IconsExtract VS Microangelo Toolset

Extract icons and cursors stored in EXE, DLL, OCX, CPL files

Create Vista icons with Toolset's Icon Editor.

Freeware
IconsExtract is available for free, making it accessible to a wide range of users without any cost barrier.
Lightweight
The application is small in size, ensuring that it doesn't take up much space on your device and is quick to download.
Portable
Does not require installation, allowing users to run it directly from any location or even from a USB drive.
Ease of Use
Offers a straightforward interface that makes it easy for users to extract icons and cursors from files and folders.
Comprehensive Extraction
Can extract icons and cursors from a variety of file types including .EXE, .DLL, .OCX, .CPL, and .ICO.
Batch Processing
Supports batch extraction, enabling users to extract multiple icons simultaneously, which saves time and effort.

Limited to Windows
IconsExtract is only available for Windows operating systems, which restricts its usability on other platforms like macOS or Linux.
Basic Interface
The user interface is quite basic and may not appeal to users looking for a modern or sophisticated UI experience.
Lack of Updates
The software may not receive frequent updates or new features, and there is a risk it could become outdated over time.
No Direct Editing
It allows for extraction of icons but does not provide options to edit icons directly within the application.
Privacy Concerns
Being developed by a third-party company, there could be potential privacy concerns, especially if used in business environments.

Comprehensive Icon Editor
The suite offers a robust set of tools for creating and editing icons, including pixel-level editing and true color support.
Multiple File Format Support
Microangelo Toolset supports a variety of icon file formats, allowing easy import and export of different types of icons.
User-Friendly Interface
The graphical user interface is intuitive and easy to navigate, making it accessible for both beginners and advanced users.
Library Management
The toolset includes features for organizing and managing icon libraries efficiently, which is helpful for users handling a large number of icons.
Compatibility
It is fully compatible with multiple versions of Windows, ensuring that users can create or edit icons for any Windows platform.

Windows-Only Platform
Microangelo Toolset is designed specifically for Windows, which limits usability for users on other operating systems like MacOS or Linux.
Limited Animation Features
While it provides basic animation capabilities, users seeking advanced animated icon design may find the tools lacking.
Cost
The software is not free, which may be a limitation for hobbyists or users with a restrained budget.
Learning Curve
Although the interface is user-friendly, mastering all the features and tools may take some time for new users.
Occasional Stability Issues
Some users report occasional crashes or performance lags, especially when handling very large icon libraries.