libfive Studio VS BRL-CAD

Compare libfive Studio VS BRL-CAD and see what are their differences

3D Cityplanner

Transforming urban planning with smarter designs, data-driven decisions, and sustainable solutions for the cities of tomorrow. featured

Contents:

» Base Details
» Videos
» Reviews
» Alternatives

libfive Studio

A minimalist GUI for solid modeling with the libfive kernel.

BRL-CAD

BRL-CAD: Open Source Solid Modeling

Landing page //
2021-09-14

Landing page //
2023-04-23

libfive Studio features and specs

Open Source
Libfive Studio is an open-source tool, allowing users to access and modify the source code, fostering community collaboration and customization.
Parametric Design
Supports parametric modeling, enabling users to create geometric objects using parameters, which can be easily adjusted and modified.
Compatibility
Offers compatibility with multiple platforms, providing flexibility for users on different operating systems.
Simplicity
Provides a streamlined and simple user interface, making it accessible for both beginners and advanced users interested in procedural modeling.

Possible disadvantages of libfive Studio

Steep Learning Curve
For users not familiar with parametric or procedural modeling, the tool may present a steep learning curve initially.
Development Activity
As an open-source project, it might not have the same level of consistent updates and comprehensive support as some commercial alternatives.
Limited Features
Might lack some advanced features available in more mature and commercially developed CAD systems.
User Community
Although it has a dedicated user base, the overall community might be smaller, which can limit the availability of third-party tutorials and resources.

BRL-CAD features and specs

Open Source
BRL-CAD is free and open-source software, which means it can be freely downloaded, used, and modified. This makes it accessible to a wide range of users, from hobbyists to professional engineers.
Rich Feature Set
BRL-CAD offers a comprehensive suite of tools for solid modeling, including geometry editing, rendering, and analysis capabilities. It supports a variety of file formats and has powerful computational capabilities.
Longevity and Provenance
BRL-CAD has been actively developed and maintained for over 40 years. Its extensive history in the field ensures a robust and stable platform trusted by industries and government agencies alike.
Cross-Platform Compatibility
BRL-CAD is compatible with multiple operating systems, including Windows, macOS, and various Unix-like systems such as Linux and BSD.
Extensive Documentation
BRL-CAD provides thorough documentation and tutorials, which can be extremely helpful for new users trying to familiarize themselves with the software as well as advanced users looking for specific information.

Possible disadvantages of BRL-CAD

Steep Learning Curve
Due to its extensive feature set and unique interface, BRL-CAD can have a steep learning curve, especially for users who are new to CAD software or who are migrating from other more user-friendly platforms.
Outdated Interface
The user interface of BRL-CAD is considered outdated compared to modern CAD software, which can make it less intuitive and harder to navigate for some users.
Limited Community Support
While BRL-CAD has a dedicated user base, it is not as large as those of more popular CAD systems. This can result in fewer community resources, such as forums, user groups, and third-party tutorials.
Less Frequent Updates
Development and updates can be less frequent compared to commercial CAD software, potentially leading to slower implementation of new features and bug fixes.
Lack of Integration with Commercial Tools
BRL-CAD may have limited integration with commonly used commercial CAD tools and PLM systems, which can be a disadvantage for users who need to operate in a mixed software environment.

Analysis of BRL-CAD

Overall verdict

BRL-CAD is a powerful and reliable open-source solid modeling system that is well-regarded in certain specialized fields.

Why this product is good

BRL-CAD has a long history of development, starting in 1979, and has been used by the U.S. military for computer-aided design and solid modelling. It offers robust performance for engineering and scientific applications, includes a wide range of features, such as ray-tracing for rendering, geometric analysis tools, and benchmark suite. Moreover, it is open-source and cross-platform, which means it is constantly being improved by a community of users and is not confined to a single operating system.

Recommended for

Professional engineers working in fields where precision modeling and analysis are required.
Universities and educational institutions that need a solid modeling system for teaching purposes.
Researchers who require accurate simulation and analysis tools.
Hobbyists interested in understanding or contributing to an open-source CAD project.

libfive Studio videos

No libfive Studio videos yet. You could help us improve this page by suggesting one.

Add video

BRL-CAD videos

+ Add

Introduction of BRL-CAD

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to libfive Studio and BRL-CAD)

BRL-CAD

18 18%

82% 82

Architecture

21 21%

Architecture

79% 79

CAD

25 25%

CAD

75% 75

3D Modeling

16 16%

3D Modeling

84% 84

User comments

Share your experience with using libfive Studio and BRL-CAD. For example, how are they different and which one is better?

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, BRL-CAD should be more popular than libfive Studio. It has been mentiond 13 times since March 2021. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

libfive Studio mentions (4)

Show HN: Make 3D art in your browser using Lisp and math
You should check out libfive! https://libfive.com/studio/. Previously discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26930822. It is the child of Ao, previously discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12319406. - Source: Hacker News / over 2 years ago
Fornjot – The world needs another CAD program
Libfive does something similar but uses lisp instead of rust. https://libfive.com/studio/. - Source: Hacker News / about 3 years ago
Adobe Joins Blender Development Fund
I found it confusing for a similar reason especially when you get into more complicated designs with multiple parts. I think development could be massively sped up with a little funding. I tried libfive (https://libfive.com/studio/) too which is roughly similar to OpenSCAD but faster to sketch with imo. There was a good discussion here on this topic too if you were interested:... - Source: Hacker News / almost 4 years ago
Massively Parallel Rendering of Complex Closed-Form Implicit Surfaces (2020)
Super cool to see Matthew's library as well: https://libfive.com/studio/. - Source: Hacker News / about 4 years ago

BRL-CAD mentions (13)

What is a Good Next Step After to Learn C in More Depth After CS50?
If computer graphics is of interest, BRL-CAD (https://brlcad.org) is very welcoming to new contributors and has lots of projects you could take on. Source: about 2 years ago
GPT4 hallucinating a FTP server at ftp.disney.com
Mike Muuss[0] approves of this message. 0: https://brlcad.org/. - Source: Hacker News / about 2 years ago
Best way/book to learn C, for a rookie like me
Join an open source community that is welcoming to newcomers (e.g., BRL-CAD, Haiku OS, OSGeo, ..) and work on a little bit of code every day. It can be a simple feature, specific bug, or something new you want to achieve. Many open source groups are very welcoming to newcomers if you do the work and ask smart questions. Source: about 2 years ago
Windows / MacOS - Home/garden design
You could also try out free AutoCAD alternatives like libreCAD (2D), or brlCAD (2D&3D, I believe). Source: over 2 years ago
Free 3D design software??? Hey friends! I am building a couple of custom sized cabinets with shaker style doors. Are there any free design design software applications that can render in 3D that isn’t too difficult to use? Any info will be so appreciated! Thanks!!
So, uh ... Learning curve. If you want anything and everything under the sun, go with BRL-CAD. It was designed for ballistics testing and simulation, but it can do pretty much anything. The learning curve for BRL-CAD is immense. Otherwise, I recommend OpenSCAD. Source: over 2 years ago