Software Alternatives, Accelerators & Startups

MakeMKV VS VidCoder

Compare MakeMKV VS VidCoder and see what are their differences

MakeMKV logo MakeMKV

MakeMKV is a software solution for converting video files into the MKV file format.

VidCoder logo VidCoder

VidCoder is a DVD/Blu-ray ripping and video transcoding application for Windows.
  • MakeMKV Landing page
    Landing page //
    2021-09-22
  • VidCoder Landing page
    Landing page //
    2018-10-24

MakeMKV features and specs

  • Ease of Use
    MakeMKV offers a user-friendly interface which makes it simple for even non-technical users to convert their DVDs and Blu-rays into MKV files.
  • Cross-Platform Compatibility
    The software is available for Windows, macOS, and Linux, making it accessible to a wide user base.
  • High-Quality Output
    MakeMKV retains the original quality of both video and audio streams during the conversion process, ensuring no loss in fidelity.
  • Speed
    MakeMKV performs conversions relatively quickly, especially when compared to some other ripping software.
  • Free While in Beta
    The software is free to use while it remains in beta, which it has been for a prolonged period.
  • Wide Format Support
    MakeMKV supports a wide variety of disc formats, including DVD and Blu-ray, allowing users to rip almost any disc they have.

Possible disadvantages of MakeMKV

  • Limited File Format
    The software only converts video to MKV format, which may not be ideal for users looking for other formats like MP4.
  • No Editing Features
    MakeMKV does not offer any video editing features, limiting it to purely ripping and conversion tasks.
  • Cost After Beta
    Once the software exits its beta phase, it will require a paid license, which could deter some users.
  • Large File Sizes
    The MKV files created by MakeMKV tend to be large, as the software does not compress the files, which can consume a significant amount of storage space.
  • Occasional Instability
    As a beta software, MakeMKV can occasionally be unstable or have bugs, which might disrupt the ripping process.

VidCoder features and specs

  • User-Friendly Interface
    VidCoder features a simple and intuitive interface that's easy for beginners to navigate while offering advanced options for experienced users.
  • High-Quality Video Encoding
    Utilizes the HandBrake encoding engine, allowing for high-quality video and audio output, with a variety of settings and presets.
  • Batch Processing
    Supports batch processing of multiple videos, enabling users to queue and process multiple files simultaneously.
  • Wide Format Support
    Supports a wide range of video and audio formats, ensuring compatibility with various media players and devices.
  • Open Source
    VidCoder is an open-source project, which means it is free to use, and the source code is available for anyone to inspect, modify, and enhance.
  • Frequent Updates
    Regularly updated with bug fixes, performance improvements, and new features based on community feedback.

Possible disadvantages of VidCoder

  • CPU Intensive
    Encoding video can be very resource-intensive, potentially slowing down the computer or consuming a lot of CPU power, especially with complex tasks.
  • Learning Curve
    While it is user-friendly, some of the more advanced features and settings may have a learning curve for users not familiar with video encoding.
  • No Built-in Media Player
    Does not include a built-in media player for previewing videos, which means users need to rely on external players to check their videos.
  • Limited Documentation
    Though there is a community and some guides available, the official documentation can be somewhat limited, making it difficult for some users to find in-depth help.

MakeMKV videos

MakeMKV Tutorial

More videos:

  • Review - MakeMKV Walk-through

VidCoder videos

Quick Tour of VidCoder

More videos:

  • Review - Convert Youtube 4K small file with Vidcoder base Handbrake
  • Review - encoding with vidcoder

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to MakeMKV and VidCoder)
Video
69 69%
31% 31
Video Converter
71 71%
29% 29
File Converter
67 67%
33% 33
CD/DVD Tools
100 100%
0% 0

User comments

Share your experience with using MakeMKV and VidCoder. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

Reviews

These are some of the external sources and on-site user reviews we've used to compare MakeMKV and VidCoder

MakeMKV Reviews

What’s the Best Alternative to HandBrake for Video Converting and DVD Ripping?
MakeMKV(https://www.makemkv.com/) provides one-click solution for ripping commercial DVD and Blu-ray discs. It works by decrypting proprietary discs to transfer codecs from the formats VOB and M2TS into MKV, preserving the necessary data without doing any lossy codec conversion. If you don’t have strict demand on the output video format (since it’s only limited to MKV),...
Source: www.vidmore.com

