Software Alternatives, Accelerators & Startups

MSYS2 VS MinGW

Compare MSYS2 VS MinGW and see what are their differences

MSYS2 logo MSYS2

A Cygwin-derived software distro for Windows using Arch Linux's Pacman

MinGW logo MinGW

MinGW ("Minimalistic GNU for Windows") is a port of the GNU Compiler Collection (GCC) and...
  • MSYS2 Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-05-05
  • MinGW Landing page
    Landing page //
    2018-12-08

MSYS2 features and specs

  • Package Management
    MSYS2 uses the Pacman package manager, which is known for its speed and ease of use. This allows users to easily install, update, and manage software packages and dependencies.
  • Unix-like Environment
    MSYS2 provides a Unix-like environment on Windows, making it easier for developers familiar with Unix/Linux systems to work on Windows without having to adjust to a new command interface.
  • Compatibility
    MSYS2 is compatible with many popular Unix/Linux tools and software, making it a versatile option for developers who need access to these tools on a Windows system.
  • Frequent Updates
    The MSYS2 project is actively maintained, with frequent updates to keep up with new features, security patches, and bug fixes, ensuring a stable and secure environment.

Possible disadvantages of MSYS2

  • Complex Setup
    The initial setup of MSYS2 can be complex and intimidating for new users, as it requires multiple packages and configurations to get started.
  • Overhead
    Running a Unix-like environment on top of Windows can introduce some overhead, potentially impacting performance when compared to native Windows applications.
  • Learning Curve
    Users who are not already familiar with Unix/Linux command-line environments may face a steep learning curve when transitioning to MSYS2, due to its reliance on command-line operations.
  • Package Availability
    While MSYS2 has a wide range of packages, not every Linux package is available or may not work as expected due to differences between the environments.

MinGW features and specs

  • Open Source
    MinGW is an open-source software project, which makes it freely available for anyone to use, modify, and distribute.
  • Lightweight
    It is a lightweight alternative to full-fledged development environments, providing essential tools without unnecessary overhead.
  • Windows Compatibility
    MinGW offers native Windows support, allowing developers to compile applications that can run directly on Windows without the need for a compatibility layer.
  • GCC Integration
    It includes the GNU Compiler Collection (GCC), which is widely considered a strong, stable, and versatile set of compilers for C, C++, and other languages.
  • Active Community
    MinGW is supported by an active community, which can provide help, patches, and additional resources via forums and online discussions.

Possible disadvantages of MinGW

  • Limited POSIX Support
    While MinGW provides some POSIX functionality, its support is limited compared to other environments like Cygwin, which might be a drawback for developers relying on extensive POSIX compatibility.
  • Manual Configuration
    Initial setup and configuration can be cumbersome for beginners, requiring a manual installation process that might be intimidating or time-consuming.
  • Lacks Newest GCC Features
    At times, MinGW may lag in providing the latest features or updates available in the newest versions of GCC, leading to potential compatibility or feature discrepancies.
  • No Native 64-bit Support
    Historically, MinGW has focused on 32-bit toolchains, which may not offer the full benefits of modern 64-bit architectures. However, MinGW-w64 was developed to address this issue.
  • Fragmentation
    The existence of multiple variants such as MinGW and MinGW-w64 can cause confusion, leading developers to face challenges in choosing the right version for their needs.

Analysis of MSYS2

Overall verdict

  • MSYS2 is a highly recommended tool for developers looking to bring a Unix-like environment to Windows. It is versatile, regularly updated, and provides extensive support for building native Windows applications. The community-driven nature and the vast collection of packages available make it a robust choice for development tasks.

Why this product is good

  • MSYS2 is a software distribution and building platform for Windows that is based on the Arch Linux package distribution model. It provides a collection of Unix utilities, GNU toolchain, and various popular open-source libraries, all in a way that is native to Windows. This makes it a great choice for developers who need a Unix-like development environment or want to build software from source on Windows. MSYS2 uses the Pacman package manager, which simplifies installation and updates of software packages, making maintenance easy.

