ADP VS Paychex

Compare ADP VS Paychex and see what are their differences

OnPay

Payroll and HR that make business a breeze featured

Contents:

» Base Details
» Videos
» Reviews
» Alternatives

ADP

ADP payroll services, HR Solutions, Tax Compliance, and PEO. Get a free ADP payroll quote today. Easy-to-use business solutions for employers of all sizes.

Paychex

Are you in need of payroll services, HR services, 401(k) and benefits administration, or more? No matter the size of your business, Paychex can help.

Landing page //
2023-08-06

Landing page //
2023-04-13

ADP

Website: adp.com
Pricing URL: Official ADP Pricing

Edit details

Paychex

Website: paychex.com
Pricing URL: Official Paychex Pricing

Edit details

ADP features and specs

Comprehensive Feature Set
ADP offers a wide range of services including payroll processing, time and attendance tracking, HR management, and benefits administration, making it a one-stop solution for businesses.
Scalability
ADP can accommodate businesses of various sizes, from small enterprises to large corporations, allowing for growth without needing to switch platforms.
Compliance Support
ADP helps businesses stay compliant with ever-changing regulations, offering resources and updates that ensure adherence to legal requirements.
Customer Support
ADP provides 24/7 customer support, ensuring that assistance is available whenever it is needed.
Integration Capability
ADP integrates seamlessly with various accounting and ERP systems, enhancing its flexibility and utility.
Data Security
ADP is known for its strong focus on data security, providing robust measures to protect sensitive employee and company information.

Possible disadvantages of ADP

Cost
ADP is often considered expensive, which may be a barrier for smaller businesses or startups with limited budgets.
Complexity
The extensive feature set can be overwhelming and may require significant time for new users to learn and navigate effectively.
Contract Commitments
ADP usually requires long-term contracts, which can be restrictive for businesses that prefer more flexible arrangements.
Customization Limitations
While ADP offers a wide range of features, customization options are somewhat limited, which may not meet the specific needs of all businesses.
Customer Support
While customer support is available 24/7, some users report inconsistency in the quality of service provided.
Implementation Time
The setup and implementation process can be time-consuming, requiring a dedicated effort from the business’s team.

Paychex features and specs

Comprehensive Payroll Solutions
Paychex Flex offers extensive payroll services, including direct deposit, tax calculation, and year-end tax forms, ensuring all payroll needs are met efficiently.
Scalability
The platform can accommodate businesses of various sizes, from small startups to large enterprises, offering tailored solutions as the company grows.
User-Friendly Interface
The system features an intuitive user interface that simplifies the process of managing payroll, benefits, and HR tasks, which can save time and reduce errors.
Employee Self-Service
Employees can access their pay stubs, tax documents, and personal information directly through the portal, reducing the administrative burden on HR departments.
Integration Capabilities
Paychex Flex can integrate with various accounting and time-tracking software, allowing for seamless data synchronization and improved workflow efficiency.
Customer Support
The platform provides robust customer support, including 24/7 access to knowledgeable representatives who can assist with any issues or questions.

Possible disadvantages of Paychex

Cost
The services offered by Paychex Flex can be expensive, which might be a significant consideration for small businesses with limited budgets.
Complexity for Small Businesses
While it offers extensive features, some small businesses may find the platform too complex for their simpler payroll and HR needs.
Learning Curve
New users may face a learning curve when initially setting up or navigating the platform, which might require additional training or support.
Limited Customization
Some users may find that Paychex Flex offers limited customization options, which can be a drawback for businesses with unique needs or processes.
Occasional Technical Issues
Users have reported occasional technical issues or downtime, which can disrupt operations and require intervention from customer support.
Contract Terms
Paychex Flex may require long-term contracts that can be difficult to alter or exit without financial penalties, which could be restrictive for businesses looking for flexible service options.

Analysis of ADP

Overall verdict

ADP is generally considered a good option for businesses seeking comprehensive HR management solutions. While some users might find it more expensive than other options, its reliability, extensive features, and strong customer support often justify the investment for many companies.

Why this product is good

ADP (Automatic Data Processing) is a reputable company that provides comprehensive human resources management software and services, including payroll processing, talent management, and benefits administration. It is known for its reliable and efficient services, which are backed by decades of experience in the industry. ADP's solutions are designed to help businesses of all sizes optimize their HR processes and reduce administrative burdens. The company also offers robust customer support and a wide range of integrations with other business software, making it a popular choice among organizations seeking to streamline their HR functions.

Recommended for

Medium to large businesses that need scalable HR and payroll solutions
Organizations seeking robust customer support and reliable service
Companies looking for a comprehensive suite of HR tools that integrate with other business applications

Analysis of Paychex

Overall verdict

Paychex is generally regarded as a solid and reliable service for payroll and HR needs. It provides extensive features that can handle complex demands, making it a competitive choice in the industry.

Why this product is good

Paychex is considered a good option due to its comprehensive suite of payroll and HR solutions, which cater to businesses of various sizes. It offers a user-friendly platform, robust customer service, and a wide array of additional features such as tax administration, compliance assistance, and retirement services. Additionally, its scalability makes it suitable for companies experiencing growth.

