Software Alternatives, Accelerators & Startups

Apache Solr VS Amazon CloudSearch

Compare Apache Solr VS Amazon CloudSearch and see what are their differences

Apache Solr logo Apache Solr

Solr is an open source enterprise search server based on Lucene search library, with XML/HTTP and...

Amazon CloudSearch logo Amazon CloudSearch

Amazon CloudSearch is a fully-managed service in the cloud that makes it easy to set up, manage, and scale a search solution for your website.
  • Apache Solr Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-04-28
  • Amazon CloudSearch Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-03-12

Apache Solr features and specs

  • Scalability
    Apache Solr is highly scalable, capable of handling large amounts of data and numerous queries per second. It supports distributed search and indexing, which allows for horizontal scaling by adding more nodes.
  • Flexibility
    Solr provides flexible schema management, allowing for dynamic field definitions and easy handling of various data types. It supports a variety of search query types and can be customized to meet specific search requirements.
  • Rich Feature Set
    Solr comes with a wealth of features out-of-the-box, including faceted search, result highlighting, multi-index search, and advanced filtering capabilities. It also offers robust analytics and joins support.
  • Community and Documentation
    Being an open-source project, Apache Solr has a strong community and comprehensive documentation, which ensures continuous improvements, updates, and extensive support resources for developers.
  • Integrations
    Solr integrates well with a variety of databases and data sources, and it provides REST-like APIs for ease of integration with other applications. It also has strong support for popular programming languages like Java, Python, and Ruby.
  • Performance
    Solr is built on top of Apache Lucene, which provides high performance for searching and indexing. It is optimized for speed and can handle rapid data ingestion and real-time indexing.

Possible disadvantages of Apache Solr

  • Complexity
    The initial setup and configuration of Apache Solr can be complex, particularly for those not already familiar with search engines and indexing concepts. Managing a distributed Solr installation also requires considerable expertise.
  • Resource Intensive
    Running Solr, especially for large datasets, can be resource-intensive in terms of both memory and CPU. It requires careful tuning and adequate hardware to maintain performance.
  • Learning Curve
    The learning curve for Apache Solr can be steep due to its extensive feature set and the complexity of its configuration options. New users may find it challenging to get up to speed quickly.
  • Consistency Issues
    In distributed setups, ensuring data consistency can be challenging, particularly for users unfamiliar with managing clustered environments. There may be delays or issues with synchronizing indexes across multiple nodes.
  • Maintenance
    Ongoing maintenance of a Solr instance, including monitoring, tuning, and scaling, can be labor-intensive. This requires dedicated effort to keep the system running efficiently over time.
  • Limited Real-time Capabilities
    Although Solr provides near real-time indexing, it may not be as effective as some specialized real-time search engines. For applications requiring truly real-time capabilities, additional solutions might be necessary.

Amazon CloudSearch features and specs

  • Easy Setup
    Amazon CloudSearch is designed to be easy to set up and manage. You can quickly configure a search domain, upload data, and begin searching, reducing the time to market for your applications.
  • Scalability
    The service automatically scales resources up and down based on the volume of data and the rate of traffic, ensuring your search application can handle varying loads without manual intervention.
  • Fully Managed
    As a fully managed service, Amazon CloudSearch handles all the heavy lifting associated with maintaining and scaling servers, performing software patches, and monitoring health metrics.
  • Search Features
    Amazon CloudSearch supports multiple search features out-of-the-box, including faceting, highlighting, and autocomplete, providing a rich search experience without requiring custom implementations.
  • Integration with AWS Ecosystem
    It seamlessly integrates with other AWS services like S3, DynamoDB, and Kinesis, making it straightforward to ingest and process data from various sources within your AWS environment.

Possible disadvantages of Amazon CloudSearch

  • Limited Customization
    Compared to other search solutions like Elasticsearch, Amazon CloudSearch offers fewer customization options and advanced features, which might be restrictive for complex search requirements.
  • Cost
    Although pricing can be competitive, the cost can quickly escalate with large datasets and high query volumes, and it may not be as cost-effective as other solutions depending on your usage patterns.
  • Less Community Support
    Amazon CloudSearch has a smaller community and fewer third-party plugins compared to more popular search engines like Elasticsearch, making it harder to find quick solutions and best practices through community support.
  • Performance
    In some scenarios, users have reported that Amazon CloudSearch can be slower in performance compared to other search engines, particularly for complex queries or large datasets.
  • Limited Offline Capabilities
    Because it's a managed service, there's limited control over offline access or local development environments. This can be a hindrance if you need to debug or test changes without affecting the live environment.