Recommended for

  • Windows developers who require Unix-like tools and software.
  • Developers and engineers looking to build and compile open-source projects on Windows.
  • Users needing a package manager for Windows to manage software installations efficiently.
  • Anyone who wants a more seamless experience transitioning between development environments on different operating systems.

MSYS2 videos

QMK Firmware Tutorial - MSYS2, and Drivers (Part 1)

More videos:

  • Review - Instalando e Atualizando o MSYS2

MinGW videos

MinGW или Cygwin

More videos:

  • Tutorial - How to Install MinGW | GCC Toolset for C and C++ Programming | Setting Path variable on Windows 10
  • Tutorial - How to install | use gcc | MinGW compiler in windows | window 10

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to MSYS2 and MinGW)
Terminal Tools
53 53%
47% 47
SSH
53 53%
47% 47
Server Management
53 53%
47% 47
Development
100 100%
0% 0

User comments

Share your experience with using MSYS2 and MinGW. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

Reviews

These are some of the external sources and on-site user reviews we've used to compare MSYS2 and MinGW

MSYS2 Reviews

10 Termux Alternatives
MSYS2 is an advanced technology software with a user-friendly environment that provides libraries and tools for building, installing, and running a specific featured software on native 64bit windows. The software you generate on this platform would have a particular system of command called minty to have complete control over your profiles to run them smoothly. The primary...

MinGW Reviews

10 Termux Alternatives
MinGW is an application with all the functions of GNU that includes the runtime of MSVC and supports C99 functionality. This software is only supported and executed on 64bit Windows and similar platforms with Linux shell environment and provides its users the facility of different import types of files and libraries and move them to other software according to your specific...

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, MSYS2 should be more popular than MinGW. It has been mentiond 8 times since March 2021. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

MSYS2 mentions (8)

  • Trying to find the real MinGW
    Hi, I have been learning C++ recently using Visual Studio and Replit and wanted to switch to using a compiler with the windows command prompt. When I search up how to install MinGW there are multiple tutorials of indian people and other people who use totally different links and download pages in each video and I'm not sure which one to trust. Is msys2.org the correct website or is sourceforge or a different... Source: about 2 years ago
  • Getting “QT with MinGW support”?
    Apart from what other people already said, http://msys2.org/ is another easy-to-setup option. Source: over 2 years ago
  • I Hate Windows!
    Also FYI: there’s a project called MSYS2 which derives from Cygwin and seeks to provide a proper set of Unix tools on Windows, including split: https://packages.msys2.org/package/coreutils. Source: over 2 years ago
  • std::cout << "It's a pain";
    Still, it isn't a compiler. You also need to install the Visual Studio build tools, or GCC and/or Clang through MSYS2. Source: over 2 years ago
  • Installing MinGW W64 with FFMPEG on Windows and fixing the weird "file downloaded incorrectly" error.
    Download the latest msys2 installer from http://msys2.org/ and run it. - Source: dev.to / almost 3 years ago
View more

MinGW mentions (1)

  • Is Mingw dead?
    Is osdn's mingw it a new project ? It's surprising how it provides gcc 4.8.2 and gcc 9.2.0. I guess the 4.8.2 is the last one provided by mingw.org, and 9.2.0 is the first of osdn's project? Is it maintained by the same developers? Source: about 4 years ago

What are some alternatives?

When comparing MSYS2 and MinGW, you can also consider the following products

Termux - Terminal emulator and Linux environment for Android

Cygwin - Cygwin is a set of tools that provide Linux and POSIX functionality to Windows.

PowerShell - Download WMF. Windows Management Framework contains the latest versions of PowerShell, DSC, WMI, and WinRM for older versions of Windows. PowerShell Module Browser. Search for PowerShell modules and cmdlets.

MobaXterm - Enhanced terminal for Windows with X11 server, tabbed SSH client, network tools and much more

PuTTY - Popular free terminal application. Mostly used as an SSH client.

MinGW-w64 - The project's goal is to deliver runtime, headers, and libs for developing 64 bit (x64), as...