to automate Windows tasks
  • Users interested in managing Microsoft services and applications

Ansible videos

What Is Ansible? | How Ansible Works? | Ansible Tutorial For Beginners | DevOps Tools | Simplilearn

More videos:

  • Review - Automation with Ansible Playbooks | Review on Ansible Architecture
  • Review - Book Review : Mastering Ansible (Jesse Keating) by Zareef Ahmed

PowerShell videos

Logitech Powershell Review!

More videos:

  • Review - iPhone Gamepad - Logitech Powershell Review
  • Review - What is the difference between Cmd, PowerShell, and Bash? | One Dev Question

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to Ansible and PowerShell)
DevOps Tools
100 100%
0% 0
SSH
0 0%
100% 100
Continuous Integration
100 100%
0% 0
Server Management
0 0%
100% 100

User comments

Share your experience with using Ansible and PowerShell. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

Reviews

These are some of the external sources and on-site user reviews we've used to compare Ansible and PowerShell

Ansible Reviews

What Are The Best Alternatives To Ansible? | Attune, Jenkins &, etc.
To put it simply, Ansible automates a wide range of IT aspects that includes configuration management, application deployment, cloud provisioning, etc. Plus, while using Ansible, you can patch your application, automate deployments, and run compliances and governance on your application. You can easily manage it by using a web interface known as Ansible Tower. Furthermore,...
Best 8 Ansible Alternatives & equivalent in 2022
Ansible is a simple IT automation tool that is easy to deploy. It connects to your nodes and pushes out small programs called “Ansible modules” to those nodes. Then it executes these models over SSH and removes them when finished. The library of modules will reside on any machine, therefore there is no requirement for any servers and databases.
Source: www.guru99.com
Top 5 Ansible Alternatives in 2022: Server Automation Solutions by Alexander Fashakin on the 19th Aug 2021 facebook Linked In Twitter
Your project connects to Ansible through nodes called Ansible Modules. You can use these modules to manage your project. As an agentless architecture, Ansible allows you to run modules on any system or server. It doesn’t require client/server software or an agent to be installed. With Ansible, you can use Python Paramiko modules or SSH protocols.
Ansible vs Chef: What’s the Difference?
For Ansible, Simplilearn presents the Ansible Foundation Training Course. Ansible 2.0, a simple, popular, agent-free tool in the automation domain, helps increase team productivity and improve business outcomes. Learn with
Chef vs Puppet vs Ansible
Ansible supports considerable ease of learning for the management of configurations due to YAML as the foundation language. YAML (Yet Another Markup Language) is closely similar to English and is human-readable. The server can help in pushing configurations to all the nodes. The applications of Ansible are clearly suitable for real-time execution along with the facility of...

PowerShell Reviews

We have no reviews of PowerShell yet.
Be the first one to post

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, PowerShell should be more popular than Ansible. It has been mentiond 23 times since March 2021. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

Ansible mentions (9)

  • Mentorship Group
    We are open to practice using any open-source project, however, we want to set a sharp focus on projects maintained by the Red Hat, and our own projects in the Caravana Cloud organization on github. If there is no reason to do differently, we'll build using technologies such as OpenShift, Quarkus, Ansible and related projects. - Source: dev.to / almost 2 years ago
  • Observability Mythbusters: Yes, Observability-Landscape-as-Code is a Thing
    *Codifying the deployment of the OTel Collector *(to Nomad, Kubernetes, or a VM) using tools such as Terraform, Pulumi, or Ansible. The Collector funnels your OTel data to your Observability back-end. ✅. - Source: dev.to / almost 3 years ago
  • Maintenance mode - vmware.vmware_rest Ansible collection
    Most of what I've learnt today was purley from this blog and only because it's from ansible.com - dated now I guess ... Source: almost 3 years ago
  • Proactive Kubernetes Monitoring with Alerting
    I installed the helm release using Ansible, but you can install with the following helm commands:. - Source: dev.to / about 3 years ago
  • Cannot run a playbook in crontab - Python error
    [root@ansible ~]# pip show ansible Name: ansible Version: 2.9.25 Summary: Radically simple IT automation Home-page: https://ansible.com/ Author: Ansible, Inc. Author-email: info@ansible.com License: GPLv3+ Location: /usr/lib/python2.7/site-packagesRequires: jinja2, PyYAML, cryptography Required-by:. Source: over 3 years ago
View more

PowerShell mentions (23)

  • FeiFlow - An Opinioned Git Branching And Release Management Strategy
    Addressing these concerns requires safeguards and automation. Our "in-house" solution is based on powershell for git scripting and logic and ADO tools set for git repo hosting, tracking, planning, linking, building, execution, and querying purposes. - Source: dev.to / over 1 year ago
  • If you have no experience, learn Powershell (or Python)
    The official PowerShell documentation (specifically, the PowerShell 101 and About topics) is a great place to start. Source: over 1 year ago
  • Best resource to learn PowerShell?
    Really sorry about that this was the link I embedded https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/powershell/. Source: about 2 years ago
  • Feeling pretty down/demoralized. Any suggestions on easy wins for my team?
    - Pick something unique to your team that’s an irritant and find a way to automate it. We used Powershell to do this ourselves, but I know people also use BASH. Source: over 2 years ago
  • Unexpected behaviour when processing large file with StreamReader
    Uh, what? https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/powershell/ is not official to you? Source: over 2 years ago
View more

What are some alternatives?

When comparing Ansible and PowerShell, you can also consider the following products

Chef - Automation for all of your technology. Overcome the complexity and rapidly ship your infrastructure and apps anywhere with automation.

MobaXterm - Enhanced terminal for Windows with X11 server, tabbed SSH client, network tools and much more

Jenkins - Jenkins is an open-source continuous integration server with 300+ plugins to support all kinds of software development

ConEmu - ConEmu-Maximus5 is a full-featured local terminal for Windows devs, admins and users. Get better console window with tabs, splits, Quake style, copy+paste, DosBox and PuTTY integration, and much more.

Codeship - Codeship is a fast and secure hosted Continuous Delivery platform that scales with your needs.

PuTTY - Popular free terminal application. Mostly used as an SSH client.