D3wasm VS dhewm3

D3wasm

D3wasm is an experiment to port the id Tech 4 engine (aka. “Doom 3 Engine”) to Emscripten / WebAssembly and WebGL, allowing to run games such as Doom 3 inside modern Web Browsers.

dhewm3

dhewm 3 is a Doom 3 GPL source port, known to work on at least Windows, Linux, macOS and FreeBSD.

Landing page //
2022-02-12

Landing page //
2022-02-12

D3wasm

Website: continuation-labs.com
$ Details: -

Edit details

dhewm3

Website: dhewm3.org
$ Details

Edit details

D3wasm features and specs

Performance Enhancement
D3wasm leverages WebAssembly to achieve near-native performance for Doom 3 in web browsers, significantly improving execution speed compared to traditional JavaScript.
Cross-Platform Compatibility
By using WebAssembly, D3wasm runs Doom 3 in various web browsers without needing platform-specific adjustments, ensuring broader accessibility across different systems.
Security Improvements
Running Doom 3 in a sandboxed WebAssembly environment can enhance security by isolating the game from direct access to the user's operating system.
Modernization
D3wasm modernizes Doom 3 by enabling it to run in contemporary web environments, keeping the classic game accessible and relevant.

Possible disadvantages of D3wasm

Development Complexity
Adapting Doom 3 to run with WebAssembly can introduce significant complexity in development, requiring expertise in both game code and WebAssembly tooling.
Browser Dependency
The performance and capabilities of D3wasm heavily depend on the WebAssembly support in browsers, which can vary and affect the game's consistency.
Resource Intensive
WebAssembly applications, like D3wasm, can be resource-intensive, potentially leading to high memory and CPU usage, affecting lower-end devices.
Debugging Challenges
Debugging WebAssembly applications can be more challenging than traditional web applications due to the binary nature of WebAssembly code.

dhewm3 features and specs

Cross-platform Compatibility
dhewm3 enhances the original Doom 3 by making it compatible with modern operating systems, including Windows, macOS, and Linux, thereby extending its accessibility to a broader range of users.
Active Maintenance
The project is actively maintained, which means it receives updates for bug fixes and performance improvements, ensuring a smoother and more reliable gaming experience.
Open Source
As an open-source project, dhewm3 allows for community contributions, enabling users to modify the code and tailor the game to their preferences, promoting a collaborative development environment.
Modern Enhancements
dhewm3 introduces modern enhancements while preserving the original gameplay, providing a balance between classic Doom 3 experience and contemporary improvements.

Possible disadvantages of dhewm3

Requires Original Game Files
To play Doom 3 using dhewm3, users need the original game files, which adds a dependency on owning or acquiring these assets separately.
Potential Compatibility Issues
Despite its cross-platform claims, dhewm3 might still encounter compatibility issues on certain systems or with specific hardware configurations.
Limited Support for Some Mods
While dhewm3 supports many Doom 3 mods, there might be specific mods that are not fully compatible, limiting the breadth of the modding experience.
Niche Audience
Being a source port of an older game, dhewm3 primarily appeals to enthusiasts and fans of Doom 3, which might not attract a large new audience.

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to D3wasm and dhewm3)

dhewm3

Marketing Platform

53 53%

Marketing Platform

47% 47

Data Dashboard

50 50%

Data Dashboard

50% 50

Games

45 45%

Games

55% 55

Project Management

54 54%

Project Management

46% 46

User comments

Share your experience with using D3wasm and dhewm3. For example, how are they different and which one is better?

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, dhewm3 seems to be more popular. It has been mentiond 11 times since March 2021. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

D3wasm mentions (0)

We have not tracked any mentions of D3wasm yet. Tracking of D3wasm recommendations started around Feb 2022.

dhewm3 mentions (11)

I had no idea Doom 3 is so gosh darned good
I played through it with dhewm3 recently. Really enjoyed it. Source: about 2 years ago
You can play Doom 3 in a web browser
There is a source port of Doom 3 if you want to play it on Linux or macOS. Source: over 2 years ago
What's the best way to play DOOM 3 nowadays?
If you are going to play it on PC, then get the original 2004 release, with the dhewm3 source port since it can get to widescreen easily and is friendlier on modern devices. Source: over 2 years ago
Has anyone installed Doom 3 (original, not BFG Edition or new bundled) from Steam on a Windows 10 system, and then copied it to their .steam folder on Ubuntu 22.04LTS and be able to play it with Wine without Steam?
Why do you want to run old, buggy code through wine when you could use native dhewm3 to play the original (non-BFG) version of doom3 with Bugfixes, OpenAL audio and proper widescreen support? https://dhewm3.org/. Source: over 2 years ago
Which version of Doom 3 is best to play?
For me go for the original Doom 3 + dhewm3 source port since the source port can get to widescreen easily and is friendlier on modern devices. BFG Edition aint that bad but its very easy and lacking other content that the original Doom 3 had (especially ROE) and it has less enemy count. Source: almost 3 years ago