Recommended for

Small to medium-sized businesses seeking a comprehensive payroll and HR solution
Businesses looking for scalable options to accommodate growth
Companies that require robust customer support and compliance assistance
Organizations interested in additional services such as retirement and insurance solutions

ADP videos

+ Add

ADP solutions explained: user reviews, screenshots and feature differences

Paychex videos

+ Add

Paychex: 5 Fast Facts

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to ADP and Paychex)

Paychex

17 17%

83% 83

HR Tools

16 16%

HR Tools

84% 84

Payroll

100 100%

Payroll

0% 0

HR And Payroll Software

23 23%

HR And Payroll Software

77% 77

User comments

Share your experience with using ADP and Paychex. For example, how are they different and which one is better?

Reviews

These are some of the external sources and on-site user reviews we've used to compare ADP and Paychex

ADP Reviews

Best Paylocity Competitors & Alternatives in 2024

For example, “RUN Powered by ADP” is the company’s payroll and Ben Admin solution specifically targeting small companies with no more than 50 employees. Depending on the subscription type, its features range from more basic, like tax filing, direct deposits, and reporting, to more complex ones, like legal assistance or complete management of state unemployment insurance.

Source: www.myshortlister.com

6 Best Payroll Software for Small Businesses (2022)

With ADP RUN, you’ll find standard features like easy tax filing, payroll automation, payroll reports, direct deposit, compliance for all 50 US states, along with mobile and web-based timecards for employees.

Source: www.wpbeginner.com

Paychex Reviews

Top 6 Paylocity alternatives and competitors (in-depth comparison)

Paychex enables you to compare your wages against other businesses to establish a fair rate. Source[/caption] Holding onto your top employees can be a challenge. If another business offers a better deal or you don’t notice a problem in time, they may leave. Paychex can help by benchmarking your pay against the competition so you can check you’re offering desirable rates....

Source: www.joinhomebase.com

The best 6 Paylocity competitors

A payroll processing software at its core, Paychex Flex has expanded its offering in recent years to include HR services and add-ons that cater to small businesses and startups. For an additional fee, Paychex can assist with group health benefits, employee retirement plans, and business insurance, allowing smaller organizations to benefit from targeted offers.

Source: www.rippling.com

Best Paylocity Competitors & Alternatives in 2024

While the provider offers different payroll solutions, Paychex Flex is one of the more prevalent alternatives for smaller employers. Its three-tier pricing structure allows businesses to customize their plan according to their needs.

Source: www.myshortlister.com

6 Best Payroll Software for Small Businesses (2022)

The best plan for most small businesses will be PayChex Flex Select. This plan includes standard payroll features, along with HR and employee management functionality.

Source: www.wpbeginner.com

BambooHR Review 2019: Pricing, Features, Alternatives

Paychex Flex is a BambooHR competitor that comes from one of the biggest companies in payroll management. Paychex has helped companies pay their employees for decades, and Paychex Flex brings many of its renowned features to the small- and mid-sized business sphere. Paychex Flex offers its users with payroll and HR support, which includes benefits administration as well as...

Source: www.fundera.com

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, ADP seems to be more popular. It has been mentiond 7 times since March 2021. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

ADP mentions (7)

W2
Unless something has changed recently you should be able to see your W2 after Jan. 3 on adp.com. Source: over 2 years ago
What is happening when a website gets a 404 error on multiple devices but the website is working outside of that network?
To add to this, if adp.com generates the error then their webserver is accessible, and then the problem is caused by i.e. a wrong configuration or a typo (server side). When people in another domain can access a specific URL then it is likely that every shown (working) page is produced exclusively for the client who requested it. Some typo (server side) can cause the web server to fetch a wrong URL internally. It... Source: about 3 years ago
Android has an autofill API. Is it possible to use autofill on desktop without installing a browser extension?
Basically they both look like https://adp.com but the "a" is a different ASCII character and has a different binary value. Source: over 3 years ago
Android has an autofill API. Is it possible to use autofill on desktop without installing a browser extension?
But it also verifies you are not entering your credentials on a fraudulent site. This is much more serious than I think you realize. For instance, which one of these is the legitimate site: https://аdp.com or https://adp.com? Source: over 3 years ago
My employer volunteered me for a 401k without my consent
I asked twitter and the personal ADP account reached out for someone to directly contact me via email. She had an adp.com and linked info on LinkedIn, etc. The number on the letter was a 1-800 with sadly no live person to ever speak to which made me go through them on twitter. Any safer options to know that Im talking to a ADP person? Source: over 3 years ago

Paychex mentions (0)

We have not tracked any mentions of Paychex yet. Tracking of Paychex recommendations started around Mar 2021.

What are some alternatives?

When comparing ADP and Paychex, you can also consider the following products

Gusto - Gusto. Payroll, benefits and compliance in one integrated product. We're here to change how the world works, and put people first.

Workday - Workday is an on‑demand financial management and human capital management software solution.

Paylocity - Paylocity has revolutionized the industry and has quickly become the leading independent provider of online payroll services and HR solutions.

Justworks - JustWorks is a software for business owners to take control for and manage effectively their payroll and human resources policies including compliance, payroll, and benefits. Read more about Justworks.

ADP Workforce Now - ADP Workforce Now provides cloud-based software, expert support and predictive analytics for data-driven insights.

BambooHR - Personalized HR software for SMBs

ADP Workforce Now vs ADP

ADP Workforce Now vs Paychex