Software Alternatives, Accelerators & Startups

Discourse VS Simple Machines Forum

Compare Discourse VS Simple Machines Forum and see what are their differences

Discourse logo Discourse

Discourse is an open source discussion platform built for the next decade of the Internet.

Simple Machines Forum logo Simple Machines Forum

Simple Machines offers free open source software such as SMF, the powerful and easy to use community forum written in PHP. Start interesting discussions on your website!
  • Discourse Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-06-13
  • Simple Machines Forum Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-10-14

Discourse features and specs

  • Modern Interface
    Discourse provides a clean, intuitive, and responsive user interface that works well on both desktops and mobile devices.
  • Open Source
    Discourse is open source software, allowing for customization, self-hosting, and community contributions, which can reduce costs and increase flexibility.
  • Rich Features
    The platform includes a variety of built-in features such as threaded replies, real-time notifications, and community moderation tools.
  • Scalability
    Discourse is designed to handle small communities as well as large, active forums, making it suitable for a variety of use cases.
  • Security
    Regular updates and a dedicated security team help keep the software secure against vulnerabilities.
  • Integration and APIs
    Discourse offers extensive APIs and integrates well with various other services and plugins, facilitating seamless extensions and automation.

Possible disadvantages of Discourse

  • Resource Intensive
    Discourse can be resource-heavy, which may require significant server capacity and maintenance, especially for large communities.
  • Hosting Costs
    While you can self-host Discourse, the server and maintenance costs can be high. Managed hosting plans provided by Discourse can also be expensive.
  • Complex Setup
    Installing and configuring Discourse can be complex, particularly for those without technical expertise in server management and Ruby on Rails.
  • Learning Curve
    Users and administrators might face a steeper learning curve compared to more traditional forum software due to its modern interface and extensive features.
  • Limited Built-in Themes
    The default theme options are somewhat limited, and extensive customization requires knowledge of front-end development.
  • Dependency on PostgreSQL and Redis
    Discourse relies on PostgreSQL for its database and Redis for caching, which might complicate setup and maintenance compared to solutions that use simpler database architectures.

Simple Machines Forum features and specs

  • Free and Open Source
    Simple Machines Forum (SMF) is freely available and its source code is open for anyone to inspect, modify, and improve. This allows high customization and community-driven enhancements.
  • Feature-Rich
    SMF provides a wide range of features out of the box, including user management, moderation tools, private messaging, and advanced permissions.
  • Community Support
    SMF has a strong and active user community that provides support, themes, and plugins. This can be particularly helpful for troubleshooting and extending the forum's functionality.
  • Customizability
    The forum is highly customizable, allowing users to change the look and feel with themes, as well as add new functionalities with plugins.
  • Performance
    SMF is designed to be lightweight and fast, which ensures good performance even with high traffic.

Possible disadvantages of Simple Machines Forum

  • Complexity for Beginners
    SMF can be difficult for beginners to set up and configure, especially those without prior experience in managing web servers or databases.
  • Limited Modern Features
    While feature-rich, SMF may lack some modern features found in newer forum software, such as real-time notifications or advanced integrations with other platforms.
  • Security Concerns
    Open source software can be a double-edged sword: while it benefits from community scrutiny, it is also publicly available for malicious actors to study and exploit potential vulnerabilities.
  • Maintenance
    Running an SMF forum requires regular updates and maintenance to ensure security and functionality. This can be time-consuming and may require technical skills.
  • Design Limitations
    Even though SMF is customizable, the default themes and layouts may feel outdated compared to more modern forum platforms, which might require additional effort to modernize.

Discourse videos

Why We Chose The Discourse Platform For Our Forums

More videos:

  • Review - Why Discourse is the Best Forum Software Out There (No, Really) | Location Rebel
  • Review - A Grammar Review for Discourse Analysis

Simple Machines Forum videos

Forum Tutorials - Simple Machines Forums, Tutorial and Overview

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to Discourse and Simple Machines Forum)
Forums And Forum Software
Forums
82 82%
18% 18
Community Platform
82 82%
18% 18
Social & Communications
100 100%
0% 0

User comments

Share your experience with using Discourse and Simple Machines Forum. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

Reviews

These are some of the external sources and on-site user reviews we've used to compare Discourse and Simple Machines Forum