VidCoder Reviews

18 Best Video Converter Software in 2022 (Free and Paid)
The encoding speed of Vidcoder is quite slow from our test. When working with the preset Very Fast 1080P, Vidcoder took over 2 minutes to transcode our 43 seconds 4K iPhone recording. It took up 70% of our CPU resource and 1600MB of the system memory while the conversion. After we changed the import video file to a 7.26GB of ISO file, the disk usage value suddenly jumped to...

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, MakeMKV should be more popular than VidCoder. It has been mentiond 43 times since March 2021. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

MakeMKV mentions (43)

  • Beta Key?
    Just re-download the install package from makemkv.com and run it, it will ask to remove old install then allow you to reinstall then the key resets. (do this until the new key is released). Then down the road if you like it you can always get the paid lifetime license. Source: over 1 year ago
  • It is important that ebooks be sold without DRM
    If you haven’t already, you should check out MakeMKV. You can buy it or use it free with the beta keys, and it should solve your problem. https://makemkv.com/. - Source: Hacker News / over 1 year ago
  • Need help from someone smarter than myself
    You’ll need a Blu-ray or UHD Friendly Blu-ray drive. Visit https://makemkv.com https://forum.makemkv.com/forum/ to learn more about it as they can explain it better. Also there is lots of support on YouTube: the is Lon.TV, He makes an entire series on PleX https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLCZHp4d1HnIvqJPAmMooCKOHieLdi3I7o. Source: about 2 years ago
  • I'm looking for software that I can use to categorise my audiobook and DVD rips.
    Or you could use Makemkv and Extract audio coppy. Source: about 2 years ago
  • Completely new to this...please go easy. I want to be able to play my music and movie collection throughout my home and have a few questions to get me going.
    Plex doesn't support disc image formats like ISO, so you would have to extract the video itself before Plex could read them (e.g. With MakeMKV). Source: about 2 years ago
View more

VidCoder mentions (19)

  • What’s better for ripping DVDs than Handbrake?
    VidCoder (Here) is my go to app, it uses handbreak as its encoder but has much better handling of real discs. Source: about 2 years ago
  • Virtualizing, colored log window in WPF
    A user recently reported that VidCoder would hang in the middle of a long encode. After dusting off WinDbg and some !clrstack and !eestack I found a thread in garbage collection for FlowDocument. We use this in only one place, the log window. - Source: dev.to / about 2 years ago
  • Best free video format converter in 2023?
    VidCoder uses Handbrake's engine and is very simple to use. Source: about 2 years ago
  • The Last Resort
    If you need a specific size, which is why I guess one of the few reasons you’d want a constant bitrate, use vidcoder, which is just a reskinned handbrake with a target size option. For compression, I’d encode with H.265 or AV1 depending on what hardware you need it for, assuming you do need it light. I would still pass through audio, unless you’re really in a pinch. Source: about 2 years ago
  • Any better alternatives to Wondershare Converter Factory?
    VidCoder is a different frontend for HandBrake with a more Metro-styled UX, and can be a bit easier to use for some workflows. Source: over 2 years ago
View more

What are some alternatives?

When comparing MakeMKV and VidCoder, you can also consider the following products

HandBrake - HandBrake allows users to easily convert video files into a wide variety of different formats.

Format Factory - Format Factory is software that allows the user to convert media into various file formats. The software is a product of PC Free Time, a Chinese software development company. Read more about Format Factory.

File Converter - Convert & compress everything in 2 clicks!

AnyDVD - Hardware layer for DVD decryption.

Shutter Encoder - Open source software without any restriction - converter all formats video|audio|image professionnals codecs and standards - swiss knife tool Windows, OSX and Linux

WinX DVD Ripper - A LOOK AT WINX DVD RIPPER SOFTWARE. So what in the heck is this DVD ripper in the first place? Well, as the name would imply, the software “rips,” a movie from a physical disc. Read more about WinX DVD Ripper.