GUI Debian Package Maker VS Makeself

A Debian package builder based on Debian Package Maker (http://debianpackagemaker.blogspot.com).

makeself.sh is a small shell script that generates a self-extractable tar.

Not present

User-Friendly Interface
The GUI provides a user-friendly interface that simplifies the Debian package creation process, making it accessible to users who may not be familiar with command-line tools.
Efficiency
Speeds up the package creation process by providing a graphical interface that guides users through each step, reducing the likelihood of errors.
Accessibility
Eliminates the need for deep technical knowledge or experience with Debian packaging, allowing more users to create packages.
Visual Guidance
Offers visual cues and tools that make the process of setting package parameters and dependencies more straightforward.

Limited Features
May not offer as many advanced features or customizability as command-line tools, limiting its usefulness for complex package requirements.
Dependency on SourceForge
Requires access to SourceForge for downloads and updates, which might not be as convenient as other distribution channels.
Potential for Obsolescence
GUI tools sometimes lag in updates compared to command-line tools, which may result in compatibility issues with newer Debian policies or systems.
Less Flexible
Could restrict users to a set workflow, reducing the flexibility to introduce custom scripts or modifications tailored for specific packaging needs.

Portability
Makeself generates self-extracting archives that are shell script-based, ensuring compatibility across different Linux and UNIX systems without requiring additional software.
Ease of Use
Creating self-extracting archives is straightforward, using simple command-line instructions to bundle files into a single executable.
Customization
Allows scripts to be executed before or after extraction, providing flexibility to define custom installation or setup processes.
Compression Support
Supports various compression methods (gzip, bzip2, xz) to reduce the size of the archive, optimizing storage and transfer.
No Dependencies
Does not introduce runtime dependencies, as it relies on standard shell scripting and common Unix tools available on most systems.

Security Risks
Self-extracting archives can potentially execute harmful scripts if tampered with, posing a security risk if distributed unchecked.
Limited to Command Line
Operates entirely through the command line, which might be less accessible to users who prefer GUI-based tools for creating archives.
Lack of Advanced Features
Lacks some advanced features found in other packaging tools, such as dependency resolution, automatic updates, or integrated uninstall options.
Platform Limits
Primarily designed for UNIX-like systems, which means native Windows support is not available without additional compatibility layers.
Not Ideal for Large Software
Might not be suitable for packaging complex applications that require detailed installation processes or dependency management.