Software Alternatives, Accelerators & Startups

Portia VS Web Scraper

Compare Portia VS Web Scraper and see what are their differences

Portia logo Portia

An open-source visual scraping tool that lets you scrape the web without coding, built by Scrapy...

Web Scraper logo Web Scraper

Web site data extraction tool ⚒️
  • Portia Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-09-12
  • Web Scraper Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-06-28

Portia features and specs

  • Ease of Use
    Portia features a user-friendly visual interface that allows users to build web scraping models without writing any code, making it accessible even to those without programming skills.
  • Open Source
    Being an open-source project, Portia allows users to freely access, modify, and contribute to the code, fostering a collaborative development environment and making it customizable.
  • Integration with Scrapy
    Portia is built on top of Scrapy, a robust web scraping framework, which means it inherits Scrapy's robust features and the ability to handle complex scraping tasks efficiently.
  • Auto-Generated Spiders
    It automatically generates spiders based on the patterns you define through its visual interface, streamlining the process of creating and deploying web scrapers.
  • Cloud Hosting
    Portia can be integrated with Scrapinghub's platform for cloud hosting, which means you can deploy and manage your scrapers in the cloud, ensuring scalability and reliability.

Possible disadvantages of Portia

  • Limited Customization
    While the visual interface is easy to use, it doesn't provide the same level of customization and control as writing your own scraping scripts in Scrapy or another framework, which may limit its capabilities for advanced users.
  • Performance
    Portia-generated spiders might not be as optimized as hand-coded spiders, potentially leading to inefficiencies and slower scraping performance in comparison to fully customized solutions.
  • Maintenance and Updates
    As an open-source project, updates and maintenance depend on community contributions, which can sometimes be sporadic and may not keep pace with rapid changes in web technologies.
  • Complex Websites
    For highly dynamic and complex websites, Portia may struggle to generate effective scraping rules and might require manual intervention or additional tools to scrape data correctly.
  • Learning Curve for Advanced Features
    While basic usage is easy, utilizing some of Portia's more advanced features or troubleshooting issues may require a deeper understanding of the underlying technologies, such as Scrapy.

Web Scraper features and specs

  • Ease of Use
    Web Scraper offers a user-friendly interface with a visual scraper builder that makes it accessible for users with minimal technical expertise. The browser extension facilitates easy setup and execution of scraping tasks.
  • Cost-effective
    It has a free tier that supports a wide range of scraping needs. The paid plans are reasonably priced, offering advanced features and capabilities for those who need them.
  • Multi-site Scraping
    Users can scrape data from multiple websites with support for pagination, which is essential for scraping large datasets spread across different web pages.
  • Cloud Scraping
    Web Scraper provides cloud services that allow users to run scraping jobs on their servers, thus freeing up local resources and ensuring more reliable execution of tasks.
  • Data Export Options
    It supports various data export formats, including CSV, JSON, and Excel. This flexibility makes it easier to integrate scraped data into different data processing workflows.

Possible disadvantages of Web Scraper

  • Limited Free Plan
    The free tier has limitations in terms of the number of scrapers, sitemap sizes, and scraping frequency. Users with higher demands may need to upgrade to a paid plan.
  • Learning Curve
    While the interface is user-friendly, there is still a learning curve, especially for more complex scraping tasks involving intricate website structures or dynamic content loaded via JavaScript.
  • Cloud Dependency
    For large-scale scraping tasks, reliance on the cloud service can be a downside if there are any service outages or latency issues, which could disrupt scraping jobs.
  • Limited Dynamic Content Handling
    Handling websites with heavy JavaScript content can be challenging. Although there are some capabilities for dealing with dynamic content, it might require additional tools or manual interventions for more complex scenarios.
  • Browser Extension Compatibility
    The Web Scraper extension is primarily designed for Google Chrome, which may be a drawback for users who prefer or are restricted to using other browsers.

Analysis of Portia

Overall verdict

  • Portia is generally considered to be a good tool for those who need to scrape web data without delving deeply into coding. Its open-source nature allows for customization and improvements by the community. However, like any tool, its effectiveness will depend on the specific needs and technical requirements of the user.

Why this product is good

  • Portia is a web scraping tool available on GitHub that is designed to make the extraction of data from websites easier for users who may not have programming expertise. It offers a visual interface for identifying data on the page, making it a user-friendly option for many and particularly suitable for structured data extraction.

