Software Alternatives & Reviews

Inkarnate VS Astral Tabletop

Compare Inkarnate VS Astral Tabletop and see what are their differences

Inkarnate logo Inkarnate

A free-form map editor for role-playing games, focusing on overland and continental maps.

Astral Tabletop logo Astral Tabletop

Create, host, and manage your tabletop role-playing games — online or in person
  • Inkarnate Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-03-12
  • Astral Tabletop Landing page
    Landing page //
    2023-09-27

Inkarnate

Categories
  • Maps
  • Game Engine
  • Gaming
  • Mapping And GIS
Website inkarnate.com
Pricing URL-

Astral Tabletop

Categories
  • Game Engine
  • Gaming
  • Online Games
  • Maps
Website astraltabletop.com
Pricing URL Official Astral Tabletop Pricing

Inkarnate videos

Inkarnate Review (2020)

More videos:

  • Review - Wonderdraft - Inkarnate Killer? (map-making app review)
  • Review - Inkarnate - Let's Make a Fantasy Map! (free version)

Astral Tabletop videos

Welcome to Astral

Category Popularity

0-100% (relative to Inkarnate and Astral Tabletop)
Game Engine
71 71%
29% 29
Maps
87 87%
13% 13
Gaming
47 47%
53% 53
Mapping And GIS
100 100%
0% 0

User comments

Share your experience with using Inkarnate and Astral Tabletop. For example, how are they different and which one is better?
Log in or Post with

Reviews

These are some of the external sources and on-site user reviews we've used to compare Inkarnate and Astral Tabletop

Inkarnate Reviews

The Best Map Makers For 2022
There is a free version of Inkarnate but the paid version unlocks a massive library of graphics and is not very expensive— just $25 per year.
10 Best Sites Like Roll20 Alternatives For Tabletop Gaming
Inkarnate also supports fantasy races. A whole of maps is also provided for the ease of the user.

Astral Tabletop Reviews

10 Best Sites Like Roll20 Alternatives For Tabletop Gaming
Astral Tabletop is another virtual tabletop platform. You can play roll-play games and other online games.
Roll20 Alternatives, Similar Games, Apps 2020
Astral Tabletop is an online role-playing stage for hosting and playing games online. Play together online with others and communicate live video or create and organize games like GM using powerful combat and map management tools with easy access to visual effects for the atmosphere.

Social recommendations and mentions

Based on our record, Inkarnate seems to be a lot more popular than Astral Tabletop. While we know about 307 links to Inkarnate, we've tracked only 7 mentions of Astral Tabletop. We are tracking product recommendations and mentions on various public social media platforms and blogs. They can help you identify which product is more popular and what people think of it.

Inkarnate mentions (307)

  • CC0-licensed fantasy map brushes based on historical cartography
    Adding to the other answers, there are also -besides Photoshop, Gimp, etc- specialized tools to draw fantasy maps. The site mentions Wonderdraft [0], but there are a bunch of others though not all of them support using external brushes. Some other tools in this space may be Watabou's tools [1], Azgaar's tools [2], Inkarnate [3], Mapforge [4], or quite a few more which you can find links to in this list [5]. Again:... - Source: Hacker News / 4 months ago
  • [PF2E][FoundryVTT][Saturday][CST-12:30PM][PAID] -|- Experienced GM seeking both new and experienced players! Explore a personalized fantasy world that is slowly changing as the Planes Converge! -|- [3-week trial period at (5$) per session. After that it's just (10$)!][2/5 slots open]
    Two, it incentivizes me to be best I can be, as I can as well as enabling me to more easily afford things like Dungeondraft or Inkarnate to create custom maps or battles for you guys! Also I kinda need more food money lol. Source: 9 months ago
  • Mapping Software
    Inkarnate for pretty, colourful maps. Has free and paid tiers. Source: 10 months ago
  • Temperate rainforest
    Erm. What do you mean? Like a map maker kinda deal that lets you place all the plants + details? Inkarnate allows users to make detailed maps of that extent. Source: 10 months ago
  • Blank Map/Grid Asset
    As a side note - I have been using https://inkarnate.com/ and it has a lot of cool features for making maps. The Portrait or Landscape options with a 10x13 or 13x10 grid is pretty similar to the hero kids grids and prints well on regular letter sized paper. There's also a huge gallery of maps created by others you can browse through for ideas. There's a pretty limited free version to play around with but if you're... Source: 10 months ago
View more

Astral Tabletop mentions (7)

  • Roll20 Sheet for Trinity Continuum?
    The closest I've found to a useable Trinity sheet is on astraltabletop.com where they have the quickstarts pre-configured. The sheets there are pretty primitive and irksome to use, though. Source: over 2 years ago
  • GM'ing Online - How do I avoid feeling like I'm building an automated game?
    I have a few recommendations based on your concerns. Find a VTT that fits your playstyle. Let the players keep their own character sheets. Have everyone roll real dice. Only use a VTT for sharing maps and placing tokens. owlbear.rodeo or astraltabletop.com have clean, simple interfaces. With a little practice, you can draw maps using owlbear as if you were in person. It has no automation so you don't need... Source: over 2 years ago
  • Want a break from your Main Campaign ? PRISON BREAK INSANITY is a Free 5th level Adventure Full of clockwork monsters, chase sequences and an intense dungeon crawl
    I'd recommend putting it up on Astral as well. Source: over 2 years ago
  • Looking at new virtual tabletop to migrate away from roll20, any recommendations?
    Check out Astral Tabletop https://astraltabletop.com. It's like a much more modern Roll20 in active development. Source: almost 3 years ago
  • Which form of online playing do you prefer, and why?
    Astral Tabletop https://astraltabletop.com currently has my attention. A free account is somewhat limited, and I can imagine you may need to only have uploaded whatever assets you need for the next session due to space limitations, but it's easier to use and way more pretty than anything else I've tried. Source: almost 3 years ago
View more

What are some alternatives?

When comparing Inkarnate and Astral Tabletop, you can also consider the following products

Dungeon Scrawl - A dungeon scrawling tool by ProbableTrain

Roll20 - Roll20 is a suite of easy-to-use digital tools that expand pen-and-paper gameplay.

donjon.bin.sh - Freely accessible online collection of random generators for tabletop games.

Fantasy Grounds - Fantasy Grounds is a virtual tabletop to help facilitate play of tabletop-style role-playing games...

Campaign Cartographer - Campaign Cartographer is the leading map making software for games (RPGs, miniatures and wargaming).

MapTool - MapTool is a 100% community driven and 100% free to use online, multiuser, networked, graphical, interactive, programmable virtual tabletop.