Apache Solr videos

Solr Index - Learn about Inverted Indexes and Apache Solr Indexing

More videos:

  • Review - Solr Web Crawl - Crawl Websites and Search in Apache Solr

Amazon CloudSearch videos

Getting Started with Amazon CloudSearch

More videos:

  • Review - Getting Started with Amazon CloudSearch: Product Tour Screencast

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to Apache Solr and Amazon CloudSearch)
Custom Search Engine
80 80%
20% 20
Custom Search
81 81%
19% 19
Search Engine
87 87%
13% 13
Search API
74 74%
26% 26

User comments

Share your experience with using Apache Solr and Amazon CloudSearch. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

Reviews

These are some of the external sources and on-site user reviews we've used to compare Apache Solr and Amazon CloudSearch

Apache Solr Reviews

Top 10 Site Search Software Tools & Plugins for 2022
Apache Solr is optimized to handle high-volume traffic and is easy to scale up or down depending on your changing needs. The near real-time indexing capabilities ensure that your content remains fresh and search results are always relevant and updated. For more advanced customization, Apache Solr boasts extensible plug-in architecture so you can easily plug in index and...
5 Open-Source Search Engines For your Website
Apache Solr is the popular, blazing-fast, open-source enterprise search platform built on Apache Lucene. Solr is a standalone search server with a REST-like API. You can put documents in it (called "indexing") via JSON, XML, CSV, or binary over HTTP. You query it via HTTP GET and receive JSON, XML, CSV, or binary results.
Source: vishnuch.tech
Elasticsearch vs. Solr vs. Sphinx: Best Open Source Search Platform Comparison
Solr is not as quick as Elasticsearch and works best for static data (that does not require frequent changing). The reason is due to caches. In Solr, the caches are global, which means that, when even the slightest change happens in the cache, all indexing demands a refresh. This is usually a time-consuming process. In Elastic, on the other hand, the refreshing is made by...
Source: greenice.net
Algolia Review – A Hosted Search API Reviewed
If you’re not 100% satisfied with Algolia, there are always alternative methods to accomplish similar results, such as Solr (open-source & self-hosted) or ElasticSearch (open-source or hosted). Both of these are built on Apache Lucene, and their search syntax is very similar. Amazon Elasticsearch Service provides a fully managed Elasticsearch service which makes it easy to...
Source: getstream.io

Amazon CloudSearch Reviews

Top 10 Site Search Software Tools & Plugins for 2022
Amazon CloudSearch comes with all the popular search features such as auto-complete, intelligent text processing, custom indexing, and geospatial search. It also supports 34 languages, which makes it an excellent solution for businesses that cater to an international audience or intend to expand globally.
Make Your WordPress Search Powerful with Algolia and 9 others
AWS CloudSearch is scalable and known for its high performance. Pricing is based on the usage and pays as you go.
Source: geekflare.com

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, Apache Solr should be more popular than Amazon CloudSearch. It has been mentiond 19 times since March 2021. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

Apache Solr mentions (19)

  • List of 45 databases in the world
    Solr — Open-source search platform built on Apache Lucene. - Source: dev.to / 10 months ago
  • Considerations for Unicode and Searching
    I want to spend the brunt of this article talking about how to do this in Postgres, partly because it's a little more difficult there. But let me start in Apache Solr, which is where I first worked on these issues. - Source: dev.to / 10 months ago
  • Swirl: An open-source search engine with LLMs and ChatGPT to provide all the answers you need 🌌
    Using the Galaxy UI, knowledge workers can systematically review the best results from all configured services including Apache Solr, ChatGPT, Elastic, OpenSearch, PostgreSQL, Google BigQuery, plus generic HTTP/GET/POST with configurations for premium services like Google's Programmable Search Engine, Miro and Northern Light Research. - Source: dev.to / over 1 year ago
  • Looking for software
    Apache Solr can be used to index and search text-based documents. It supports a wide range of file formats including PDFs, Microsoft Office documents, and plain text files. https://solr.apache.org/. Source: almost 2 years ago
  • 'google-like' search engine for files on my NAS
    If so, then https://solr.apache.org/ can be a solution, though there's a bit of setup involved. Oh yea, you get to write your own "search interface" too which would end up calling solr's api to find stuff. Source: over 2 years ago
View more

Amazon CloudSearch mentions (4)

  • How does a large application's search functionality work? ELI5
    Personally, rather than trying to implement this functionality myself from scratch I would use something like Amazon CloudSearch that supports autocomplete suggestions for things that have been added to it. Source: almost 2 years ago
  • How Should I Build a Search Bar
    TL;DR: Dynamo is "bad" for searching. Use something else ( Elastic, CloudSearch ) if you don't know what you're doing. Source: about 3 years ago
  • Ask HN: Why is search on Amazon so bad?
    Maybe they use:
      https://aws.amazon.com/cloudsearch/
    . - Source: Hacker News / over 3 years ago
  • Options for serverless search?
    There is also Amazon CloudSearch as a managed search service but it does seem kind of abandoned from the looks of its landing page. Source: over 3 years ago

What are some alternatives?

When comparing Apache Solr and Amazon CloudSearch, you can also consider the following products

ElasticSearch - Elasticsearch is an open source, distributed, RESTful search engine.

Algolia - Algolia's Search API makes it easy to deliver a great search experience in your apps & websites. Algolia Search provides hosted full-text, numerical, faceted and geolocalized search.

Typesense - Typo tolerant, delightfully simple, open source search 🔍

Swiftype - The simplest way to add search to your website or application. Sign up for free.

Google Cloud Search - Search across all your company's content in G Suite.

Meilisearch - Ultra relevant, instant, and typo-tolerant full-text search API