RealWorld Icon Editor VS IconViewer

Create Windows icons and Mac OS icons from images and 3D models in an integrated icon maker.

Bot Productions's IconViewer utility allows you to view, copy, and save the icons in a file through its property sheet.

User-Friendly Interface
The RealWorld Icon Editor features an intuitive and easy-to-navigate interface, making it accessible to both beginners and advanced users looking to create or edit icons.
Comprehensive Tools
It offers a wide range of tools and options for icon design, including vector drawing, 3D modeling, and support for all essential icon formats.
Layer Support
The software supports layers, allowing users to work non-destructively and manage complex icon designs with ease.
Cost-effective
The RealWorld Icon Editor is available at a competitive price, providing good value for money with its extensive feature set.

Limited Advanced Features
While suitable for basic and intermediate tasks, some users might find it lacks advanced features available in more specialized graphic design software.
Windows Only
The software is only available for Windows, limiting accessibility for users on macOS or Linux platforms.
Occasional Performance Issues
Some users may experience performance lags or crashes, especially with larger or more complex files.
Learning Curve for 3D
While the interface is user-friendly, users new to 3D modeling might find a steep learning curve when utilizing the software's 3D features.

User-Friendly Interface
IconViewer integrates seamlessly with Windows, offering an intuitive and straightforward user experience for browsing icons.
Compatibility
The tool is compatible with multiple Windows operating systems, making it versatile for a wide user base.
Functionality
IconViewer allows users to view and extract icons from executables, DLLs, and other file types effortlessly.
Freeware
IconViewer is available free of charge, providing significant utility without any cost to the user.

Limited to Windows OS
The tool is only available for Windows platforms, excluding users on macOS or Linux.
Basic Feature Set
IconViewer is designed specifically for viewing icons and might not include advanced features that some users might desire.
Less Frequent Updates
The software might not receive regular updates or new features, potentially limiting its functionality over time.