Software Alternatives, Accelerators & Startups

SolidWorks Simulation VS Minsky

Compare SolidWorks Simulation VS Minsky and see what are their differences

SolidWorks Simulation logo SolidWorks Simulation

Simulation solutions for SOLIDWORKS® provide an easy-to-use portfolio of analysis tools for predicting a product’s real-world physical behavior by virtually testing CAD models.

Minsky logo Minsky

System dynamics program with additional features for economics
  • SolidWorks Simulation Landing page
    Landing page //
    2022-07-27
  • Minsky Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-10-14

SolidWorks Simulation features and specs

  • Integration
    Seamlessly integrates with SOLIDWORKS CAD, allowing for easy transition from design to simulation without requiring data translation or additional file handling.
  • User-Friendly Interface
    SolidWorks Simulation features an intuitive interface with comprehensive help documentation and tutorials, making it accessible for both beginners and experienced users.
  • Wide Range of Analysis Types
    Supports various analysis types including static, dynamic, thermal, fatigue, and fluid flow, among others, providing versatility for different engineering needs.
  • Parametric Optimization
    Allows users to perform parametric optimization studies, facilitating design improvements and innovation by evaluating multiple design scenarios efficiently.
  • Robust Validation Tools
    Equipped with tools to validate and verify simulations against empirical data, aiding in the credibility and accuracy of the simulations.

Possible disadvantages of SolidWorks Simulation

  • Cost
    SolidWorks Simulation can be expensive, with high licensing fees that might not be affordable for small businesses or individual users.
  • Hardware Requirements
    Requires high-performance hardware to run complex simulations efficiently, potentially necessitating additional investment in computing resources.
  • Learning Curve
    Although user-friendly, mastering the full suite of tools and capabilities requires time and effort, especially for those new to simulation software.
  • Complex Simulations Limitations
    Some users report limitations when dealing with extremely complex simulations or very large assemblies, which may require supplementary specialized software.
  • Limited Mac Compatibility
    SolidWorks Simulation is primarily designed for Windows-based systems, resulting in limited compatibility and support for macOS users.

Minsky features and specs

  • Graphical Interface
    Minsky offers a user-friendly graphical interface that allows users to visually construct complex system dynamics models without extensive coding expertise.
  • Economic and Financial Modeling
    It is particularly well-suited for modeling economic systems and financial instability, featuring specialized tools that cater to economists and financial analysts.
  • Turing Complete
    Minsky is Turing complete, giving users the ability to create a wide range of models, from simple to highly complex, using its capabilities.
  • Open Source
    As an open-source software, Minsky offers transparency in its functions and allows users to modify and enhance the software according to their needs.

Possible disadvantages of Minsky

  • Steep Learning Curve
    Users might encounter a steep learning curve, especially those with no background in system dynamics or economic modeling.
  • Limited Community Support
    Being a niche tool, the community around Minsky is relatively small compared to more mainstream modeling software, potentially limiting the availability of community-driven resources or support.
  • Performance Issues
    Some users may experience performance issues when running very complex or large-scale models due to computational constraints.
  • Interface Limitations
    The graphical interface, while user-friendly, could be limiting for advanced users accustomed to more customizable and extendable environments.

Analysis of SolidWorks Simulation

Overall verdict

  • SolidWorks Simulation is considered a highly effective simulation tool, especially for those who are already using SolidWorks for CAD design. Its integration, ease of use, and comprehensive features make it a reliable choice in the field of engineering simulations. However, for highly specialized simulations, other dedicated tools might be more appropriate.

Why this product is good

  • SolidWorks Simulation is a powerful tool used for validating and optimizing designs through advanced simulation capabilities. It offers finite element analysis (FEA) that allows engineers to test static, dynamic, and thermal behaviors of models. The integration within the SolidWorks environment makes it easy to perform simulations without needing to transfer files between software. Additionally, its user-friendly interface and robust features like design optimization, fatigue analysis, and drop test analysis make it accessible for both novice and experienced engineers. The availability of comprehensive tutorials and support further enhance its usability.

Recommended for

  • Mechanical engineers looking to integrate simulation within their design process.
  • Designers requiring accessible but powerful simulation tools.
  • Companies already utilizing SolidWorks for CAD, seeking a seamless simulation solution.
  • Educators and students in engineering programs for learning and teaching purposes.

SolidWorks Simulation videos

What's New SOLIDWORKS Simulation 2021

More videos:

  • Review - SOLIDWORKS Simulation Step-Up Series: Accuracy and Convergence

Minsky videos

Integrative literature review of the financial fragility hypothesis proposed by Minsky

More videos:

  • Review - Marvin Minsky
  • Review - Day 62: The Society of Mind by Marvin Minsky Book Highlights

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to SolidWorks Simulation and Minsky)
3D
100 100%
0% 0
Technical Computing
53 53%
47% 47
Simulation Software
0 0%
100% 100
CAD
100 100%
0% 0

User comments

Share your experience with using SolidWorks Simulation and Minsky. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

What are some alternatives?

When comparing SolidWorks Simulation and Minsky, you can also consider the following products

Inventor - Inventor is a 3D CAD software that lets you quickly create 3D models with embedded intelligence, intuitive workflows, and optimized performance.

EMSO simulator - EMSO simulator is an equation-oriented process simulator with a graphical interface for modeling...

Autodesk Fusion 360 - Integrated CAD, CAM, and CAE featuring collaborative editing and cloud-based computation.

Insight Maker - Explore powerful simulation algorithms for System Dynamics and Agent Based Modeling in a truly...

MATLAB - A high-level language and interactive environment for numerical computation, visualization, and programming

StochSD - StochSD (Stochastic System Dynamics) is a Continuous System Simulation extension that is built with the capabilities to help you simulate continuous flows between compartments and, most importantly, also has the power to manage discrete transitions …