Software Alternatives & Reviews

Gumroad VS Big Cartel

Compare Gumroad VS Big Cartel and see what are their differences

Gumroad logo Gumroad

An all-in-one solution to sell your work and grow your audience.

Big Cartel logo Big Cartel

Big Cartel is home to hundreds of thousands of clothing designers, bands, record labels, jewelry makers, crafters, and other artists.
  • Gumroad Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-04-24
  • Big Cartel Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-10-17

Gumroad videos

Gumroad Review & Tutorial: Should You Use it To Sell Your Products in 2019?

More videos:

  • Review - Gumroad Review - What It Is, Who It's For And How Much It Costs.
  • Review - Why you should sell on gumroad

Big Cartel videos

How I Package & Ship Orders | Big Cartel vs Shopify pt 1

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to Gumroad and Big Cartel)
eCommerce
80 80%
20% 20
eCommerce Platform
74 74%
26% 26
eCommerce Tools
100 100%
0% 0
Online Marketplace
0 0%
100% 100

User comments

Share your experience with using Gumroad and Big Cartel. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

Reviews

These are some of the external sources and on-site user reviews we've used to compare Gumroad and Big Cartel

Gumroad Reviews

8 Best Patreon Alternatives for Creators (2023)
Gumroad is a digital platform for artists to sell and distribute their products directly to their fans. Artists can create digital products such as e-books, music, videos, or works of art and set a price for them. And takes a small commission on each sale.
Source: talkbitz.com
Top 14 Gumroad Alternatives To Sell Digital Downloads!
As a creator, you know the importance of finding the right platform to sell your digital goods online. Gumroad has long been a popular choice, but the recent news that it has increased its price by over 300% has upset many creators. Gumroad will now charge a flat 10% platform fee for all its creators, plus an additional transaction fee between 3 -7% for payment processing....
Source: checkya.com
9 Gumroad Alternatives to help you get started asap
But the intangible point that is being missed is - These high volume sellers were the primary word of month for Gumroad and drove many users. Now Gumroad will miss that if they just make this move from revenue calculations. But I get it, its not a charity and it's a business. But for the love of Gumroad, it still hurts creators :)
11 Patreon Alternatives for Audience Monetization in 2023
Sell all of your products on your Gumroad page and add a Gumroad button to your own website.
Source: www.uscreen.tv
12+ Brilliant Patreon Alternatives to Monetize Your Audience
Gumroad is an e-commerce tool for content creators selling books, courses, music, and film.

Big Cartel Reviews

Top Platforms to build Ecommerce Website without Coding in 2023
Nevertheless, Big Cartel offers a wealth of helpful guides on how to use the platform and get the most out of it. Affordable plans starting at $9.99 and $19.99 are available from Big Cartel. There are three plans available on the platform: Gold, Platinum, and Diamond.
Source: qpe.co.in
Best Wix alternatives if You are not Satisfied with Wix (2023)
Big Cartel is a simple platform that is simple to use for non-programmers. It provides every tool required to open your store. You may also construct a custom shop on the website where you can display a selection of items. Big cartel provides excellent capabilities for tracking shipments, simple-to-use tools for analyzing data, and highly comprehensive websites. Big Cartel...
Source: qpe.co.in
How to Sell Art Online and Make Money From Home
Big Cartel has pricing ranging from free to $29.99 per month. The cool thing is that it’s a flat fee, and they don’t take a percentage of your sales. This one is definitely worth checking out if you’re looking to make money from your art.
The best Etsy alternatives for selling your crafts
Big Cartel is geared specifically toward creatives and even has a limited but usable free plan. It doesn’t offer a central marketplace like Etsy does, but it does provide services to help crafters develop an online store on their own site. Note that it doesn’t include arrangements for credit card or other payments; that you will have to arrange yourself via Stripe, PayPal or...
15 Best Etsy Alternatives for Crafty Entrepreneurs in 2022
Big Cartel has plenty of customizable website templates to choose from, meaning that you won’t need to build your online store from scratch. Big Cartel also allows you to use a custom domain for your store, making it easier to look professional and trustworthy to potential customers.
Source: zyro.com