Discourse Reviews

20 Telegram Alternatives to Chat With in 2024
Discourse is a basic forum function that could be an alternative to Telegram if you want to stick to text discussions. It's pretty analog, missing both video and livestreaming tools. Instead, Discourse is a basic community that lets you organize discussions--it feels a bit like having your own reddit or Quora.
18 Best Discord Alternatives 2020 | Expert Reviews
Discourse comes in a couple of flavours. You can self-host it yourself in which case the software is free, and you simply need to sign up for server space, or you can pay Discourse for a hosted-for-you option, though self-hosting is a lot cheaper the premium option takes care of the technical side.
IndieHackers: Best forum software
I used Flarum when trying to get a community set up for my product (ended up abandoning it to revisit when we have a larger customer base). It worked fairly well and I enjoyed it but it's definitely beta and unless you're fairly tech savvy it's not quite worth the setup / maintenance. Lots of config changes, crashes, huge issues with plugins, and some features missing. I'd...

Simple Machines Forum Reviews

We have no reviews of Simple Machines Forum yet.
Be the first one to post

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, Discourse should be more popular than Simple Machines Forum. It has been mentiond 23 times since March 2021. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

Discourse mentions (23)

  • Qilin: A Starter Project Template For Every Open Source Project
    GitHub Discussions can also be a great place for support as long as these are regularly monitored. Another option along the same lines is Discourse and the Open Source Matrix which is used by quite a few Open Source and community-based projects. - Source: dev.to / about 1 year ago
  • Ask HN: How to run an old-school mailing list?
    A lot of communities use [Discourse ](https://discourse.org). [LPSF](https://forum lpsf.org) migrated to it when Yahoo Groups was discontinued. Some of the advantages are that it's open source, self-hostable, and can be configured to work as both a traditional mailing list and modern forum. - Source: Hacker News / about 1 year ago
  • My Fediverse use – I'm hosting everything myself – PeerTube, Mastodon and Lemmy
    More like https://discourse.org/. You can run it yourself, but I can also just have them ding a credit card every month and not think about it again (I do this for a community). - Source: Hacker News / over 1 year ago
  • Reddit faces content quality concerns after its Great Mod Purge
    Discourse perhaps? I've seen it in use in a few places; it has a modern look and feel to it at least. https://discourse.org/. - Source: Hacker News / over 1 year ago
  • So Long, Twitter and Reddit
    I fully agree with you see my comment here[0] -- I think you may have misread my comment, it says "Discourse" (as in the forum software[1]), not Discord. [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37245220. - Source: Hacker News / over 1 year ago
View more

Simple Machines Forum mentions (4)

  • Just remember forums exist
    Https://simplemachines.org/ This looks nice. Doesn't look like it has tags/flair though. Lots of questions in regards to how it compares to the other options. Source: almost 2 years ago
  • Is there a painless way to set up a forum website on a raspberry pi?
    I've always been a fan of SMF. Install is pretty straight forward. Source: over 2 years ago
  • The Platformer #25: High-Impact Hacking
    This project, called YaBB — Yet another Bulletin Board (I’ve always been good at naming things) — is pretty much dead. A few months ago the website was still up, but it appears to be down now. Yes, the project was forked into YaBB SE (a direct PHP port), and ultimately evolved into Simple Machines Forum, which still seems to be under development today (and powers Bitcoin Talk — if you’re still into the crypto thing). - Source: dev.to / over 2 years ago
  • Integrating Forums in an android app?
    Is it possible to integrate forums like Simple Machines Forum in an app or any other forum? Or is there any package/plugin that makes it easier to develop it and integrate it with firebase/firestore. Source: over 3 years ago

What are some alternatives?

When comparing Discourse and Simple Machines Forum, you can also consider the following products

Flarum - Flarum is the next-generation forum software that makes online discussion fun. It's simple, fast, and free.

Vanilla Forums - Build an engaging community forum using Vanilla's modern cloud forum software.

XenForo - Intuitive. Social. Engaging. Fast. XenForo brings a fresh outlook to forum software.

phpBB - Raspberry Pi. The Raspberry Pi is a cheap, credit-card sized computer. The official website uses phpBB for their discussion forums. phpBB is not affiliated with nor responsible for any of the sites listed on the showcase.

MyBB - MyBB is a discussion board software that runs on PHP and MySQL

NodeBB - NodeBB Forum Software - A better community platform for the modern web. NodeBB is a next generation forum software that's free and easy to use.