Recommended for

    Portia is recommended for users who are looking for a relatively easy and intuitive way to scrape websites, especially those without advanced programming skills. It's suitable for projects that require structured data crawling and for users who appreciate community-driven tools.

Analysis of Web Scraper

Overall verdict

  • Web Scraper is a reliable and efficient tool for web data extraction. It combines ease of use with robust features, making it suitable for users who need to extract data without writing code.

Why this product is good

  • Web Scraper (webscraper.io) is considered good due to its user-friendly interface and powerful scraping capabilities. It offers a browser extension for easy setup, allows data export in multiple formats, and provides features like pagination handling and element selection, making it accessible for both beginners and advanced users. Additionally, it supports scheduled scraping and has cloud services for large-scale projects.

Recommended for

    Individuals and small to medium-sized businesses looking for a straightforward and effective way to collect data from web pages without the need for advanced programming skills. It is also ideal for marketers, researchers, and data analysts who require regular web data extraction.

Portia videos

My Time at Portia Review

More videos:

  • Review - My Time At Portia Switch Review - STARDEW 3D!?
  • Review - My Time at Portia Review 2019

Web Scraper videos

Web Scraper intro tutorial

More videos:

  • Review - Web scraper review
  • Tutorial - How to Extract Multiple Web Pages by Using Google Chorme Web Scraper Extension

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to Portia and Web Scraper)
Web Scraping
47 47%
53% 53
Data Extraction
49 49%
51% 51
Data
64 64%
36% 36
Web Scraping API
40 40%
60% 60

User comments

Share your experience with using Portia and Web Scraper. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

Reviews

These are some of the external sources and on-site user reviews we've used to compare Portia and Web Scraper

Portia Reviews

Top 15 Best TinyTask Alternatives in 2022
Portia is a trustworthy, all-inclusive investment operation platform created from the middle to the back office, which streamlines the numerous activities and increases efficiency. The modular platform gives you a commanding perspective on your work and boosts productivity with efficient workflow. Solutions for client reporting, portfolio accounting, performance measurement...

Web Scraper Reviews

We have no reviews of Web Scraper yet.
Be the first one to post

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, Web Scraper seems to be more popular. It has been mentiond 34 times since March 2021. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

Portia mentions (0)

We have not tracked any mentions of Portia yet. Tracking of Portia recommendations started around Mar 2021.

Web Scraper mentions (34)

  • How do I create a script that inspect the website and click all the button(parse address)?
    Point and click web browser plugin GUI: https://webscraper.io/. Source: almost 2 years ago
  • Web scraper for a flight price comparison website?
    In my 5+ years of experience as the scraper guy in the office, paying for these services could take a lot of money. So automated scraping might be your option. If you need help, tap me. Or you could use webscraper.io for easier nocode approach to it if you wanna do it yourself. Source: about 2 years ago
  • Data from EuroNews.com
    I don't know what corpus linguistic analysis is, but you can scrape the articles off of their website and analyse it in whichever software you're comfortable with. If you're not familiar with a programming language, you can use a GUI scraper like this one. Source: about 2 years ago
  • Issues scouting the right web scraper
    I'm looking into VPNs that have rotating IPs with time-set features. Didnt find any yet that I can try for free first. For the scraping Im using a free chrome browser extension from https://webscraper.io/. Source: over 2 years ago
  • [Help] how to make a copy of an online database
    For text only dbs a even a scraper addon would do. Try something like webscraper.io, it takes a bit of fucking around to get it working but it's foolproof. Source: over 2 years ago
View more

What are some alternatives?

When comparing Portia and Web Scraper, you can also consider the following products

Scrapy - Scrapy | A Fast and Powerful Scraping and Web Crawling Framework

Apify - Apify is a web scraping and automation platform that can turn any website into an API.

import.io - Import. io helps its users find the internet data they need, organize and store it, and transform it into a format that provides them with the context they need.

ScrapingBee - ScrapingBee is a Web Scraping API that handles proxies and Headless browser for you, so you can focus on extracting the data you want, and nothing else.

ParseHub - ParseHub is a free web scraping tool. With our advanced web scraper, extracting data is as easy as clicking the data you need.

Data Miner - Data Miner is a Google Chrome extension that helps you scrape data from web pages and into a CSV file or Excel spreadsheet.