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, Gumroad seems to be a lot more popular than Big Cartel. While we know about 109 links to Gumroad, we've tracked only 7 mentions of Big Cartel. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

Gumroad mentions (109)

  • Ask HN: Best way to sell $1 digital product?
    Not used it myself but https://gumroad.com springs to mind. - Source: Hacker News / 2 months ago
  • Bandcamp support is faltering – maybe you should download your music now
    I'm yet to try https://gumroad.com/ but have seen some producers move to after attracting copyright complaints on Bandcamp. - Source: Hacker News / 5 months ago
  • 20 ways for Developers to boost income 💰
    Monetize your expertise by creating and selling digital products. Platforms like Gumroad, Teachable, and Udemy provide avenues for sharing your knowledge. - Source: dev.to / 5 months ago
  • Has anyone used a fluid-type scale in their application?
    I've fallen in love with the way gumroad.com handles their scaling on the website based on the browser width and my goal is to mimic that. Source: 6 months ago
  • Safari Displaying Website Incorrectly. How to Fix It?
    A really bizarre thing happened to me yesterday. Safari stopped loading gumroad's product editor. The website works correctly, however whenever I try to edit product it only displays background color and a horizontal line. It's been working for months without any issues until yesterday. I haven't changed anything about my setup (MBP16 2021 Monterey 12.2.1, Safari 15.3) both software and hardware wise. I've tried... Source: 8 months ago
View more

Big Cartel mentions (7)

  • A man offers you $10,000 USD if you deliver fake cocaine to the cartel and promises lifetime protection if you succeed. Do you take this offer?
    Yep. I would get a bag of flour, put a sticky note on it that says “Cocaine” w/ a QR code to this video. Then deliver it to big cartel’s offices. Source: 10 months ago
  • GoDaddy VS Squarespace
    If you only sell a handful of products I can recommend using the free version of bigcartel.com. It's specifically made for selling arts and crafts, trinklets, etc. You can even set up a free custom domain on the free plan. Source: about 1 year ago
  • my shop is on strike, but I've been thinking of leaving Etsy for awhile. Anyone have any alternatives?
    I don't think there's any marketplaces for handmade products (apart from Amazon Handmade) but if you want to have a shopping cart I recommend Big Cartel. It's remotely hosted (not self hosted) and it's designed for unsigned and independent creators (rather than department stores with thousands of products and categories). Yhey are targeting the lower-tier merchants rather than the middle tier and upper tier. It's... Source: about 2 years ago
  • Looking for website suggestions for a boutique.
    If you haven't already I recommend you check out bigcartel.com (not affiliated in any way). They're pretty easy to setup in my experience and their target audience is exactly those selling shirts, arts, and crafts etc. Source: about 2 years ago
  • What's an easy to use website builder that would let me start selling prints?
    You might look into Saatchiart.com and bigcartel.com; both sites where you can sell prints, but don't need to build your own web page. Source: over 2 years ago
View more

What are some alternatives?

When comparing Gumroad and Big Cartel, you can also consider the following products

Payhip - Sell digital downloads, courses, coaching, and more from one simple platform.

Shopify - Shopify is a powerful ecommerce platform that includes everything you need to create an online store and sell online. Try it free for 14 days.

Sellfy - Sellfy is an easy to use but powerful e-commerce platform where you can sell digital, print on demand or subscription products. Use a Sellfy storefront to create a beautiful online store or embed a Sellfy shopping cart to your own website.

OpenCart - A free shopping cart system. OpenCart is an open source PHP-based online e-commerce solution.s

WooCommerce - A freely available eCommerce plugin that enables shop facilities on your WordPress website. Functionality enabling extensions & beautiful themes available.

Podia - Podia is your all-in-one digital storefront. The easiest way to sell online courses, memberships and downloads, no technical skills required. Try it free!